1 / 15

Surety Outlook

Surety Outlook. Willis Construction Risk Management Conference April 19-21, 2011 Dallas, TX. Overview. Historical Results – 12 year history Current Market Conditions Surety Carriers Surety Reinsurance Construction trends and surety impact Globalization The next three years

Download Presentation

Surety Outlook

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Surety Outlook Willis Construction Risk Management Conference April 19-21, 2011 Dallas, TX

  2. Overview • Historical Results – 12 year history • Current Market Conditions • Surety Carriers • Surety Reinsurance • Construction trends and surety impact • Globalization • The next three years • What does this mean to your business? • Willis Surety Solutions

  3. $1.17T $831B $788B 12 YEAR HISTORY Billions $8 $7 $6 $5 $4 $3 $2 $1 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Written Surety Premium Surety Losses (Contract & Commercial) Value Of Construction Put In Place

  4. Top 10 Sureties & Written Premium (2000) Travelers $388,872,000 St. Paul $387,649,000 CNA $285,528,000 Zurich $206,922,000 AIG $160,025,000 Liberty $141,603,000 ACE $125,781,000 Safeco $124,739,000 Chubb $120,138,000 Fireman’s Fund $106,144,000 Total:$2,047,401,000* *Approx. 59% of all surety premium Top 10 Sureties & Written Premium (2010) Travelers $867,822,000 Liberty $751,166,000 Zurich $512,317,000 CNA $406,463,000 Chubb $256,920,000 Hartford $177,157,000 HCC $176,126,000 IFIC $143,273,000 ACE $109,531,000 NAS $104,845,000 Total: $3,505,620,000* *Approx. 67% of all surety premium What a difference a decade makes!

  5. Today’s Surety Market • 5th consecutive year with loss ratio less than 20%. • Capacity more than doubled! • Returns attracting capital – e.g. XL for contract and Aspen, Arch and HCC in commercial. • Co-surety compatibility – more inter party acceptance vs. mid 2000’s – e.g. CNA • Procurement shifts – P3, RFP, gap, etc – legal review. • Rates – the inverted pricing curve flattens (see chart).

  6. 2006 Managing Capacity Managing Work Finding Quality People to Perform Over-extended subcontractors 2011 & Beyond Subcontractor risks Contract Terms Expanding “strike zone” Margin Compression Project/owner financing Credit Relationships Underwriting Trends

  7. $10.8B $5.5B EXTENDED SURETY CAPACITY (IN MILLIONS) 3500 2002 2010 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0

  8. 25 23 20 16 2010 12 11 10 8 7 4 PRICECURVE # OF SURETIES 2007 25 2010 2007 15 10 0 $10M $10M-$100M $100M-$500M $500M-$1B $1B CONTRACTORS - AGGREGATE SURETY CAPACITY

  9. Surety Reinsurance • Significantly more capacity today than early 2000’s which is reflected in growth in capacity. • Largely an XOL business today versus quota share – reinsurers are further removed from frequency exposure. • Highly profitable following fortunes of surety market the last five years. • Larger retentions taken by surety companies based on their reserves, profitability and spread of risk from their consolidation – reinsurers competing for smaller risk transfer opportunity.

  10. Reinsurance Program • Quota ShareExcess of Loss XOL 2/3 RET 2/3 Q 1/3 RET 1/3

  11. Construction Industry Trends and Surety Impact • Reduced levels of construction spending and a projected slow recovery. • Pendulum shift towards owners for contract procurement, and terms and conditions. • Margin compression. • Subcontractor default risk has increased. • Procurement longer cycles – P3, RFP, Gap, funding delays, politics. • Acquisitions – consolidations. • Commodity escalation.

  12. Globalization • Non U.S. contractors looking to expand into US markets – primarily via acquisitions – Spanish firms such as ACS, OHL and Ferrovial have been the most obvious examples. • U.S. viewed as a stable market with long term potential and a short term buying opportunity, based on economic slowdown. • U.S. contractors are expanding their strike zone to find work and we are receiving more inquiries from U.S. firms looking to expand outside of North America. • Surety requirements for non U.S. companies require a meaningful U.S. asset base, parent guarantee and often LC’s. Non U.S. firms often find U.S. surety requirements inefficient.

  13. The next three years • Slow growth – ENR survey – “improving” moves from 16% to 71% over three years. • Persistent margin pressure • Acquisitions – global and domestic • Surety loss development – 2012 and 2013 • Global competition • Joint Ventures – new markets, new skills, bigger • Good people – team upgrade opportunities • Reinvention – dealing with the new normal • Strong survive and prosper

  14. What does it mean to your business • No opportunity to “wait it out” - adjust to a prolonged and different market. • Expense strategies have been highly effective in short term but revenue strategies needed for the longer term, e.g. new markets, differentiation, acquisitions. • Accept it is difficult, not hopeless. • From a surety perspective, anticipate deterioration of results, but not a market change as dramatic as the early 2000’s. • There will be adequate surety capacity in terms of limits, but patience and support for new strategies will be tested.

  15. Willis Solutions • Networking for JV partners, subcontractor pre-qualification, acquisitions, surety work-outs, etc. • Broad surety market relationships at the local and headquarter level to help you stay close to changes in people, appetite, loss development, co-surety compatibility, reinsurance, etc. • Professional surety brokers - locally and nationally linked together. • Close to emerging trends in project financing such as P3, last years Gap financing and next year’s solution TBD. • Our partnership with you – our clients to invest in the business at the trade association level, local and national committees, this Risk Conference and our Construction Practice.

More Related