1 / 10

Japan

Japan. Souichirou Kozuka Sophia University, Tokyo. Franchising in Japan. 1200+ franchisors, 235.000 outlets JFA member: 254 franchisors Sales 20.3 trillion yen (203 billion Euros) Two types of networks Convenience stores: individual franchisees, strong control by the franchisor

toshi
Download Presentation

Japan

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Japan Souichirou Kozuka Sophia University, Tokyo JAPAN - Souichirou Kozuka

  2. Franchising in Japan • 1200+ franchisors, 235.000 outlets • JFA member: 254 franchisors • Sales 20.3 trillion yen (203 billion Euros) • Two types of networks • Convenience stores: individual franchisees, strong control by the franchisor • Restaurants: large franchisees, often joining more than one chain JAPAN - Souichirou Kozuka

  3. Franchising legislation in Japan • Medium-small Retail Business Promotion Act (MSBRP): disclosure law • Disclosure items provided by Ministerial Order: Main points of the franchise agreement plus information about the franchisor • Applicable only to retail franchising • Protection of SMEs – applicable when half of the franchisees are SMEs JAPAN - Souichirou Kozuka

  4. Competition law: JFTC Guidelines • JFTC Guidelines of 2002 serves as the second franchising legislation • Disclosure + some relationship regulations • Open list of disclosure items • Abuse of dominant position; tie-in; retail price maintenance • Applicable to all kinds of franchising • Cease and desist order, injunction by parties JAPAN - Souichirou Kozuka

  5. Self-regulation • Disclosure format by Japan Franchise Association (JFA) • Satisfying both MSBRP and JFTC Guidelines • Mandatory on all members (expanding the scope of legislative regulation) JAPAN - Souichirou Kozuka

  6. Nature of franchise agreement • SC 4 July 2008 • “Open account” in a franchise agreement of convenience stores • Nature of that part of the agreement: mandate (franchisee mandates franchisor to carry out accounting and settlement) • Duty of reporting derived from the Civil Code • Disclosure of payment details ordered JAPAN - Souichirou Kozuka

  7. Interpretation of franchise agreement • SC 11 June 2007 • Calculation of franchise fee under a franchise agreement for a convenience store • Whether the purchase price for goods disposed of by the franchisee is included in “sales” • Definition in the manual prevailed • Textual interpretation – consistent with SC 2008 (requalification by the Court)? JAPAN - Souichirou Kozuka

  8. Termination of franchise agreement • Usually definite term is provided • General rules for a continuing contracts: grave reason is required for termination?(no SC case but lower courts tend to affirm) • Tokyo DC 25 Jan. 2005: failure to provide deposit plus repeated delay in payment of royalties found to have destroyed relationship • No right of indemnity JAPAN - Souichirou Kozuka

  9. Practical tip for termination • Tokyo DC 21 Feb. 2006 • Repeated failure to pay royalties, unreported borrowing from a nonbank with high interest rate, substandard quality of service • Warning, followed by suspension upon MOU three times (for three years) • Termination justified as relationship found to have been destroyed, no abuse affirmed JAPAN - Souichirou Kozuka

  10. Case law on disclosure • Application of disclosure law (MSRBP) does not preclude the development of case law • Duty of franchisor to provide accurate information before concluding an agreement • Earnings claim: not included in the disclosure items under MSRBP but often disputed later • Unreasonable assessment makes the franchisor liable (eg CA Fukuoka 31 Jan. 2006) JAPAN - Souichirou Kozuka

More Related