1 / 27

ASTR 1101-001 Spring 2008

ASTR 1101-001 Spring 2008. Joel E. Tohline, Alumni Professor 247 Nicholson Hall [Slides from Lecture12]. Contrasting Models of Planetary Motions. Greek Geocentric Model (Ptolemaic System) – §4-1 Originated by Apollonius of Perga & Hipparchus in 2 nd century B.C.

roxy
Download Presentation

ASTR 1101-001 Spring 2008

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. ASTR 1101-001Spring 2008 Joel E. Tohline, Alumni Professor 247 Nicholson Hall [Slides from Lecture12]

  2. Contrasting Models of Planetary Motions • Greek Geocentric Model (Ptolemaic System) – §4-1 • Originated by Apollonius of Perga & Hipparchus in 2nd century B.C. • Expanded upon by Ptolemy in 2nd century A.D. • Copernican Heliocentric Model – §4-2 • Proposed in 1543 by Nicolaus Copernicus • (Also considered in 3rd century B.C. by Aristarchus)

  3. Contrasting Models of Planetary Motions • Geocentric Model • Underlying hypothesis: Earth is unmoving and at “center of the universe” • Heliocentric Model • Preferred (by Copernicus) initially because of its relative simplicity • Eventually proven correct by new observations made possible by the aid of telescopes (see Galileo’s discoveries §4-5)

  4. Naked-Eye Observations“explained” by both Ptolemy and Copernicus • Stars (and Sun, Moon, etc.) rise in east and set in west once every 24 hours • Remove 24-hr diurnal motion; Sun and Moon both move steadily west-to-east at different rates (Moon = month period; Sun = year period) • Superior planets [Mars, Jupiter, Saturn] usually wander slowly east-to-west (observed periods greater than 1 year) but periodically display retrograde (west-to-east) motion • Inferior planets [Mercury, Venus] never wander very far (in angular separation) from the Sun; only seen shortly before or shortly after sunrise/sunset

  5. Galileo’s New Observationsmade with the aid of a telescope (~ 1610) • Revolutionary discoveries not especially relevant to the “geo-” versus “helio-” centric debate: • Mountains and Craters on the Moon • Sunspots on the Sun (ouch!) • Rings of Saturn • The “Milky Way” is “a mass of innumerable stars”

  6. Galileo Galilei (1564-1642)

  7. Galileo’s New Observationsmade with the aid of a telescope (~ 1610) • Revolutionary discoveries not especially relevant to the “geo-” versus “helio-” centric debate: • Mountains and Craters on the Moon • Sunspots on the Sun (ouch!) • Rings of Saturn • The “Milky Way” is “a mass of innumerable stars”

  8. Galileo’s New Observationsmade with the aid of a telescope (~ 1610) • Revolutionary discoveries not especially relevant to the “geo-” versus “helio-” centric debate: • Mountains and Craters on the Moon • Sunspots on the Sun (ouch!) • Rings of Saturn • The “Milky Way” is “a mass of innumerable stars”

  9. Galileo’s New Observationsmade with the aid of a telescope (~ 1610) • Revolutionary discoveries not especially relevant to the “geo-” versus “helio-” centric debate: • Mountains and Craters on the Moon • Sunspots on the Sun (ouch!) • Rings of Saturn • The “Milky Way” is “a mass of innumerable stars”

  10. Galileo’s New Observationsmade with the aid of a telescope (~ 1610) • Revolutionary discoveries not especially relevant to the “geo-” versus “helio-” centric debate: • Mountains and Craters on the Moon • Sunspots on the Sun (ouch!) • Rings of Saturn • The Milky Way is “a mass of innumerable stars”

  11. Galileo’s New Observationsmade with the aid of a telescope (~ 1610) • Discoveries useful in resolving the “geo-” versus “helio-” centric debate: • Venus exhibits phases like those of the Moon • The apparent size of Venus was related to the planet’s phase (as well as to the planet’s angular distance from the Sun) • Jupiter has four “Galilean satellites”; their orbital behavior is like a Copernican system in miniature

  12. Galileo’s New Observationsmade with the aid of a telescope (~ 1610) • Discoveries useful in resolving the “geo-” versus “helio-” centric debate: • Venus exhibits phases like those of the Moon • The apparent size of Venus was related to the planet’s phase (as well as to the planet’s angular distance from the Sun) • Jupiter has four “Galilean satellites”; their orbital behavior is like a Copernican system in miniature

  13. Phases of Venus

  14. Phases of Venus expected in the Coperican Heliocentric model

  15. Galileo’s New Observationsmade with the aid of a telescope (~ 1610) • Discoveries useful in resolving the “geo-” versus “helio-” centric debate: • Venus exhibits phases like those of the Moon • The apparent size of Venus was related to the planet’s phase (as well as to the planet’s angular distance from the Sun) • Jupiter has four “Galilean satellites”; their orbital behavior is like a Copernican system in miniature

  16. Angular size “a” expressed in arcseconds.

  17. Galileo’s New Observationsmade with the aid of a telescope (~ 1610) • Discoveries useful in resolving the “geo-” versus “helio-” centric debate: • Venus exhibits phases like those of the Moon • The apparent size of Venus was related to the planet’s phase (as well as to the planet’s angular distance from the Sun) • Jupiter has four “Galilean satellites”; their orbital behavior is like a Copernican system in miniature

  18. Galileo’s New Observationsmade with the aid of a telescope (~ 1610) • First fundamentally new astronomical data in almost 2000 years! • Contradicted prevailing opinion (and religious belief) and strongly suggested a heliocentric (Copernican) structure of the “universe”

  19. Scientific utility of theCopernican Heliocentric Model • Can deduce the true “sidereal” (as opposed to readily measured “synodic”) orbital periods of each of the planets [see textbook BOX 4-1 and Table 4-1] • Can deduce the distance that each planet is from the Sun, relative to the Earth’s distance from the Sun (1 AU); [see textbook discussion associated with Table 4-2]

  20. Synodic versus SiderealPlanetary Orbital Periods • When two systems that have different natural oscillation periods (Plong & Pshort) start out “in alignment” with one another, they will return to an aligned arrangement after a time that is identified by their so-called “beat” period, “B”.

  21. Synodic versus SiderealPlanetary Orbital Periods • For two planets: Sidereal periods

  22. Synodic versus SiderealPlanetary Orbital Periods • For two planets: Synodic period

More Related