1 / 33

Catastrophic Claims in Ontario

Catastrophic Claims in Ontario . Stephen Moore, based on an earlier presentation by Jess Bush. Why are Catastrophic Claims so Expensive?. The cost of catastrophic claims is increasing at an alarming rate; This presentation will attempt to explain why;

Download Presentation

Catastrophic Claims in Ontario

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Catastrophic Claims in Ontario Stephen Moore, based on an earlier presentation by Jess Bush

  2. Why are Catastrophic Claims so Expensive? • The cost of catastrophic claims is increasing at an alarming rate; • This presentation will attempt to explain why; • This presentation will focus on auto claims in Ontario because they raise more and more complex issues than other types of tort claims;

  3. The Usual Tort Heads of Damages • General damages; • Family Law Act damages*; • Past loss of income; • Future loss of income; • Past medical care; • Future medical care*; • Loss of interdependent relationship*;

  4. Tort Damages, continued • Guardianship Fees and Management Costs*;

  5. General Damages • Catastrophic general damage cap is $100,000 in 1978 dollars; • With inflation that cap is now approximately $325,000; • FLA general damages tend to cap at $100,000; • Parents of catastrophically impaired children usually receive about $75,000 each;

  6. Past Loss of Income • Pre-trial loss of income claims are capped at 80% of net income; • Unless that number exceeds $400 per week, the past loss of income claim is usually very small;

  7. Future Loss of Income • Future loss of income is based on 100% of the gross loss; • Even if the SABs insurer cashes out there is almost always a big gap between the available future collateral benefits and the tort claim;

  8. Medical Care • Most of the past medical care is covered by the SABs unless they have run out; • There are a myriad of future care items that can really increase the cost of future care and they include: • Attendant care; • OT and Rehabilitation; • Community Integration;

  9. Medical Care Continued • Equipment including computers, communication devices etc.; • Transportation expenses; • Home modifications;

  10. Attendant Care* • Will it be provided privately or by an agency? • Agency care is usually about double the cost of privately provided care; • Will it be provided by a PSW, RSW or RNA? • PSWs cost about $24 per hour, RSWs about $40-45 per hour and RNAs are over $50 per hour; • How much is overnight care costing?

  11. Rehabilitation* • The rehabilitation expense is often one of the most abused heads of damages; • One needs the input of a physiatrist and an OT to combat these claims; • OTs and RSWs tend to cost 2-4 times as much as PSWs;

  12. Community Integration* • Special workers are appointed to help the person re-integrate; • They tend to be RSWs or the equivalent and do things like take the plaintiff to the movies or the library or out to a bar;

  13. Equipment* • Often very expensive but often unproven home environmental controls are recommended; • Expensive computers and programs are recommended that are never used or used only sparingly; • Equipment and expensive software is often recommended to assist in communication; • Watch for duplication and lack of credit;

  14. Transportation • Usually a claim for an expensive van with no credit for another vehicle the plaintiff would buy anyway; • Claims for drivers in addition to attendants;

  15. Home Modifications • Elaborate home modifications are recommended usually without giving any credit for housing expenses that would normally be paid out of a person’s salary; • Claim is often for 3 or 4 modifications during a lifetime;

  16. Loss of Interdependent Relationship • What is it? • It is worth between $50 and $150,000 but the reports can put the number up much higher; • Attack the number or attack the theory?

  17. Guardianship and Management Fees • Required if the plaintiff lack competency; • Covers the charges by the corporate guardian (usually a trust company) and the personal guardian plus the legal costs for passing accounts; • Can easily add 15% to the future care costs; • Shop for better rates on these items;

  18. Who Pays for What • Pre-trial claims are reduced by any available collateral benefits; • Most collateral benefit payors have no rights of subrogation; • Tort defendants pay all future losses and receive an assignment of all future collateral benefits;

  19. What Collateral Benefits are Available • OHIP pays for all hospital expenses and most medical treatment provided by MDs; • It generally does not cover care provided by physiotherapists, OTs, chiropractors, massage therapists etc.; • OHIP has no right of subrogation unless the automobile is from out-of-province;

  20. Statutory Accident Benefits • First party coverage available from an insurer or the government for all persons injured in a motor vehicle collision in Ontario; • For non-catastrophic claims it provides up to $400 per week in income replacement benefits based on 80% of the person’s pre-accident net income;

  21. SABs, continued • It provides up to $3,500/$50,000 or $100,000 of medical/rehabilitation benefits for a period of 10 years; • It provides up to $36,000/$72,000 of attendant care ($3,000 max per month) benefits for a maximum period of 104 weeks; • It provides other benefits including caregiver, visitor expense, housekeeping and home maintenance and other expenses;

  22. SABs Catastrophic Impairments • The med/rehab max jumps to $1 million and is payable for life; • The attendant care benefit maximum moves to $1 million with a monthly maximum of $6,000; • Case manager services;

  23. Other Collateral Benefits • The tort defendant also gets to deduct other collateral benefits such as: • some LTD payments; • amounts available under EHC insurance; and • CPP disability pensions;

  24. Future Collateral Benefits • Tort defendants pay full future damages and, in exchange, receive an assignment of all future collateral benefits; • This means the tort defendant must front the cash for all future costs and income losses; • SABs carriers will often cash out their future obligation and if this is done the tort defendant can deduct the cash out;

  25. Future SABs, continued • The deductions must be deducted head by head; • For example, the future IRB must be deducted from the future loss of income claim; excess benefits cannot be deducted; • Some SABs are not deductible such as the non-earner benefit;

  26. What is Driving the Numbers Up? • Increasing costs of medical care; • Changes in the discount rates; • Professor Coyte and discount rates for medical expenses; • The courts preference for home over institutional care;

  27. Discount Rates • As recently as 2003 the partially mandated discount rate was 2.5% • It is now 0.75% for the first 15 years and 2.5% thereafter; • This allow will drive up the cost of future care for a period of 25 years by 18.6 %;

  28. Professor Coyte • Evidence can be lead to vary the regulated discount rate; • Professor Coyte provides evidence that the cost of medical care rises faster than the cost of other goods by about 1%; • This lowers the discount rate to -0.25% for the first 15 years and to 1.5% thereafter; • This alone can increase future care costs by 25%

  29. Combined Impact on Future Care Costs • The drop in discount rates since 2003 plus Professor Coyte’s reduction to discount rates when combined can increase the cost of future care by over 40% over what they were in 2003; • This increase ignores that actual increase in the cost of such services since 2003.

  30. Home Care vs. Institutional Care • The courts prefer home care to institutional care regardless of the increased cost;

  31. Strategies to Reduce Claims • Try and get the SAB carrier to cash out-invite them to the mediation; • Have the appropriate experts review all of the recommendations of the plaintiff’s experts; • Make sure someone investigates the plaintiff’s life expectancy; • Try and demonstrate that institutional care is desirable and inevitable;

  32. Strategies, continued • Watch for duplication and attempts to claim costs that are not extraordinary; • Where there is contributory negligence make sure you deduct it before deducting collateral benefits; • Where there is contrib consider making the plaintiff prove past losses; • Consider using Professor Manga.

  33. Structures • They can be used to avoid gross up for taxes on future care costs; • Be careful, if the future care claim is based on CPI or CPI plus 1%, then the cost of the structure can be greater than the actuarial number; • Trying to sell a structure to an Ontario plaintiff represented by a good lawyer is usually a waste of time;

More Related