1 / 36

Constitutional Rights of Prisoners Chapter 6 “The Hole” and Administrative Segregation

Constitutional Rights of Prisoners Chapter 6 “The Hole” and Administrative Segregation. Order Maintenance. Punitive isolation (penalty for violating rules) The jail’s jail Solitary confinement Reduced diet Limits on reading materials Limits on outside exercise.

sofia
Download Presentation

Constitutional Rights of Prisoners Chapter 6 “The Hole” and Administrative Segregation

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Constitutional Rights of Prisoners Chapter 6 “The Hole” and Administrative Segregation

  2. Order Maintenance • Punitive isolation (penalty for violating rules) • The jail’s jail • Solitary confinement • Reduced diet • Limits on reading materials • Limits on outside exercise

  3. Administrative Segregation • Isolation for a reason other than punishment. • Protective isolation • Isolation during investigation

  4. Court Intervention • “Hands off” doctrine practiced by courts prior to 1960s. • No relief for prisoners who complained of conditions. • Internal matters for prison officials. • No supervision of courts.

  5. Court Intervention • Federal system • Separation of powers • Prisons in executive branch of government. • No authority of courts in judicial branch • State system • Administration was within power reserved to states in 10th Amendment.

  6. 8th Amendment • When court does intervene there must be a federally protected right.

  7. 8th Amendment • 8th Amendment prohibits “cruel and unusual punishment” • Includes torture, • unnecessary cruelty, • inhuman and barbarous treatment, • punishment disproportionate to offense, • punishment that is unnecessarily cruel in view of the purpose for which it is used.

  8. 8th Amendment • Punishment includes: • fine • penalty • confinement • court sentence

  9. 8th Amendment • Under corrrectional law: punishment includes • action by administrative body, • which imposes a sanction, • for purpose of penalty, • as result of an offense. • Punishment is subject to 8th Amendment standards

  10. Constitutionality of Isolated Confinement • Courts have upheld use of isolation • No liberty or property interest in being in general population

  11. Constitutionality of Isolated Confinement • Procedures in use of isolation can be challenged by prisoners. • Conditions may be disproportionate to offense. • Procedures used to impose isolation may be unfair and thus violate due process.

  12. Constitutionality of Conditions of Isolated Confinement • When conditions of isolated confinement violate 8th Amendment there is remedy. • Burden of proof is on the inmate. • When facts established supporting claim, it usually is matter of law whether those facts constitute 8th Amendment violation. • Thus it is not a jury question.

  13. Isolation • Boag c. MacDougall, 454 U.S. 364 (1982) • A prisoner claimed that he was placed in solitary confinement without any notice of charges or a hearing. • He was threatened with violence when he asked about the charges. • He was still in the hole a week later. • Court ruled these facts state a cause of action. • The claims cannot be dismissed summarily because the prisoner was transferred to another prison. • Also, the prisoner inartful pleading must be construed liberally.

  14. Conditions Subject to 8th Amendment Review • Hygiene • Physical condition of cell • Exercise allowed • Diet • Duration of isolation

  15. Hygiene • Inmate not provided means maintaining hygiene – unconstitutional • If provided soap, water, towel, periodic bathing – not unconstitutional • Lack of water and bath every 5 days – not unconstitutional

  16. Hygiene • One court held that no comb, pillow, toothpaste, toothbrush for 7-10 days • in cell with roaches and mice in cell, • no reading material and continuous light • did not constitute 8th Amendment violation.

  17. Conditions of Isolation • Griffin v. Smith • conditions of special housing unit violated 8th Amendment • Conditions included: • excessive and unnecessary use of force by guards, • grossly inadequate exercise, • denial of access to psychological specialists, • unsanitary food utensils, • cigarette burns and hair on food trays, • smaller portions of food than general population, • loss of mail sent to supt.

  18. Conditions of Isolation Hutto v. Finney, 437 U.S. 678 (1978) • The Supreme Court refused to overturn the district court’s detailed remedial orders holding that punitive isolation in sections of the Arkansas penal system violated the 8th Amendment. • These orders placed limits on the number of men that could be held in one cell, required that each man have a bunk, discontinued the gruel diet, and set maximum isolation at 30 days. • The Court’s rationale for imposing their judgment was that the prison system had failed to comply with previous orders,

  19. Conditions of Isolation • Courts have held it permissible to have no light or windows in cells, and to have no mattresses. • However, these same conditions when combined with overcrowding, unclean cells, or lack of heat have been found to violate the Eighth Amendment.

  20. Conditions of Isolation • Courts will review: • personal hygiene of inmate • physical condition of cell • access to exercise outside of cell • Prisoners can be deprived of contact visits, library, radio and TV, as long as nutrition and hygiene are adequate.

  21. Diet • Reduced diet has been approved by courts. • Bread and water with full meal every 3 days has been approved. • Bread and water generally disapproved. • Opposed by American Correctional Association.

  22. Length of Time in Solitary • Distinction between punitive isolation and administrative segregation

  23. Length of Time in Solitary • 15 days is punitive isolation found unconstitutional • 36 days found permissible • 48 hours found to be unconstitutional • Administrative segregation for 12 months found permissible. • Punitive isolation for indeterminate period / okay

  24. Length of Time in Solitary • 5 years in max. security section • Inmate allowed out of cell for only 1 hour a day (no time outdoors), • did not violate 8th Amendment. • Inmate had taken part in a riot, and had killed another inmate while in maximum security Section.

  25. Appointed Counsel • Counsel must be provided inmates in administrative segregation pending investigation or those on trial for felonies. • Inmate must ask for attorney. • Must make prima facie showing the detention is because of the investigation.

  26. Liberty Interest • Inmates have no “liberty interest” in being in general population • But, state may create a liberty interest. • Repeated use in prison regulations. • Mandatory language regarding procedures for isolation. • Requirement that admin-seg will not be used unless inmate commits certain acts.

  27. Liberty Interest • If statute or regulation creates “liberty interest” it cannot be restricted without due process.

  28. Due Process • Hearing • Informal • Non-adversary evidentiary review • Advance notice to prisoner • Notice must give inmate opportunity to answer charges. • Notice must be within reasonable time after transfer.

  29. Due Process • Hewitt v. Helms, 459 U.S. 103 (1983)

  30. Due Process • Sandin v. Conner, Supreme Court modifed due process requirements for inmates. • Before Sandin, Court required that inmate suffer some loss of liberty. • Post Sandin, Court required the loss be of “real substance”. • Intent was to get court out of the regular practice of reviewing day-to-day prison activities.

  31. Problems With Interpretation of Sandin • How to determine if loss was of “real substance” • Compare condition of ad-seg with disc-seg • Compare state with federal • Compare state with another state

  32. Purposes of Isolated Confinement • Courts found 8th Amend violations when isolation was for improper purpose. • Proper purpose of isolation is maintenance of order in prison. • Isolation not related to maintaining order is cruel and unusual punishment. • Unsanitary conditions in isolation section are unnecessarily punitive and violate 8th Amendment.

  33. Purposes of Isolated Confinement • Inmate cannot be placed in isolation • because of militant political ideas, or • because of past or threatened litigation • Denying food for 50 hours held not related to any legitimate correctional aim.

  34. Punishment Must Be Proportionate to Offense • Basis for relief is punishment which is disproportionate to infraction. • Unsanitary conditions make punishment disproportionate. • 5 months isolation for refusing to sign a safety form found disproportionate to infraction. • Whipping inmates in Arkansas prisons found disproportionate. • Entire Arkansas prison system found disproportionate to any offense, and therefore unconstitutional.

  35. Supermax • Scarver v. Litscher, 434 F.3d 972(7th Cir. 2006)

  36. Conclusion • Isolated confinement found to be valid correctional tool. • Courts will provide relief from confinement in isolation when: • Conditions are unsanitary • Diet is insufficient • When punishment is for improper purpose • When punishment is disproportionate to infraction • Procedure to be followed when transferring to isolation depend on whether there is a “liberty interest” and whether the deprivation of liberty is of “real substance.”

More Related