1 / 36

Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Public Enterprises

28 August 2012. Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Public Enterprises. Ensuring A Stable Future for SAA Despite Turbulent Times for World Airlines. SAA Presentation to Parliament’s Portfolio Committee on Public Enterprises. Key Areas Today. 1. Africa Expansion Programme. 2.

nickson
Download Presentation

Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Public Enterprises

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. 28 August 2012 Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Public Enterprises Ensuring A Stable Future for SAA Despite Turbulent Times for World Airlines

  2. SAA Presentation to Parliament’s Portfolio Committee on Public Enterprises Key Areas Today 1 Africa Expansion Programme 2 Airbus Procurement Hedging 3 Page 2

  3. SAA’s Growth Strategy in Africa 1 African Strategic Context 2 African Network Performance Update 3 Strategic Challenges Facing SAA 4 SAA’s Strategic Response: Growth and Optimisation All data sourced from: IATA’s PaxIS; SAA RCT Report and the APG forecasting tool. Page 3

  4. SAA’s African Reach • SAA has already achieved substantial African operational scale • We continue to plan for and open additional routes • SAA currently flies to 26 destinations on the continent • We serve 21 African countries outside South Africa • We carry an average of 4,600 passengers per day on these routes Page 4

  5. Johannesburg Hub Strategy • Growing traffic to our continental destinations from outside Africa a strong indication our Johannesburg hub concept paying off • Increasing numbers of international passengers using Johannesburg as easy transit point from • Beijing • Sao Paulo • Buenos Aires • Mumbai • Perth • Hong Kong Page 5

  6. Top Carriers serving Africa to Non-African Points • Capacity to and from Africa over past 2 years has increased by more than 32% • Mostly provided by non-African Ailines

  7. Strategic Challenges to SAA • Emirates continues to grow its network in Africa • Emirates is able to grow in relation to SAA on an on-going basis • Their particular model of state ownership enables invisible subsidies, eg. through aircraft financing not available to others • Emirates have a simple growth with substantial fleet, network and product advantages over SAA • Their non-direct flight pricing is having long-term market behaviour consequences • Passenger network and monthly seat capacity • November 2006: • 16 destinations / 140,168 seats • June 2012 • 18 destinations / 462,790 seats • Flydubai: 5 destinations / 21,735 seats 23 African destinations Seats: 484,525 230% Increase in six years Page 7

  8. Strategic Challenges to SAA • Other African Airlines continue to grow their networks in Africa • SAA is still the largest airline in Africa, measured by RPKs • Egypt Air carries 43% more passengers in a single airline group with regional jet operations. • Other African airlines continue to grow in relation to SAA • Some are expanding aggressively, seeking to emulate the Emirates model, including leveraging higher and mid-hemisphere positions • They are either fully or partly state owned and subsidised • Their expanding networks reduce the need to travel via Johannesburg and provide greater access to competing tourism markets • FY 06/07 vs. FY 12/13 Capacity: • These competitors add capacity and develop new routes very quickly • Their fleets have grown: Egypt Air has 72 passenger aircraft, Ethiopian 33 and growing fastest, Kenya Airways plans to double their fleet in five years from 32 now • SAA/Mango have together 53 passenger aircraft Page 8

  9. SAA’s Response: A Growth and Optimisation Strategy • We have looked in detail at what successful airlines are doing • We are proposing for discussion among stakeholders a strategy to • build on our strengths • learn from our partners and peers internationally, including their successes and mistakes • meet our challengers with innovative, well reasoned responses • Our proposed growth and optimisation strategy includes • New route development or increased capacity from our Johannesburg hub • Replicating brand and operating hubs in new African markets, including Mango regional operations • Expanding the role and offering of our non-airline subsidiaries, such as SAA Technical and Air Chefs on the continent Page 9

  10. SAA’s Response:Growth and Optimisation • New route development from Johannesburg hubs to African destinations where • traffic rights available • passenger volumes sufficient • SAA routes launched from Johannesburg FY 2011/12 • Ndola (Zambia) (October 2011) • Pointe Noire (Republic of Congo) (January 2012) • Bujumbura/Kigali (Burundi and Rwanda) (January 2012) • + additional capacity increases on some existing routes • SAA routes launched in FY 2012/13 • Johannesburg: • Cotonou (Benin) (May 2012) • Abidjan (Cote d’Ivoire) (August 2012) • Brazzaville (Republic of Congo) (September 2013) Page 10

  11. SAA’s Response:Growth on Existing Routes • Further route development from Johannesburg hub • Some of these destinations present challenges regarding traffic rights • SAA has growth plans for some existing routes, including • Dar Es Salaam (Tanzania) • Lusaka (Zambia) • Harare (Zimbabwe) • Accra (Ghana ) • We are currently evaluating two or three more regional destinations for FY 13/14 Page 11

  12. African Network Growth Faces Rights Challenges • In some core markets, SAA’s growth is limited by restrictions in bilateral air traffic agreements Mozambique • Restrictions on capacity or frequency • Recently revised to allow additional seats, we have applied • We will increases services as soon as bilateral approvals are granted DRC • SAA restricted to four weekly frequencies per week • We would like to operate six weekly frequencies • This would offer our passengers more choice and greater connectivity throughout our network Angola • SAA restricted to seven weekly frequencies per week • We need double daily services (14 frequencies per week) to meet demand and offer better connectivity to South America and the Far East Page 12

  13. Strategic Exercise – Replicate Brands and Hub? • We are examining LAN Chile’s recent successes closely • To overcome their “end of hemisphere” disadvantage, they established branded hubs in other, more northerly parts of South America • LAN’s only hub in 2001 was Santiago • Over the next four years, they “climbed the hemisphere” with • strong Department of Transport support • a focus on weaker markets with no defending airlines • a very strong balance sheet • Today, LAN has investments in • LAN Chile (100%) • LAN Ecuador (45%) (founded 2002) • LAN Peru (70%) (2002) • LAN Dominicana (49%) (2003) • LAN Argentina (49%) (2005) • Currently, LAN is about to merge with Brazil’s TAM Page 13

  14. Strategic Exercise – Replicate Brands and Hub? • We are examining Ethiopian’s new strategy closely • Ethiopian Airlines hub Addis Ababa has a strong, almost mid-hemisphere position • Ethiopian follows a long-term growth strategy of new route development • They have grown passenger numbers 79% and freight tonnage 117% • Freight now makes up 17% of revenue • Ethiopian is expanding its geographical advantage and reach by establishing Asky in Togo, taking a 25% equity stake • Ethiopian operates to 13 of 18 Asky West and Central African destinations, including the Asky hub in Lome • This maximises feed and de-feed to both networks and draws traffic through Ethiopian’s Addis Ababa hub to their long haul network • Subject to shareholder approval, our strategic exercise is to examine whether this east-west partnership could be a model for a north-south axis involving SAA and SAX Page 14

  15. Strategic Exercise: A West African Hub? • We are looking at the feasability of a West African SAA/SAX/Mango hub • SAA and alliance partners would gain new hub in almost mid-hemisphere position • Could draw more traffic through Johannesburg • Our current ECOWAS air traffic analysis shows that • West Africa is substantially under-served • Ghana is the prime location for a potential joint venture • We are currently in discussion with the government on this possibility • Critical success factors currently under examination: • SAA would need to take a ≤49% equity stake • A sound local partner with capital • SA Express or Mango the preferred brand for market entry • SAA to increase SA-Ghana capacity for long haul feeder traffic, especially to South America, Asia, Australia • SAA subsidiaries Cargo, Technical and Air Chefs to provide skills and technology transfer to new airline and Ghana to ensure Ghanaian government support Page 15

  16. Strategic Exercise: Expanding Mango into Regional Markets? • We are looking at the feasability of expanding Mango into regional leisure markets • Mango’s low cost base makes it a very competitive airline within Africa • We have completed a flight operational evaluation of all leisure destinations within B738 range of South Africa • These include • Mauritius • Zanzibar • Kilimanjaro • Mombassa • Livingstone • Mango received an International Air Services License in September 2011 • Start of Lanseria operations on 1 June provides additional operational and commercial opportunities Mango’s use as a regional market growth tool would support the Group’s growth objectives Page 16

  17. Strategic Exercise: New Market Entry via SAA Subsidiaries? • We are looking at expanding subsidiaries into new markets as a possible • compliment to potential airline expansion • stand alone growth element • This growth strategy successfully implemented by Lufthansa and Singapore Airlines • SAA Cargo • Air cargo service are fundamental to African development • Cargo can be 20% of airline revenue, faces fewer bilateral restrictions • New route developments are planned by SAA Cargo • Air Chefs • Kenya a potential first market for our in-flight catering services • Lufthansa subsidiary LSG Skychefs already operating in many African markets, showing potetnial • SAA Technical • Initial support set-up and support for SAA /alliance partners start-ups in West Africa • Evaluating full function base facitlity by signing up maitenance agreements with local, regional and international carriers operating in and around West Africa • Plan would include scheduled/non-scheduled maintenance services and component/part logistics support Page 17

  18. African Network Performance Update • Financial Overview, African Routes: • Financial Year To Date (April – July) 2010 vs 2011 vs 2012 Comments • In FY 11/12, SAA introduced services to Ndola, Pointe-Noire, Kigali, Bujumbura, and added capacity and frequency to profitable destinations in Africa such as HRE, LUN and MPM • Overall ASK offering has remained relatively stable, with slight year on year increases. • Increase in revenue paying passengers and load factor due to increased demand in FY 11/12 • SAA has also absorbed demand following demise of Air Zimbabwe, Zambezi Airlines, and Air Malawi Page 18

  19. The Good News: We Are Growing in Africa 5 years ago... Currently… • SAA is the dominant carrier linking South Africa with the continent • We have grown this role in the last five years, our share continue to increase on regional markets Page 19

  20. SAA Presentation to Portfolio Committee on Public Enterprises 1 Africa Expansion Programme 2 Airbus Procurement 3 Hedging Page 20

  21. Airbus Procurement: Background • The initial contract was entered into with Airbus in 2002, for 15 aircraft • Contract renegotiated in 2008: • Price reductions • Five additional aircraft, bringing the order to 20 in total • Deferral of deliveries • Flexibility of choice between A320’s and A321’s • Deliveries between June 2013 and late 2017 Page 21

  22. Airbus Procurement: Financing • Financial obligations of this transaction are onerous • Various alternative financing options are being considered with a view to • transferring the acquisition price obligations of the A320s to a financier • re-financing the Pre-Delivery Payments already made by SAA Page 22

  23. Airbus Procurement: Engaging Potential Funders • Engaged with the three major European Export Credit Agencies, who provide credit services on many aircraft purchases • SAA consulted both local and international potential counter parties • We issued a Request for Proposals (RFP) on alternative financing possibilities • Responses received from a broad range of potential bidders • Responses to the RFP are currently being considered • Currently also engaging Airbus on potential alternative financing options Page 23

  24. SAA Presentation to Portfolio Committee on Public Enterprises Contents 1 Africa Expansion Programme 2 Airbus Procurement 3 Hedging Page 24

  25. What is Hedging? • Hedging is a method of reducing or protecting oneself from the risk of loss caused by price fluctuations in a specific market or commodity • Normally consists of taking positions which off-set each other • It’s a method that introduces some form of certainty in an uncertain market, in order to reduce risk • Protection normally achieved during periods of volatility • Hedging is a form of insurance to provide greater stability • But it cannot reduce fuel prices or stabilise exchange rates in the long-run Page 25

  26. Advantages and Disadvantages of Hedging • Advantages: • Creates greater price certainty • Counters short-term volatility in the market • Limits losses • Disadvantages: • Can negate positive market movements • Can be extremely costly • Not possible or advisable to hedge 100% of exposure • Realisation of losses if stop loss limits exceeded (i.e. exposure beyond the limits of what is hedged against) Page 26

  27. Major Risks Airlines Face • The most important risks exposures faced by airlines are: • Currency: • Rand weakness against major currencies affects SAA • For example, in the past year the Rand weakened by almost 20% against the US Dollar • Many costs are in Dollars or Euros (fuel, aircraft, spares) • Commodities: • Oil price rises affect all airlines • In the past financial year SAA’s fuel cost increased by R2.2 bn (36%) Page 27

  28. SAA’s Hedging Philosophy • Reduce volatility of jet fuel costs and effect this has on SAA’s cash flow and earnings • contribute to price stability • Occupy a competitive position in the industry in terms of jet fuel price risk management • negate competitive advantage competitors derive from their jet fuel risk management strategies • Hedging at SAA specific and NOT of speculative nature • Provide a protection buffer during times of very high jet fuel prices Page 28

  29. Review and Monitoring of Hedging • The Financial Risk Management Policy (including hedging policy) is reviewed annually and all stakeholders are consulted • The new hedging approach is supported by an analytical framework which allows SAA to measure the cash flow at risk from hedging • All hedge positions are monitored by the Financial and Risk Sub-committee and reported to the Executive Committee, the Audit Committee and the Board • Limits are monitored daily by the Treasury Back Office • All limits are reviewed quarterly Page 29

  30. How do we Hedge? • The hedging policy includes • Currency hedging limits • hedging net currency exposure with a maximum of 75% of future exposures • Fuel hedging limits • hedging to a maximum of 60% of budgeted exposure • maximum of 12 months forward • Hedging tools: SAA uses the Oliver Wyman model • SAA considers ‘net exposures’ to determine value at risk, which means that natural hedges are also taken into account • Hedging instruments: Options, Swaps and Forwards Page 30

  31. SAA’s Hedging Programme used Underlying exposure Duration of hedge Volumehedged Instruments used • Commodities • Jet fuel • Gas Oil • Crude • FX • USD • GBP • EUR • Current needs only • Less than 12 months • Greater than 12 months • Varied by underlying exposure • Adhere to policy • Adjust volume hedged according to market intelligence • Restructure hedges due to changes in exposure and / or risk appetite • Forwards • Swaps • Call options • Collars

  32. Industry Best Practice • Common practice for all main line carriers to hedge to some degree: • Delta Airlines 40% hedged through to 2011 • Cathay Pacific 35% to 40% hedged in 2011 (50% in 2010) • Malaysia Airlines covered 33% in 2011 (60% 2010) • Lufthansa 85% hedged with a lead time of 24 months • SAA’s policy is conservative • The approved targeted range is as follows: • Fuel - minimum 0% and Max 60% - 12 month rolling • Foreign exchange – minimum 0% and maximum 75% of future exposure Page 32

  33. Why Hedging Matters: Fuel as a % of total costs Fuel costs continue to escalate sharply as a % of total costs Page 35

  34. Fuel Prices Affect Profitability • Fuel prices heavily influence SAA’s profitability • SAA’s profits are much higher when fuel is low • Hedging allows us to mitigate this effect Page 36

  35. Hedging Lessons from the Past • More dynamic approach required towards managing risk exposure • Changing market conditionsrequire more than just taking a view without sufficient flexibility • The risk of imposing minimum hedge ratio limits – removes discretion to increase / decrease hedging ratios during times of volatility • Put more emphasis on the upside risk when reviewing market context • Simpler is better • Keep away from exotic hedging instruments. Page 39

  36. SAA Presentation to Portfolio Committee on Public Enterprises Questions? Page 40

More Related