190 likes | 347 Views
A Meta-Analytic Examination of Assumed Properties of Child Sexual Abuse Using College Samples. Conducted by: Rind, Bruce, Tromovitch, Philip, Bauserman, Robert Presented by: Katie Hochella, Radford University. Purpose. Find if CSA and adjustment correlated
E N D
A Meta-Analytic Examination of Assumed Properties of Child Sexual Abuse Using College Samples Conducted by: Rind, Bruce, Tromovitch, Philip, Bauserman, Robert Presented by: Katie Hochella, Radford University
Purpose • Find if CSA and adjustment correlated • CSA and adjustment attributable to family environment • Relationship between family environment and adjustment
Issues to Consider • How CSA is measured • Exhibitionism • Fondling • Oral Sex • Intercourse • How adjustment is measured • Intensity • Pervasiveness • Causality • Gender Equivalence
Definition of CSA • Sexual interaction involving either physical contact or no contact (e.g. exhibitionism) between either a child or adolescent and someone significantly older, or between two peers who are children or adolescents when coercion is used.
Literature Review • 1966-1995 • Methods • Psyc LIT (1974-1995) • Sociofile (1974-1995) • PsycINFO (1967-1995) • Dissertation Abstract International (up to 1995) • ERIC (1966-1995) • Reference Lists • Unpublished master’s theses and dissertations
Literature Review Cont’d • Studies • 191 articles were found • 59 were useable • These included 70 samples total • Effect Sizes • 15,824 participants • 3,254 men (18 samples) • 12,570 women (40 samples) • No differentiation (1 study) • Key Terms • Adjustment or effect(s) • College or undergraduates • Sex Abuse or sexual abuse or child and adult and sexual
Studies to Include • Qualitative and quantitative data • Control group with no history of CSA • Distinct CSA, no other types of abuse • Described at least one of the 18 symptoms • Sufficient data to compute effect sizes • College students only • If others included, must have been separated
Potential Moderators • Duration • Frequency • Force • Incest • Penetration
Adjustment Measures • Intensity • Consent (Wanted vs. Unwanted) • Pervasiveness • View on encounter (+, \, -) • Causality • Are symptom relations causal in nature or family related • Gender • Did CSA effect males and females differently
Critiques • Some results were significant, but not largely so • Falsely gives a harmless impression of CSA • Years included in study • “Believe the Child” campaign • Population studied • Definition of Abuse