1 / 24

Prediction Markets and the Wisdom of the Crowds

Prediction Markets and the Wisdom of the Crowds . Presented by: Kaitlin Santanna & Eva Budzynski. A quick experiment… . How many jelly beans are in the jar?. ?. The Wisdom of the Crowds.

royce
Download Presentation

Prediction Markets and the Wisdom of the Crowds

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Prediction Markets and the Wisdom of the Crowds Presented by: Kaitlin Santanna & Eva Budzynski

  2. A quick experiment… • How many jelly beans are in the jar? ?

  3. The Wisdom of the Crowds • As we saw from the two averages, the predictions of the group as a whole was better than one single guess • This idea was the inspiration for John Surowiecki’s book “The Wisdom of the Crowds” • Good because asking a diverse group of people • Bay of Pigs • Traffic • How can this idea be applied to the finance world?

  4. Prediction Markets • A speculative market whose purpose is to make predictions • Assets’ final cash value is tied to the outcome of a particular event • The current market prices are interpreted as predictions of the probability of the outcome of this event

  5. Who uses prediction markets? • Major corporations • Yahoo, Microsoft, Google • Sales, product behavior • Public opinion • Educational institutions • You!!!!!

  6. Prediction Markets Make It Big • The value and effectiveness of prediction markets was first known in 1988 • Iowa Electronic Market (IEM) • Created by the University of Iowa’s business school • Features a host of markets designed to predict outcomes of elections • Has correctly predicted the outcome of elections better than traditional polling

  7. Iowa Electronic Market • Open to anyone who wants to participate • Allows people to buy contracts based on how they think a particular political candidate will do • Two most common contracts • Predict winner of election • Predict what percentage of final popular vote candidate will get

  8. Predict the Winner • Cash-or-nothing format • For example, if you picked George Bush to win the 2000 election, you would have bought a “GWB to win” contract that paid you $1 • If he had lost, you would have gotten nothing • Price you pay for this type of contract reflects market’s judgment of candidate’s chance of victory • If contract is $.50, market believes has 50% of winning

  9. Predict the Percentage • Predict the percentage of the final popular vote a candidate will get • Payoffs are determined by the vote percentage • If you bought a GWB contract in 2000, you would have received $.48 (since he won 48% of the popular vote) when the election was over

  10. IEM 2008 Example • 2008 Presidential election • Vote-Share Market (PRES08_VS) • Determined by the percentages of the popular vote received by the Democratic and Republican nominees • Opened on Thursday, June 1, 2006 • Payoff: • Payoffs are determined by the percentages of the total two-party popular vote • E.g., contracts for a candidate who receives 32.4% of the popular votes will be worth 32.4 cents each

  11. IEM Example (cont’d) • Results • The Friday, November 7, 2008, New York Times was the official source used to determine payoffs • IEM data on website http://iemweb.biz.uiowa.edu/pricehistory/PriceHistory_GetData.cfm • November 7, 2008, last trade before midnight

  12. PRES08_VS Graphs http://iemweb.biz.uiowa.edu/graphs/graph_Pres08_VS.cfm

  13. IEM’s Accuracy • Berg, Forsythe, Nelson and Rietz’s article “Results from a dozen Years of Electronic Futures Market Research” • IEM’s performance in 49 elections from 1988-2000 • Election-eve prices in the IEM were off by: • 1.37% Presidential • 3.43% Other U.S. • ¾ of the time, IEM’s market price was more accurate • Less volatile and change only in response to new information

  14. Hollywood Stock Exchange • HSX – www.hsx.com • The entertainment stock market where you can trade movies, stars, and more just as you would stocks and bonds • MovieStocks- represent films, both in the process of being made and that are currently in theaters • StarBonds- represents actors and directors • Anyone can start a portfolio, and when you set up an account you are given two million Hollywood dollars

  15. Hollywood Stock Exchange • When you have an account you can do many things: • Buying – you are betting that the price will rise • Selling – when you think a security has already peaked in its price • Short Selling – when you think a particular security is overvalued and the price is going to go down, you should sell the security “short” • Covering – opposite of short selling, when you realize profit/loss by covering your shorted security

  16. MovieStocks • The price of a MovieStock reflects how much money traders think the film will make domestically in its first four weeks in the box office • For example, if a MovieStock is at H$80, then it is thought it will make 80 million in the first four weeks • Once the opening weekend box office is totaled, a MovieStock will adjust in price to reflect the actual box office gross vs. what was expected • MovieStocks will be cashed out and removed from the HSX four weeks after they have been in wide release

  17. StarBonds • The price of a StarBond reflects the overall star power as determined by HSX traders, how much money their films make at the box office as determined by their trailing average gross (TAG) • When the star’s second film is released the price is readjusted • When a celebrity meets the end of their career, the StarBond is cashed out

  18. Options • These are Hollywood derivatives based around a specific event • “Call” and “Put” options are released on opening weekend of a particular MovieStock • Each option has a “strikeprice” that is set according to what the market expects the film to gross its opening weekend • Options are cashed out on the Monday following the opening weekend at a price equal to the opening weekend box-office gross (in millions) - strikeprice

  19. Extras • Commissions • Insider Trading is LEGAL • Position Limits • Manipulation • Hollywood Reserve Bank • Hollywood Investment Bank (HIB) • Hollywood Securities and Exchange Commission (HSEC)

  20. U.S. Gambling Laws & Prediction Markets • Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act of 2006 illegalized all online betting • Betfair • IEM has received two no-action letters from the Division of Trading and Markets of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission • HSX not for real profit

  21. Other Popular Websites • Newsfutures – change me • Intrade – www.intrade.com

  22. Accuracy Studies • Dr. Charles Manski • Steven Gjerstad • Real-money vs. n0t-for-profit markets

  23. Sources of Inaccuracy • Can be direct attempts to manipulate the market • 2004 manipulation attempt on presidential markets on Tradesports.com • An anonymous trader sold short so many Bush 2004 presidential contracts that the price was driven to zero, implying a zero percent chance that Bush would win • Attempts like this are short-lived • Ends up increasing the accuracy • Monitors on major prediction market websites

  24. Work Cited

More Related