1 / 16

Temporary Worker Programs: US and other Countries

Temporary Worker Programs: US and other Countries. Philip Martin: plmartin@ucdavis.edu http://migration.ucdavis.edu. Three Topics. TWPs: nothing more permanent than temporary workers US: H-1B, H-2A, H-2B programs

tao
Download Presentation

Temporary Worker Programs: US and other Countries

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Temporary Worker Programs: US and other Countries Philip Martin: plmartin@ucdavis.edu http://migration.ucdavis.edu

  2. Three Topics • TWPs: nothing more permanent than temporary workers • US: H-1B, H-2A, H-2B programs • Other countries: Are TWPs optimal compromise between no borders and no migrants extremes?

  3. TWPs • Purpose: add workers temporarily, not settlers • Experience: Programs get larger and last longer than anticipated • Why: incentives of employers and migrants--distortion and dependence

  4. Distortion and Dependence • Distortion: Employers rely on migrant network for recruitment and training--they lose links to local workers and labor markets • Dependence: Migrants’ lives improve with higher wages; reducing recruitment could increase unauthorized migration

  5. Migration and Development • Sending workers abroad reduces poverty via remittances • Do 3 Rs of recruitment, remittances, and returns speed development? • Virtuous circles between migration and development: Indian IT • Vicious circles: African health care workers • Rural migrants generally do NOT lead to stay-at-home development; instead, more migration--internal or external?

  6. Migration-development Lessons • No automatic link between migration and development • Receiving-country employers are the key decision makers; their preferences may clash with sending-country governments • Rural migrants not likely to return, but investments in their children may speed rural-urban migration

  7. US TWP Programs • H-1B: Foreign professionals fill US jobs that require a college degree; 65,000/year • H-2A: Foreign farm workers; no cap • H-2B: Foreign low-skilled; 66,000/year • At least 12 more, from E-treaty traders to J-exchange visitors to TN-NAFTA professionals

  8. H-1B Professionals • Purpose: Bridge labor market gaps at a time of mis-matches • Trade off: easy employer access but cap of 65,000 a year; reached in 1998 • IT boom, low unemployment, and increase in cap--eventually 195,000/yr • 2004: cap reverts to 65,000/yr

  9. H-1B Issues • Is there effective DOL oversight of employers, especially body brokers? • Are H-1B visa holders the world’s best and brightest? • Why does the S & E labor market resemble a revolving door?

  10. H-2A • Certification program with no cap; 98% of employer requests approved • H-2A = 3% of farm workers; unauthorized = 50% Why? • Recruitment: 5% US referrals, 2% US hires

  11. H-2A and AgJOBS • About 60,000 H-2A workers and 1 million unauthorized • AgJOBS compromise: Legalize the unauthorized, require continued farm work, and make H-2A more employer-friendly • 3 changes: attestation, no housing, AEWR • Canada: different starting point--not 17 unauthorized workers for every H-2A worker

  12. US TWP Issues • Migrants: Temporary visitors (H-2A/B) or probationary immigrants (H-1B)? • Attestation versus certification: trust the employer? • Other TWPs: Caps on H-1B and H-2B prompt employers to use non-DOL administered programs

  13. Other Countries • Estimated 100 million migrant workers and 200 bilateral labor agreements • 3 major questions: how many, from where, in what status? • Hard to obtain agreement on these questions in receiving countries

  14. Europe: 3 Major Trends • From one macro program to many micro programs (shotgun to rifle) • From employment service to employers answering the 3 questions • From getting workers to more goals, from cooperation on unauthorized to promoting development

  15. 3 Lessons for Canada • Include economic mechanisms to deal with distortion and dependence • Include employers and advocates in program design, and give administrators discretion • Be cautious: TWPs tend to get larger and to last longer

  16. Thank You • More information: • http://migration.ucdavis.edu

More Related