1 / 29

Ivory Tower Blues: Confronting the Critics

Ivory Tower Blues: Confronting the Critics. The Argument: Massive disengagement + High grade inflation = Crisis The critics. The benefits of a university education. Monetary 10-30% annual rate of return $1,000,000 over lifetime (average) Non-monetary Liberalism & technical skills

tori
Download Presentation

Ivory Tower Blues: Confronting the Critics

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Ivory Tower Blues:Confronting the Critics • The Argument: • Massive disengagement + • High grade inflation = Crisis • The critics

  2. The benefits of a university education • Monetary • 10-30% annual rate of return • $1,000,000 over lifetime (average) • Non-monetary • Liberalism & technical skills • Long-term career success • Humanities vs. Applied Degrees • Citizenship roles, intellectual growth, and a broad awareness of the world?

  3. Are these benefits in jeopardy? • Education vs. training? • Critical analysis of arguments and the ability to communication ideas • Vs. Memorization of facts and procedures • … grading practices: • Education - critical and reflexive • improvement is always possible; reference point is the unknown limit of the human intellect; perfection is unattainable • Training - passive, descriptive, regurgitative • meeting expectations regarding procedures and information retention; 100% possible

  4. DISENGAGEMENT + GRADE INFLATION = ? • Disengagement is at historically high levels • Grade inflation is at historically high levels • the combination = a crisis for • Students (and parents) • Professors • The system

  5. The slow boil of grade inflation and disengagement: It is time to pay attention

  6. Crisis for students • Personal debt for a BA-lite • Less skill acquisition • Underemployment • “Degree purchasing” • Less learning for self • More disruption for other students • Alienation from learning • Entitlement for grades with little effort • Not “in the moment” • Increasing stress levels

  7. Crisis for faculty • Disengagement compact • alienation from teaching/mentoring • Adversarial encounters over grades • 22% on stress-reducing medications • 22% report physical health issues • 13% experience clinical levels of distress • Job satisfaction/cynicism • Recruitment? • Early retirement?

  8. Crisis for the system • Loss of: • Function • Sorting and credentialing • Push toward vocationalism • Credibility • Employers and professional schools • Respect • Public • Profscam / The Great Training Robbery

  9. Reviews of the book • Cacophony of contradictory reactions • 1. Total support with how we handled it • 2. Support, but we don’t go far enough • 3. Problems exist, but we overstate them or they have always been this bad • 4. Denial that there are any problems • Good reviews tell readers about the book • Vs. grandstanding or rebuttals (Rorschach projections)

  10. THE CRITICS • Crisis, what crisis? • All of these problems exist, but there is no crisis • (Allan Hutchinson, Assoc. Dean, Osgood Law School, Globe & Mail) • Administrators in denial • NSSE • ~10% engaged/~40+ disengaged • 80-90% regularly receive As + Bs

  11. European Credit Transfer System (ECTS) for all passing grades • A – 10% ~ EXCELLENT - outstanding performance with only minor errors • B – 25% ~ VERY GOOD - above the average standard but with some errors • C – 30% ~ GOOD - generally sound work with a number of notable errors • D – 25% ~ SATISFACTORY- fair but with significant shortcomings • E – 10% ~ SUFFICIENT - performance meets the minimum criteria

  12. Mass university education is upon us: Get used to it • We need to adjust to the “diversity” of learning styles of disengaged students • And create a 2-tiered system • (Benedikt Hallgrimsson, Assoc. Dean, Medicine, U. of Calgary, University Affairs) • High schools have tried this and made matters worse • 2-tier? (Mac/Calgary/UBC - élite streams) • The BA-lite for the disengaged masses? • Is it ethical to take their money?

  13. There are no disengagement problems • “All of my students are engaged” • (Rebecca Coulter, Faculty of Education, Western, The Agenda, TV Ontario) • Students at my university aren’t like that • (Heather Munroe-Blum, Principal, McGill University; Cross-Country Check-up, CBC) • “I truly do not believe that [the book] describes our university here at Western” (Paul Davenport, President, Western, Western News)

  14. Increasing disengagement at the university level: US NSSE data Hours per week spent by upper year university students studying, reading, writing, rehearsing, etc. for all classes

  15. … in universities • NSSE: • ~10% fully engaged: treat university as a full-time job • ~ 25+ hours per week (hpw) + classes • ~40% - partially engaged • some preparation for class; some last-minute work on papers; cramming for exams: • ~ 11-20 hpw + classes • ~40-50% - disengaged • little or no preparation for class; little work on papers; little studying for exams: • ~ 0-10 hpw + classes

  16. McMaster NSSE 2006 compared to Ontario universities and US equivalents

  17. It’s always been like this • Students have always been disengaged • David Strong (President, University Canada West, Cross-Country Check-up) • Has higher education been a fraud all along? • Diseng + Inflation is a new situation • A generational change

  18. … always like this? • Children of the wealthy never cared about learning • If so, it didn’t matter to their futures … now it does • Those who are not wealthy deserve a quality education

  19. Embrace grade inflation • Grades have been increasing for a long time • Just recalibrate your assessment to a B average • We are hitting the ceiling • the B will come to be defined as “average” and therefore beneath students • … and we are running out of letters

  20. Types of grade inflation • Higher grades, same standards • Same grades, lower standards (hidden inflation) • Higher grades, lower standards

  21. Impact of grade inflation • Grade conflation • Under-reward excellence • Over-reward mediocrity • Effort disincentive • Less skill development • Less personal transformation

  22. Prolonged youth … grade 13, 14, 15, 16 • University is just a middle class rite of passage now anyway, just like high school was, so why does it matter? • Not necessary if the secondary system were reformed and vocational tracks developed • Why destroy the Liberal Arts for this?

  23. High grades are good for students • Self-esteem • Optimism • Persistence • High grades arefraudulent when given to students who don’t deserve them • False feedback is bad for them, setting them up for failure • System ethics and integrity?

  24. Low grades alienate students • Grades should be used for feedback and assessment, with the goal of helping students discover their strengths and nurture their abilities

  25. There was no Golden Era of education • You are romanticizing the past • We experienced excellent Liberal Arts educations and don’t want this lost for future generations • We want to stop the slide into mediocrity and the destruction of the Liberal Arts

  26. Students have busy lives • The new reality is that students fit university into their lives rather than fitting their lives into university • Should we simply give them a BA-lite? • Aren’t we misleading and cheating them?

  27. Professors are bad teachers • Professors need to be met half-way by students, as part of the “bi-lateral contract” of the Liberal Arts; otherwise, we are but a glorified high school

  28. What legacy will we leave? “Why am I here?”

  29. Ivory Tower Renewal: Best practices in leading universities Follow the debate on • www.ivorytowerblues.com • Thank you for your attention

More Related