Exploring Multiverse Hypotheses in Physics Courses
E N D
Presentation Transcript
Multiverses by Robert Nemiroff Michigan Tech
Physics X: About This Course • Officially "Extraordinary Concepts in Physics" • Being taught for credit at Michigan Tech • Light on math, heavy on concepts • Anyone anywhere is welcome • No textbook required • Wikipedia, web links, and lectures only • Find all the lectures with Google at: • "Starship Asterisk" then "Physics X" • http://bb.nightskylive.net/asterisk/viewforum.php?f=39
Multiverse Hypotheses Initial idea from H. Everett. Expanded by M. Tegmark: • Level 1: Beyond our observable universe • standard general relativistic universe • open universe with infinite volume • universe "started" with infinite volume • expanded by inflation • physical laws and constants are the same • everywhere • at all times • identical volume 10^10^115 meters away
Multiverse Hypotheses • Level 1: Beyond our observable universe: • there are infinitely many exact replicas of you reading an exact replica of this slide, right now. • there are also infinitely many nearly exact replicas of you doing something slightly different, progressing toward a different future
Multiverse Hypotheses • Level II: Universes with different physical constants • Chaotic inflationary epochs (for example) may create universe bubbles were different rules hold. • Some bubbles are "Level 1" bubbles like our own. • Cyclic Universes (Wheeler): Closed universes may "bounce" with different bubbles formed each bounce • Fecund Universes (Smolin): black hole collapse causes new universe to form "inside" • universes that produce black holes proliferate
Multiple Histories Feynman suggested that when a particle moves from A to B, it takes EVERY POSSIBLE PATH. Each path is assigned an "amplitude", which is related to a probability. These amplitudes will interfere, however, and only those paths with the greatest constructive interference at the end will result in the most probable endpoints to see in nature.
Multiverse Hypotheses • Level III: Universe Offshoots from Many Worlds Interpretation of QM • every time a quantum measurement is made, every possible outcome of that measurement creates a parallel universe where that measurement occurs • these universes do not interact • similar to Feynman's multiple histories
Multiverse Hypotheses • Level III differs from Level 1 because • Level 1 twins reside far across 3D space in time and space. • theoretically a single photon could pass you and your twin. • Level III twins reside in a disconnected physical reality • theoretically, a single photon could NOT pass you and your twin.
Multiverse Hypotheses • Level IV: Ultimate Ensemble • All universes that can be theoretically defined • all space-time for ... • different constants • different measurements • differences that humans can't imagine • So general that there cannot be a Level V
Multiverse Hypotheses Criticisms: Most multiverse hypotheses are not falsifiable. There is no present practical test that can indicate clearly which one is correct, if any. • Multiverse theorists are very sensitive to this criticism and are constantly trying to find falsifiable claims. Multiverse hypthoses are needlessly complex -- hence they violate Occam's Razor. • Entire Multiverse theory might be simpler than any alternative.