150 likes | 311 Views
Towards defining and accounting for ecosystem services. Spencer Banzhaf. James Boyd. Senior Fellow/Director – Resources for the Future Ph.D. University of Pennsylvania Ecosystem Services, Ecological Benefit Assessment. Professor – Dept of Economics at Georgia State University
E N D
Spencer Banzhaf James Boyd Senior Fellow/Director – Resources for the Future Ph.D. University of Pennsylvania Ecosystem Services, Ecological Benefit Assessment Professor – Dept of Economics at Georgia State University Ph.D. Duke University Environmental Economics
Ecosystem Services are the benefits of nature to households Woodland Trust 2014
Problem Statement: “The development and acceptance of welfare accounting and environmental assessment are hobbled by lack of standardized ecosystem units.” ? ? ?
Green GDP vs. ESI (Ecological Services Index) ESI is the market and non-market ecosystem service values GDP is the market value of all officially recognized final goods and services produced within a country in a year. “Green GDP” = GDP + non-market ecosystem values
Public policy demand for standardized units of ecosystem measurement Excludable Non-excludable Private Good Common Pool Rival Non-rival Club Good Public Good
Final Ecosystem Services: components of nature, directly enjoyed, consumed, or used to yield human well-being (Definable Unit) Ecosystem Service Quantity Value or Price ** Key assumption: social policy goal is to maximize human well being
A = A(M,N) A = commodity M = marketed good N = Non-market Ecological input
Production Theory Perspectives The value can be derived from the input’s productivity times the value of the final commodity: PN = (∂A/∂N)PA Non-market input’s value can be derived from the value of the market input and the substitutability of the market and non-market inputs: PN = (∂A/∂N)/(∂A/∂M)*PM
3 definitions of the measure of non-market service are referenced: • dN (the change in non-market input) • (dA/dN)dN (change in the final commodity) • pNdN (the shadow value of the change)
Critiques • TFP on the market goods side- is there an equivalent on the non-market goods side? • Services vs. goods; pg 620 capital stock as a proxy? • Based on human well-being rather than the intrinsic values of ecosystem integrity • Does this fully motivate society to protect the necessary components of the ecosystem?
Measurement should be focused on the flow of final current services as well as capital depreciation
q = quantity • p = price