1 / 35

Borrower Defense Regulations

Session 16. Borrower Defense Regulations. Barbara Hoblitzell and Annmarie Weisman | Nov-Dec. 2016 U.S. Department of Education 2016 FSA Training Conference for Financial Aid Professionals. ABOUT US. Agenda. Existing Direct Loan BD Regulation New Direct Loan BD Regulation: Federal Standard

tmccary
Download Presentation

Borrower Defense Regulations

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Session 16 Borrower Defense Regulations Barbara Hoblitzell and Annmarie Weisman | Nov-Dec. 2016 U.S. Department of Education 2016 FSA Training Conference for Financial Aid Professionals

  2. ABOUT US Agenda • Existing Direct Loan BD Regulation • New Direct Loan BD Regulation: • Federal Standard • Individual and Group Claims Processes • Financial Responsibility • Disclosure Requirements • Other Regulatory Changes

  3. Existing Direct Loan BD Regulation: 685.206(c) 3

  4. Existing DL BD Regulation • Publishedin 1994 • Included in Promissory Notes

  5. Existing DL BD Regulation In any proceeding to collect on a Direct Loan, a borrower may assert as a defense against repayment an act or omission of the school that gives rise to a cause of action against the school under applicable State law.

  6. Existing DL BD Regulation If a claim is successful, the borrower is relieved of the obligation to repay: • all or part of the loan • associated costs and fees Further relief is possible

  7. Existing DL BD Regulation Examples of possible further relief include: • Reimbursing the borrower for amounts paid toward the loan • Determining that the borrower is not in default on the loan and reinstating Title IV aid eligibility • Updating adverse credit bureau reports

  8. Existing DL BD Regulation Recovery: ED may initiate a proceeding to require the school to repay ED the amount of a discharged loan(s) when the school’s act or omission resulted in asuccessful BD claim • ED does not initiate such a proceeding after the record retention period ends unless the school received actual notice of the claim during that period See 34 CFR 685.206 (c)

  9. New Direct Loan BD Regulations: 685.222 9

  10. New DL BD Regulations • Easier to understand • More accessible; provides access to BD for all Federal student loan borrowers • Facilitates collection and review of evidence for resolving claims • Promotes more efficient, transparent, and fair claims processing

  11. New DL BD Regulations • Access to BD relief for FFEL and Perkins borrowers through Direct Consolidation Loans • FFEL borrowers given the same access to administrative forbearance as DL borrowers during BD claim evaluation • Forbearance and GA stop collection provisions designated for early implementation on Nov. 1, 2016

  12. New DL BD Regulations • Establishes a new Federal standard • Creates processes for individual and group claims • Establishes statutes of limitation for BD claims

  13. New DL BD Regulations • Federal Standard • Favorable, contested judgment based on State or Federal law • Breach of contract • Substantial misrepresentation

  14. New DL BD Regulations • Statutes of Limitation, Generally • For claims for relief from loan balances still owed: • None • For claims for recovery of amounts already paid: • Six years

  15. New DL BD Regulations • Group Discharges • Easier path to relief for borrowers in cases of widespread misrepresentation or other cases affecting multiple borrowers • ED can identify groups of borrowers from individually filed applications or from any other source of information • Can include borrowers who did not file an application when common facts and claims exist

  16. New DL BD Regulations • Schools may not enter into pre-dispute arbitration agreements • Schools may not forbid class actions for borrower defense-type claims. • Schools may not require students to first pursue an internal process before contacting accreditors and regulators about potential violations of the law. • Schools must notify the Secretary when arbitration and judicial claims are filed and the decisions and awards issued in arbitration and in court proceedings.

  17. Regulatory Clarification: Pell Grant Reinstatement 17

  18. Pell Grant Reinstatement • Lifetime Eligibility Used (LEU) • ED restoring semesters of Pell Grant eligibility for students at schools that closed before they completed their program • ED exploring the operational changes required to implement this, but will not require an application

  19. Financial Responsibility 19

  20. Financial Responsibility • Triggers & Early Warnings • Establishes triggering and early-warning events • When significant enough to cause the school to have a failing financial responsibility composite score, automatically requires schools to provide financial protection to ED • Protects taxpayers from shouldering the costs of the school’s liabilities

  21. Financial Responsibility

  22. Financial Responsibility • Financial Protections • Funds from LOCs could be used to cover the costs of closed school discharges and/or BD claims • Triggers tied to the school’s failing composite score standards or past performance

  23. Financial Responsibility • Triggering Events: Automatic • Debts and borrower defense-related lawsuits • Other litigation • Accrediting agency actions • Cohort default rates • Gainful employment • Withdrawal of owner’s equity • 90/10 • SEC actions, SEC reports, Exchange actions

  24. Financial Responsibility • Triggering Events: Discretionary • Any event or condition that is reasonably likely to have a material adverse effect on the institution’s financial condition, business, or results of operations, including but not limited to certain specified discretionary triggers.

  25. Financial Responsibility • Triggering Events: Discretionary • Failing State of agency licensing requirements • Failing financial stress test • High annual drop-out rate • Actions that pose risk to accreditation status • Violation of a loan agreement • Pending BD claims • Anticipated BD claims as a result of a lawsuit, settlement, judgment, or finding from a State or Federal administrative proceeding

  26. Disclosure Requirements 26

  27. Disclosure Requirements • Disclosures of Triggering Events for Financial Protection • ED will consumer test which events, and what form of disclosure, are most relevant and useful to students • Affected schools must provide the disclosure to prospective and enrolled students

  28. Disclosure Requirements • Repayment Rate Warnings for Students • Proprietary institutions with poor loan repayment outcomes must include a warning in their advertising and marketing materials • Repayment rates will be based on GE data • ED will consumer test warning language to ensure it is relevant to students

  29. Other Regulatory Changes 29

  30. Closed School Discharges • Borrowers will receive accurate and complete information regarding their eligibility for a closed school discharge earlier in the process • Borrowers may receive automatic discharges if they do not re-enroll at another school within three years

  31. False Certification • False Certification • Provides for a false certification discharge if the school: • falsified the borrower’s high school graduation status • falsified the borrower’s high school diploma • referred the borrower to a third party to obtain a falsified high school diploma • ED may also discharge without an application when it has evidence that a school falsified a student’s SAP

  32. Resources 32

  33. BD Regulations: Resources • Borrower Defenses to Repayment Rulemaking website: http://www2.ed.gov/policy/highered/reg/hearulemaking/2016/index.html • DCL-GEN-16**

  34. QUESTIONS?

  35. Contact Information Barbara Hoblitzell – Management & Program Analyst Office of Postsecondary Education barbara.hoblitzell@ed.gov 202-453-7583 Annmarie Weisman - Director, Policy Coordination Group Office of Postsecondary Education annmarie.weisman@ed.gov 202-453-6712

More Related