The Science of Residency Determinations 2005. Carl N. Friedman Student Support Services NYS Education Department. When his theory was questioned, Einstein replied, only half in jest, “the facts are wrong.” Albert Einstein.
Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.
Carl N. Friedman
Student Support Services
NYS Education Department
When his theory was questioned, Einstein replied, only half in jest, “the facts are wrong.” Albert Einstein
We have to live today by what truth we can get today and be ready tomorrow to call it falsehood. William James
It requires a very unusual mind to make an analysis of the obvious. Alfred North Whitehead
No Child Left Behind – School Choice – SINIs without progress – Persistently Dangerous
Stewart H. McKinney Homeless Assistance Act 42 USC 11431 et. seq.
Education Law 3202 – Entitlement
Education Law 3203 – Property Intersected…
Education Law 3209 – Education of Homeless Children
Education Commissioner’s Regulations
Judicial Decisions of the Commissioner of Education or Court Decisions
Title I Schools that fail to show adequate yearly progress in two consecutive years are considered in need of improvement. Parents may request a transfer to another in-district school. Similarly, victims of a violent criminal offense may also ask for a transfer within the district.
Who At NYSED Can Help?
Stewart H. McKinney Homeless Assistance Act
WHO AT NYSED CAN HELP?
Every school district should have a “Homeless Liaison” who will facilitate hassle-free entrance to school. The law provides that the school allow the registrant into school immediately and then do the appropriate paperwork to determine residency.
The McKinney Act requires the State and the local districts to develop and revise policies to remove barriers to enrollment and retention.
Homeless students have the right to choose the schools
Education Law 3203
Education Law 3209
Educational Entitlement – is afforded to residents of the district over five and under twenty-one years of age who have not received a high school diploma.
Where a body of land is intersected by two school districts and is the location of an owner occupied single family dwelling, the family may choose which district they may send their children.
Defines a homeless person as:
Defines school district choice as the district of origin, current location, or specific accommodations within a BOCES affiliate.
Defines – transportation benefits for persons in receipt of public assistance.
Commissioner of Education
Catlin v. Sobol 4/4/91 Overturned by State Supreme Court and then overturned again by Appellate Court
The Commissioner agreed with the district that the parents moved from the school district thus changing the residency thus the district should no longer have to pay the BOCES for special education services.
Plyer v. Doe – State of Texas passed a statute which prohibited the use of State funds for children who were not citizens of the U.S. Though the case concerned equal protection of the law the court found that the right to a free public education was based upon where a person lives not their alien status.
The beginning of wisdom is the definition of terms.
Socrates (470-399 BC)
Does a record from Family Court attesting to the transfer of care and custody, tell you any more about residency than a birth certificate?
Eyewitness accounts (notarized)
Supportive evidence linked to a place of residence
TO REGISTER A STUDENT?
Adults other than Parents
Two Parent Household
Single Parent with Official Custody
FERPA(Family Education and Rights to Privacy Act)
Family Policy Compliance Office
Child spends equal time living with both parents
For Online Citations:
Go to http://www.nysed.gov
And in the Google Search Engine type in “Commissioner’s Decisions”. You will be brought to a list of possible sites all dealing with Commissioner’s Decisions.
Single Parent With Care But No Official Custody (Gen. Ed.)
Formal custody awarded by Family Court
Witnessed statement from the biological parent(s) and the new adult the minimums for care and custody
Witnessed statement from the biological parent(s) and the new adult
Irrelevant Factors in residency determinations for emancipated youth?
Relevant Factors in registering an emancipated youth?
WHAT ARE SCHOOLS REQUIRED TO DO WHEN THE RESIDENCY DETERMINATION IS NEGATIVE?
Commissioner’s Regulation 100.2(x) – where the board of education or its designee determines that the child is neither a resident nor entitled to attend the schools of the district they must
Instructions for making an appeal to the Commissioner of Education is available at www.counsel.nysed.gov
310 Appeals DETERMINATION IS NEGATIVE?
BOARD OF EDUCATION POLICY CONCERNING NON-RESIDENTS DETERMINATION IS NEGATIVE?
SUMMER SCHOOL DETERMINATION IS NEGATIVE?
SOME WORKING GUIDANCE DETERMINATION IS NEGATIVE?
Comprehensive Attendance Policy DETERMINATION IS NEGATIVE?
School Enrollment Process
Enrollment at School