1 / 47

Duty and Desire

Duty and Desire. Lisa Does Her Duty. Three basic questions. 1) What is the experience of morality? Duty against ordinary desires Being a dutiful person is a “higher desire” 2) How do we know what is our duty? E.g., Lisa has a duty to better herself.

mholmquist
Download Presentation

Duty and Desire

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Duty and Desire Lisa Does Her Duty

  2. Three basic questions • 1) What is the experience of morality? • Duty against ordinary desires • Being a dutiful person is a “higher desire” • 2) How do we know what is our duty? • E.g., Lisa has a duty to better herself. • 3) Are dutiful people condemned to suffer? • =The problem of justice. • People who are good ought to be happy. It’s the wicked who should suffer, not the good.

  3. Opposition/contradiction? • 1) Desires, feelings, interests (longer range desires) • First order preferences • 2) Duties, responsibilities • Second order reflection on the first order preference • Implies possibility of sacrificing first order of preferences for a “higher” order • Do the right thing!

  4. Morality presupposes desires • For the Simpson family, duty stands out in opposition to desire • If there is no conflicting desire, doing what is right is not a “duty” • E.g., it’s not a duty to enjoy a good meal. • But there’s nothing wrong with that. • Fulfilling desires is wrong only when they conflict with a duty

  5. What is the motive of the action? • I help a sick Aunt. Why? • 1) She’s fun to be around and I have nothing better to do • 2) I am hoping she will put me in her will • 3) I’d rather watch TV, but she needs the help • Morality is about inner motives for an action, not actions themselves regarded externally

  6. The moral person • Resolution, commitment, “engagement” • To do what is right rather than what she wants to do. • Hence sacrifice is implied – for persons with ordinary desires. • It’s not easy to be moral

  7. Homer rationalizes • Moe to Homer: Destroy my car so I can collect the insurance. • Homer 1) wants to please Moe; 2) wants to do what is right. • He turns to his idea of moral truth: Marge • An imaginary Marge in his mind says to him: the right thing to do is to destroy the car. • Homer’s “conscience” is satisfied

  8. Having it both ways • 1) He ought to do what is right (duty) • 2) But he also wants to please Moe (desire) • He wants to have it both ways, and avoid inner conflict • But we see that this is an illusion. • Moral of the story: don’t do as Homer does.

  9. False solutions to the dilemma • His method of solving the dilemma is comical—but also common • Rationalize, delude oneself • Other ways to do this? • Pick a moral authority who appeals to your desires and interests • Is all morality like this?

  10. Moe has little problem • Moe is not so conflicted • He puts his own desires and interests first • = He is an egotist (me first, and to heck with others) • For him the issue of duty never arises

  11. Homer and Marge: marriage on the rocks • Homer loves Marge, and wants to do what is right by his marriage and family responsibilities • but he is also impetuous and unrestrained—doing what appeals to him in the moment without thinking how this might affect her • After drinking too much, he makes a pass at Mrs. Flanders at a party • Marge: we need marriage counseling

  12. General Sherman calls • Reverend Lovejoy holds marriage counseling at Catfish Bay • Homer wants to catch General Sherman, a legendary large fish • He can do his duty to Marge and what he wants! • She catches him sneaking off to fish in the morning: the stern face of duty • Homer chooses duty, renounces fishing for Marge

  13. Homer gets what he wants anyway • Accidentally, Homer is pulled into a boat by the giant catfish • It’s not his fault! • He has the battle of a lifetime (Hemingway’s Old Man and the Sea) • The Simpsons evokes high art and literature • If we put duty first, will our desires be satisfied anyway, as if by magic?

  14. Homer chooses duty over desire • 1) Homer succeeds in catching General Sherman: • and imagines his fame when others see his prize • 2) but throws the fish back when confronted by a furious Marge • =the face of duty! (in the flesh, not imagined in his mind) • again, he chooses duty: “I gave up fame and breakfast for our marriage.”

  15. Homer’s moral guidance • He lacks internal control over his desires • Moe’s proposition (moral role of Moe?) • Homer’s “conscience” is external: Marge • But this is here a trick of his subconscious, • which is governed by his desires, rationalizing them • In presence of the real Marge he goes straight • Promises not to fish • Throws General Sherman back • His morality is external • but personal, not based on external rules

  16. Ned Flanders follows the moral rules • Ned Flanders has a marital problem with his wife: he catches her underlining in his copy of the Bible! • 1) No desires and interests of his own • 2) External basis of moral rules: divine commands written in the Bible • “External religion”

  17. Morality of Flanders • Seems to be the “super-moral” person • Goody-goody • No conflict with desires • “Flanders has no life” (episode) • Compare why Flanders is in marriage counseling with why Homer is there.

  18. Between Moe and Ned • Opposite poles or extremes • Pure egotism and pure moralism • 1) Desire without duty • 2) “Duty” (following externally based moral rules) without desire

  19. Viva Ned Flanders • Ned reveals an embarrassing fact: he is actually 60 years old • Homer: you look so young because you’ve never had a life • Ned takes Homer as his guide to living a life • > A double wedding in Las Vegas

  20. Morality of external religion • Commandments from external Source • Not internally based • Incentive of external religion is selfish • Heaven or hell? • External religion: treats people as children • That’s why Ned looks young

  21. Morality and motivation • Why do the right thing? • Because it will bring a reward and avoid a punishment? • Because it is the right thing, whatever the consequences • External religion teaches egotistical motivation • Jessica Lovejoy reveals the meaning of this

  22. Dark side of religion • Bart has a crush on Jessica Lovejoy, the minister’s daughter • So he thinks he has to go to Sunday school • But religion for her is a façade—she steals from the collection plate in church • “If you tell, no one will believe you. Remember I’m the sweet, perfect minister’s daughter, and you’re just yellow trash.”

  23. Moral hypocrisy • Jessica plays the moral/religion game • She uses external appearances of the goody-goody child for selfish purposes • Such hypocrisy seems worse than straightforward, honest egotism (Moe) • But her father’s religion suggests this, because its morality is externally based

  24. Bart’s morality • “Stealing from the collection basket is really wrong! Even I know that.” • How does he know? • Bart has limits—moral ones • He breaks some rules: external conventions • But he respects other, more serious ones: it’s wrong to steal • Not because the Bible says so

  25. Morality and mores • Mores: conventions of proper behavior • Spike your hair; make super-loud noises, use rude words • Bart loves to break these. • Teacher to Bart: “There was no Roman god named Farticus” • Indicators of social class hierarchy? • Morality: deeper requirements of social life • Stealing from honest people • Bart respects these

  26. Bart’s instinctive morality • Sources of Bart’s knowledge of morality? • Not a Book of Rules (Ned’s religion) • Not an authoritative person (Marge for Homer) • > Internal source, but not clearly thought out, like an instinct • “from his heart”

  27. Bart’s guilty conscience • “Bart the mother” • He acts on impulse without foreseeing consequences (like father like son) • Accidentally kills mother bird • Becomes their mother: • he feels guilt after the fact, and tries to make recompense • He sees a duty here, and sacrifices his normal pleasures

  28. Fickleness of public morality (that’s us) • Bart has fun like a healthy boy. “Good Bart!” • Bart accidentally kills the mother bird. “Bad Bart!” • (He aims his gun to miss, but the gun is crooked) • Bart wants to help the unborn baby birds. “Good Bart!” • The birds turn out to be lizards that kill lots of birds, but Mother Bart protects them. “Bad Bart!” • They are his “children”—it doesn’t matter that they kill other’s children • Other examples of this outlook? • The birds that the lizards kill are just those pesky pigeons. “Good Bart!”

  29. Consequentialist, utilitarian morality • Morality of action is determined by its consequences. • The public (is that us?) judges this way—consequences for itself. • The morality therefore shifts with the unfolding consequences: bad, good, bad, good …

  30. Lisa’s critique of Bart • “I don't get it, Bart. You got all upset when you killed one bird, but now you've killed tens of thousands, and it doesn't bother you at all.” • =Lisa looks at the principle of the action and demands consistency • I.e., logic, reason • She gives an argument for why Bart’s actions are not moral—i.e., are morally wrong. • What is Lisa’s moral approach?

  31. Duties … to whom? • Is morality = altruism? • There are duties to self, as well as to others. • How can there be a “duty” to oneself? • Conventional mores: housewife, serving others • Feminism: duty to self as well • Standing up for oneself can be difficult • it goes against thousands of years of patriarchal society

  32. Marge as feminist Conventional housewife Serves husband and children, That’s her (conventional) duty! Externally imposed morality but wants a larger life for herself Is that “selfish”? Or is there a duty to oneself? At first this is a desire, but then when difficulties emerge, it becomes a duty

  33. Two radically different perspectives Marge’s first words on hearing Lionel’s job offer, and Lionel’s reply: Marge: Helping people find homes.. that must be really rewarding! Lionel: Yes, the money’s good, but the beauty is, you get to stay in the house until it's sold! Morality v. self-interest

  34. Conflicting motives • Lionel’s motive: self-interest, to make money no matter what the cost • Marge’s motive: to help her friends, even if it means not to make a sale • She will not tell a lie to make a sale • But what about “bending the truth,” or hiding it?

  35. Two mottos or maxims • Marge: “Well, like we say, ‘The right house for the right person!’” • Lionel: “Listen, it’s time I let you in on a little secret, Marge. The right house is the house that’s for sale. The right person is anyone.” • -> Moral hypocrisy • Moral slogans in advertising?

  36. Problem of truth • Marge: “But all I did was tell the truth!” • Lionel: “Of course you did.” “But there’s the truth” (here he frowns and shakes his head negatively) “and the truth” (here he looks cheerful and shakes his head positively.) • > Lionel plays a game with the truth (hypocrisy)

  37. Underlying social conditions • Competitive economy > bottom line • Individualism of “homo economicus” • Circumstances seem to require and reward self-interest or selfishness, and punish honesty, helping others (duty)

  38. Marge’s choice (1) • 1) Be a “closer” and “bend” the truth • 2) Tell the whole truth and lose your job • But Marge believes she needs the job to prove her worth as a person • To realize a duty to self, can she betray her duty to others? • Problem of moral conflicts: I fulfill one duty and violate another

  39. Marge’s choice (2) • She makes the sale to the gullible Flanders family by hiding the secrets of the house • Gruesome murder • She looks at her check • Symbol of success as a person? • But not at the expense of the truth, of friendship, of duty • She decides to tell the truth, and offers the check back

  40. Is honesty the best policy? • The Flanders are delighted to hear about the murders • She tells the truth, and she gets the reward • Isn’t this how life should work? • Do what is right (because it is right) and get rewarded for it • = Justice

  41. The Highest Good • 1) Do the right thing in order to get the reward • 2) Do the right thing because it is the right thing • And suffer for it? • And be rewarded for it? • Marge does the right thing, and gets rewarded

  42. The Just Society • A society in which • people who do their duty are rewarded • And those who violate it are punished • Happiness, satisfaction of desire, is not the motive of duty • But the consequence of it • Highest duty (Kant) = to create a society in which this is the general rule

  43. Exception that proves the rule • Marge does her duty, and gets rewarded • Conforms to her original intention • Belies Lionel’s bottom line philosophy • = This is an exception to the rule • Those who are successful are the ones with the “killer instinct” (says Lisa), such as Cookie

  44. Marge does the right thing, and suffers for it • Reality intervenes in this idyll of Justice in the form of Homer • He crashes his car into the house and it is destroyed • Marge tears up the check she got from the Flanders • =She does the right thing, and suffers for it • Is this the way it has to be?

  45. Marge is one of a kind. Why? • Marge does her duty • As a result she is fired • Marge: I'm sorry, Mr. Hutz, but I just can't lie to people! • Lionel: You're one of a kind, Marge!

  46. The Just Society anyway? • But her family acclaims her: they love her all the more • Lisa: I'm proud of you, mom. You refused to compromise your integrity! • Lisa’s morality? • Bart: Yeah, you did the right thing... eventually. • Is the Simpson family an example of a just society?

  47. Final comment • Marge: $300 unemployment check for doing nothing? “I feel like such a crook.” • What is the morality of our social welfare state? • Versus pure capitalism • = Unjust to get something for nothing? • Review the nature of the Highest Good

More Related