1 / 66

TGah MAC Ad Hoc Agenda and Report

TGah MAC Ad Hoc Agenda and Report. Authors:. Date: 2013-16-09. Agenda for September 2013 –Nanjing, China. Call the meeting to order. Designation of a secretary for the minutes. Reminder on Affiliation, IEEE 802 and IEEE 802.11 IPR policies and procedures; call for awareness.

stanislaus-duscha
Download Presentation

TGah MAC Ad Hoc Agenda and Report

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. TGah MAC Ad Hoc Agenda and Report Authors: Date: 2013-16-09 Merlin, Liu, Shao

  2. Agenda for September 2013 –Nanjing, China • Call the meeting to order. • Designation of a secretary for the minutes. • Reminder on Affiliation, IEEE 802 and IEEE 802.11 IPR policies and procedures; call for awareness. • Reminder to record attendance. • Proposed agenda: • Reminder of the Ad-hoc operating rules • Call for submissions for comment resolution • Call for submissions other than for comment resolution • Address submissions for comment resolution • Address submissions not for comment resolution • Adjourn Merlin, Liu, Shao

  3. Secretary Mon PM3: YonghoSeok (LGE) Tue AM1: Alfred Asterjadhi (Qualcomm) Tue PM1: Ron Murias (InterDigital) Wed PM1: Li Chia Choo (Institute for Infocomm Research (I2R)) Tue AM2: Li Chia Choo (Institute for Infocomm Research (I2R)) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  4. Submissions and notes Merlin, Liu, Shao

  5. Interpretive guide • Text coloring: • Black = pending agenda item • Red = item partially addressed • Green = item completed • Gray = item not addressed in the session indicated at the top of the slide Merlin, Liu, Shao

  6. Submissions • (done in TG) 13/1027 CC9-Resolution-CID 3 • Alfred Asterjadhi (Qualcomm Inc.) • No objection. Motion on Wednesday. • (done in TG) 13/1062 CIDs for Speed Frame Exchange • Alfred Asterjadhi (Qualcomm Inc.) • No objection. Motion on Wednesday. • (done in TG) 13/1064 CC9-Resolution-CIDs 808+838+839+840 • Alfred Asterjadhi(Qualcomm Inc.) • No objection. Motion on Wednesday 13/1064r1 • (done in TG) 13/1106 CC9-Resolution-CIDs 112+497+544+545+550+605+606+628+657+846+858 • Alfred Asterjadhi (Qualcomm Inc.) • No objection. Motion on Wednesday 13/1106r1 Merlin, Liu, Shao

  7. Submissions cont. • (done in TG) 13/1033 CIDs 835,836,687,686,779,781,131 • George Calcev (Huawei) • Small edits. • No objection. Will have motion on 13/1033r1 on Wednesday. Merlin, Liu, Shao

  8. Submissions cont. • YonghoSeok (LG Electronics) • (done in TG) 13/1048 clause-9-19-4a-4-comment-resolution • No Objection. Motion on Wednesday • (done in TG) 11-13-1084-00-00ah-CC9-clause-10-43d-comment-resolution • No objection. Motion on Wednesday • (done in TG) 11-13-1085-00-00ah-CC9-clause-8_4_2_170k-comment-resolution • No objection. Motion on Wednesday. • (done in TG) 11-13-1086-00-00ah-CC9-CID-813-816-825-826-886-comment-resolution • Will add more detail on rejection. • No objection. Motion on Wednesday to 13/1086r1 • 11-13-1087-00-00ah-CC9-miscellaneous-comment-resolution • Deferred: • 705, 706 707 709 710, 711 712 713 (se Amin’s Document 891) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  9. Submissions cont. • 13/1072 Resolutions on BSS Max Idle Period • Lin Wang(ZTE Corporation) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  10. Submissions cont. • (done in TG) 13/828 MAC-CID 163 • Bo Sun (ZTE Corp.) • No objection. Motion on Wednesday • (done in TG) 13/881 CC9-GEN-comment-resolutions-CID729+568 • Bo Sun (ZTE Corp.) • Edits for rejection reasons will come in. • No objection. Motion on Wednesday on 13/881r2 • [Deferred] 13/891 CC9-clause-9-32n-3-1-comment resolution • KaiyingLv(ZTE Corp.) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  11. Submissions cont. • 13/1068 CC09 Comment Resolution CID 265 • Betty Zhao (Huawei) • 13/1069 CID 265, 534, 535, 716 and 834 • Betty Zhao (Huawei) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  12. Submissions cont. • James Wang (MediaTek) • 11-13-1098-00-00ah CC9 Resolution of CID201 and 202 • 11-13-1099-00-00ah CC9 Comment Resolution CID 685, 688-694 • 11-13-1101-00-00ah-CC9-Comment Resolution-CID 214-216-217-218-221-260-679-680-824 • 11-13-1102-00-00ah-CC9-Comment-Resolution-CID-335-760-761-762 • 11-13-1103-00-00ah-CC9-Comment-Resolution-CID-213-220 • 11-13-1104-00-00ah-CC9-Comment-Resolution-CID-780-782-to-787 Merlin, Liu, Shao

  13. Submissions cont. • Minho Cheong, MAC submissions to be presented on Wed. • 13/1120 cc9-mac-comment-resolutions-on-sectorization (not I server yet) • CIDs428-429-434 withdrawn via Minho • Minho Cheong, PHY submissions • 13/1049 cc9-phy-comment-resolutions-24.2.2-24.2.3 • 13/1050 cc9-phy-comment-resolutions-24.3.4 • 13/1118 cc9-phy-comment-resolutions-Annex-E Merlin, Liu, Shao

  14. Submissions cont. • 13/984 d01 PHY CID70 • Hongyuan Zhang (Marvell) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  15. Submissions cont. • 13/1026r0 CC9 Comment resolution for CIDs 657, 659 • Ron Murias (InterDigital) • 13/1025r0 CC9 Comment resolution for CIDs 628, 629 • Ron Murias (InterDigital) • 13/1024r0 CC9 Comment Resolution for CIDs 617, 620, 758, 759, 933 • Ron Murias (InterDigital) • 13/1023r0 CC9 Comment Resolution for CID 604 • Ron Murias (InterDigital) • [Documents withdrawn since all were already addressed in other submissions] Merlin, Liu, Shao

  16. Submissions cont. • 11-13-1035-00-00ah-cc9-possible-integration-regarding-cid773&774 • Shusaku Shimada (Schubiquist Technologies Guild) • Strawpoll failed • Shusaku will have a separate submissions to address 773&774 • No plan for further submission on this topic at this meeting • 11-13-1082-00-00ah-cc9-combination-analysis-with-Direct-Link-regarding-cid807 • Shusaku Shimada (Schubiquist Technologies Guild) • [withdrawn, CID alredyresolved in earlier presentation] Merlin, Liu, Shao

  17. Submissions cont. • 11-13-1034-00-00ah-cc9-cids-31 and 592-comment-resolutions • Peter Loc (Huawei) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  18. Submissions cont. • Yuan Zhou (I2R) • 11-13-1093-00-00ah-CC9-Comment-Resolution-CID-86 • 11-13-1094-00-00ah-CC9-Comment-Resolution-CID-362 • 11-13-1095-00-00ah-CC9-Comment-Resolution-CID-717 • 11-13-1096-00-00ah-CC9-Comment-Resolution-CID-471[deferred] Merlin, Liu, Shao

  19. Submissions cont. • 13/1124 CC9-Resolution-CIDs-856 • Shoukang Zheng (I2R) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  20. Submissions cont. • 13/1067 CC9 resolution of CID 219 317 • Liwen Chu (STMicroelectronics) • Withdraw the following comments: 312, 318, 319, 320, 322, 325 • Liwen Chu (STMicroelectronics) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  21. Submissions cont. • 13/1088 coexistence assurance [to be discussed in the TG] • YonghoSeok (LG Electronics) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  22. Submissions cont. • 13/1134 Resolutions to CIDs 41, 150, 350, and 898 • ChittabrataGhosh (Nokia) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  23. Submissions cont. • 13/1138, Comment resolution for annexDCID730 (PHY) • Jianhan Liu (Mediatek) • 13/1136, Comment resolution for clause-8-4-2-170a CID418 and CID903 (MAC) • Jianhan Liu (Mediatek Inc.) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  24. Submissions cont. • Amin Jafarian (Qualcomm) • 13/1141 CC9-Resolution-CIDs-831+542 • 13/1140 CC9-Resolution-CIDs-499+ • 13/1139 CC9-Resolution-CIDs-323+266+416+431+430+91+794+16+517+697+698+795+699 • 13/0981 CC9-Resolution-CIDs-68+445+676+446+447+35+232+674+449+450+451 • 13/0975 CC9-Resolution-CIDs-393+632+631 Merlin, Liu, Shao

  25. Submissions cont. • Matthew Fischer MAC submissions • 11-13-1145-00-00ah-CC9-resolutions-for-8_4_2_170j-4_11c_d • 11-13-1142-01-00ah-CC9-resolutions-for-9_32k • Vote deferred, document need revision • 11-13-1143-00-00ah-CC9-resolutions-for-9_32f • Vote deferred, document need revision Merlin, Liu, Shao

  26. Submissions cont. • 13/1127 CCA channelization and levels [PHY] • Eugene Baik (Qualcomm) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  27. Submissions • 11-13-1151-00-00ah-CC9-Resolution-CIDs-527-934-100-627-935.doc (David) • 11-13-0979-01-00ah-cc9-resolution-CIDs-419-766-66-67 (Amin) • 11-13-1022-01-00ah-CC9-Resolution-CIDs 1+2+6+922+963 (Alfred) • 11-13-1106-02-00ah-CC9-Resolution-CIDs 112+497+544+545+550+605+606+628+657+846+858 (Alfred) • 11-13-1201-00-00ah-CC9-Resolution-CIDs-Clause-6.3.3.2.2.-6.3.3.3.2-10.1.4.3.2 (Jae Seung)11-13-1202-00-00ah-CC9-Resolution-CIDs-Clause-8.3.3.10-8.3.4.15c-8.4.2.170 (Jae Seung) • 1189 Chao Chun • 1191 Chao Chun • 812r2 CID 19 (Alfred) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  28. Submissions • Review of the comments status (Yongho/Simone) • 11-13-1214-00-00ah-CC9-Resolution-CIDs Miscellaneous (Alfred) • 13/1140r1 for CID 570 (Amin) [Simone to check status] • [to be done in TG] https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/13/11-13-1207-00-00ah-partial-aid-color-bits.pptx In TG • Matthew Fischer (Broadcomm) • 1064r2 (Alfred) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  29. Comments review Notes • The following CIDs were unresolved and no submission is known that will try to resolve them; During ad hoc discussion the following actions were recorded. • David H: (173 general)  withdrawn (174 for the coex document in TG) • Hongyuan: 193 212 194 205 • Jianhan: 233  withdrawn in AM2 • Matt: (335 PHY) • Note: already withdraw 338 334 326 327 354 355 365 341 + requested withdrawal of other CIDs that wre already resolved: please Matt the rest were already resolved) • Minho: 422 (433 PHY)  422 withdrawn in AM2 • Mitsuru: (568 566 General)  to be done in the TG • Ron: 673 (607 General) 675 (622 Editor) 650 641 639 638 636 695  All Withdrawn in AM2 • Shusaku: (760 PHY), (761 PHY), (800 PHY) • Zhongding: 938 933  withdrawn in AM2 Merlin, Liu, Shao

  30. MAC ad hoc Straw Polls Merlin, Liu, Shao

  31. Straw Poll 1 • From document 1035r0 • Do you agree to extend TSF Timer Accuracy field by limiting the accuracy value to 7bit to accommodate other relating information like TSF Stability than the absolute (TSF) Accuracy for future usage? • Yes 1 • No 1 • Abstain 21 Tue AM1 Shusaku Merlin, Liu, Shao

  32. MAC ad hoc Pre-Motions to be brought for vote in TGahtask group Merlin, Liu, Shao

  33. Pre Motion 1 Mon PM3, Yongho • Do you agree with the resolution of the CIDs • 518, 580, 551, 5, 876, 101, 115, 116, 118, 134, 496, 528, 538, 539, 569, 603, 604, 617, 629, 659, 754, 758, 759, 768, 769, 772, 792, 807 • In document 11-13-1087-01-00ah-CC9-miscellaneous-comment-resolution • Passes with unanimous consent Merlin, Liu, Shao

  34. Pre Motion 2 Mon PM3, Lin Do you agree with the changes proposed in 13/1072r2? Pre Motion passes with unanimous consent Merlin, Liu, Shao

  35. Pre Motion 3 Mon PM3, Betty • Do you agree with the resolution of • CID 265 in 13/1068r2 CC09 Comment Resolution • CID 264, 534, 535, 716 and 834 in 13/1069r1 Passes with unanimous consent Merlin, Liu, Shao

  36. Pre Motion 4 • Do you agree with the resolution of comments • CID 201 and 202 • 11-13-1098-00-00ah CC9 Resolution of CID201 and 202 • CID 685, 688 to 694 • 11-13-1099-00-00ah CC9 Comment Resolution CID 685, 688-694 • 214, 216,217,218,221,260,679,680,681,682,824 • 11-13-1101-00-00ah-CC9-Comment Resolution-CID 214-216-217-218-221-260-679-680-824 Passes with unanimous consent Mon PM3, James Merlin, Liu, Shao

  37. Pre Motion 5 • Do you agree with the resolution of comments • 335, 760, 762 in 11-13-1102-01-00ah-CC9-Comment-Resolution-CID-335-760-761-762 • 213, 220 in 11-13-1103-00-00ah-CC9-Comment-Resolution-CID-213-220 • 780, 782-to-787 in 11-13-1104-00-00ah-CC9-Comment-Resolution-CID-780-782-to-787 Passes with unanimous consent Tue AM1, James Merlin, Liu, Shao

  38. Pre motion 6 • Do you agree with the resolution of • 41, 150, 350, and 898 in 13/1134r0 Resolutions to CIDs 41, 150, 350, and 898 Passes with unanimous consent Tue AM1, Chittabrata Merlin, Liu, Shao

  39. Pre motion 7 • Do you agree with the resolution of the CIDS • 86 in 11-13-1093-00-00ah-CC9-Comment-Resolution-CID-86 • 362 in 11-13-1094-00-00ah-CC9-Comment-Resolution-CID-362 • 717 in 11-13-1095-00-00ah-CC9-Comment-Resolution-CID-717 Passes with unanimous consent • Tue AM1, Yuan Zhou Merlin, Liu, Shao

  40. Pre Motion 8 • Do you agree with the resolution of CID • 856 in 13/1124r0 CC9-Resolution-CIDs-856 Passes with unanimous consent • Tue AM1, ShoukangZheng Merlin, Liu, Shao

  41. Pre Motion 9 • Do you agree with the resolution of • CIDs 31 and 592in11-13-1034-00-00ah-cc9-cids-31 and 592-comment-resolutions • Passes with unanimous consent • Tue AM1 Peter Loc (Huawei) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  42. Pre Motion 10 Do you agree with the resolution of CID 219 and 317 in 13/1067r0? Passes with unanimous consent Tue AM1 LiwenChu (STMicroelectronics) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  43. Pre Motion 11 • Do you agree with the resolution of the following CIDs • 831 and 542 in document 13/1141r0 • 499, 500, 501, 328, 234, 608, 757, 756, 755, 329, 502, 504, 370, 371, 845, 378, 330, 94, 146, 147, 609, 503, 614, 95, 611, 505, 615, 331, 612, 616, 507, 506, 610, 333, 332, 96, 369, 97, 235, 508, 125, 578 In document 13/1140r0 Passes with unanimous consent Tue AM1, Amin Merlin, Liu, Shao

  44. Pre Motion 12 • Do you agree with the resolution of the following comments? • 323,266,416,431,430,91,794,16,517,697,698,795,699, 695 • In 13/1139r0 • 68,445,676,446,447,35,232,674,449,450,451 • In 13/0981r1 CC9-Resolution-CIDs- • 393,632,631 • In 13/0975r3 CC9-Resolution-CIDs-393+632+631 • 419, 766, 66, 67 • 11-13-0979-01-00ah-cc9-resolution-CIDs-419-766-66-67 • Passes with unanimous consent Tue PM1, Amin Merlin, Liu, Shao

  45. Pre Motion 13 • Do you agree with the resolution of the CIDs • 418 and 903 in document 13/1136r0 Passes with unanimous consent Tue PM1, JianhanLiu (Mediatek Inc.) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  46. Pre Motion 14 • Do you agree with the resolution of the following CIDs • CIDs 647, 313, 316, 315, 441, 442, 440, 443, 452, 314, 874, 894, 564, 558, 668, 666, 667, 670, 672, 669, 343, 671 in 11-13-1143-01-00ah-CC9-resolutions-for-9_32f • Pre motion passes with unanimous consent Wed PM1, Matt Merlin, Liu, Shao

  47. Pre Motion 15 • Do you agree with the resolution of CIDs • 527, 934 • in 11-13-1151-00-00ah-CC9-Resolution-CIDs-527-934-100-627-935.doc • Passes with unanimous consent Wed PM1, David Merlin, Liu, Shao

  48. Pre Motion 16 • Do you agree with the resolution of CIDs • 627 • In 11-13-1022-01-00ah-CC9-Resolution-CIDs 1+2+6+922+963 • 605, 606, 628, 657 • 11-13-1106-02-00ah-CC9-Resolution-CIDs • Passes with unanimous consent Wed PM1, Alfred Merlin, Liu, Shao

  49. Pre Motion 17 • Do you agree with the resolution of CIDs • 56, 57, 60, 261, 262, 263, 519, 518, 516,705, 706, 707, 709, 710, 711, 712, 713,749, 750, 751, 981, 982, 983, 984 In 13/891r6 Passes with unanimous consent Wed PM1, KaiyingLv (ZTE Corp.) Merlin, Liu, Shao

  50. Pre motion 18 • Do you agree with the resolution of CIDs • CIDs 509, 522, CIDs 380, 510, 511, 623, 764, 765, CIDs 837, 920 In 11-13-1201-00-00ah-CC9-Resolution-CIDs-Clause-6.3.3.2.2.-6.3.3.3.2-10.1.4.3.2 • CID 403, CIDs 348, 349, 351, 588, 937, CIDs 412, 413, 438, 656 In 11-13-1202-00-00ah-CC9-Resolution-CIDs-Clause-8.3.3.10-8.3.4.15c-8.4.2.170 Pre motion passes with unanimous consent Wed PM1, Jae Seung Merlin, Liu, Shao

More Related