1 / 135

Mereotopologies: Fiat and Bona Fide Boundaries

Mereotopologies: Fiat and Bona Fide Boundaries. A substance has a complete physical boundary. The latter is a special sort of part of a substance … a boundary part something like a maximally thin extremal slice . boundary. substance. interior. A substance takes up space.

sevita
Download Presentation

Mereotopologies: Fiat and Bona Fide Boundaries

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Mereotopologies: Fiat and Bona Fide Boundaries

  2. A substance has a complete physical boundary • The latter is a special sort of part of a substance • … a boundary part • something like a maximally thin extremal slice

  3. boundary substance interior

  4. A substance takes up space. • A substance occupies a place or topoid (which enjoys an analogous completeness or rounded-offness) • A substance enjoys a place at a time

  5. A substance has spatial parts • … perhaps also holes

  6. Each substance is such as to have divisible bulk: • it can in principle be divided into separate spatially extended substances

  7. By virtue of theirdivisible bulk • substances compete for space: • (unlike shadows and holes) • no two substances can occupy the same spatial region at the same time.

  8. Substances vs. Collectives • Collectives = unified aggregates: families, jazz bands, empires • Collectives are real constituents of reality (contra sets) • but still they are not additional constituents, over and above the substances which are their parts.

  9. Collectives inherit some, but not all, of the ontological marks of substances • They can admit contrary moments at different times.

  10. Collectives, • like substances, • may gain and lose parts or members • may undergo other sorts of changes through time.

  11. Qualities and processes, too, may form collectives • a musical chord is a collective of individual tones • football matches, wars, plagues are collectives of actions involving human beings

  12. Collectives/heaps • are the duals of undetached parts • Both involve fiat boundaries

  13. Substances, Undetached Parts and Heaps • Substances are unities. • They enjoy a natural completeness • in contrast to their undetached parts (arms, legs) • and to heaps or aggregates • … these are topological distinctions

  14. substance undetached part collective of substances

  15. special sorts of undetached parts • ulcers • tumors • lesions • …

  16. physical (bona fide) boundary fiat boundary Fiat boundaries

  17. Holes, too, involve fiat boundaries

  18. hole A hole in the ground • Solid physical boundaries at the floor and walls but with a lid that is not made of matter:

  19. Holes involve two kinds of boundaries • bona fide boundaries which exist independently of our demarcating acts • fiat boundaries which exist only because we put them there

  20. Examples • of bona fide boundaries: • an animal’s skin, the surface of the planet • of fiat boundaries: • the boundaries of postal districts and census tracts

  21. Mountain • bona fide upper boundaries • with a fiat base:

  22. where does the mountain start ? ... a mountain is not a substance

  23. nose ...and it’s not an accident, either

  24. Examples • of bona fide boundaries: • an animal’s skin, the surface of the planet • of fiat boundaries: • the boundaries of postal districts and census tracts

  25. Mountain • bona fide upper boundaries • with a fiat base:

  26. Architects Plan for a House • fiat upper boundaries • with a bona fide base:

  27. where does the mountain start ? ... a mountain is not a substance

  28. nose ...and it’s not a process, either

  29. One-place qualities and processes • depend on one substance • (as a headache depends upon a head)

  30. kiss John Mary • Relational qualities and processes stand in relations of one-sided dependence to a plurality of substances simultaneously

  31. Examples of relational qualities and processes • kisses, thumps, conversations, • dances, legal systems • Such real relational entities • join their carriers together into collectives of greater or lesser duration

  32. Mereology • ‘Entity’ = absolutely general ontological term of art • embracing at least: all substances, qualities, processes, and all the wholes and parts thereof, including boundaries

  33. Primitive notion of part • ‘x is part of y’ in symbols: ‘x ≤ y’

  34. We define overlap as the sharing of common parts: • O(x, y) := z(z ≤ x  z ≤ y)

  35. Axioms for basic mereology • AM1 x ≤ x • AM2 x ≤ y  y ≤ x  x = y • AM3 x ≤ y  y ≤ z  x ≤ z • Parthood is a reflexive, antisymmetric, and transitive relation, a partial ordering.

  36. Extensionality • AM4 z(z ≤ x  O(z, y))  x ≤ y • If every part of x overlaps with y • then x is part of y • cf. status and bronze

  37. Sum • AM5 x(x)  • y(z(O(y,z) x(x  O(x,z)))) • For every satisfied property or condition  there exists an entity, the sum of all the -ers

  38. Definition of Sum • x(x) := yz(O(y,z) x(x  O(x,z))) • The sum of all the -ers is that entity which overlaps with z if and only if there is some -er which overlaps with z

  39. Examples of sums • electricity, Christianity, your body’s metabolism • the Beatles, the population of Erie County, the species cat

  40. Other Boolean Relations • x  y := z(z ≤ x  z ≤ y) binary sum • x  y := z(z ≤ x  z ≤ y) product

  41. Other Boolean Relations • x – y := z (z ≤ x  O(z, y)) difference • –x := z (O(z, x)) complement

  42. What is a Substance? • Bundle theories: a substance is a whole made up of tropes as parts. • What holds the tropes together? • ... problem of unity

  43. Topology • How can we transform a sheet of rubber in ways which do not involve cutting or tearing?

  44. Topology • We can invert it, stretch or compress it, move it, bend it, twist it. Certain properties will be invariant under such transformations – • ‘topological spatial properties’

  45. Topology • Such properties will fail to be invariant under transformations which involve cutting or tearing or gluing together of parts or the drilling of holes

  46. Examples of topological spatial properties • The property of being a (single, connected) body • The property of possessing holes (tunnels, internal cavities) • The property of being a heap • The property of being an undetached part of a body

  47. Examples of topological spatial properties • It is a topological spatial property of a pack of playing cards that it consists of this or that number of separate cards • It is a topological spatial property of my arm that it is connected to my body.

  48. Topological Properties • Analogous topological properties are manifested also in the temporal realm: • they are those properties of temporal structures which are invariant under transformations of • slowing down, speeding up, temporal translocation …

  49. Topological Properties

  50. Topology and Boundaries • Open set: (0, 1) • Closed set: [0, 1] • Open object: • Closed object:

More Related