1 / 21

Industrial Organization

Industrial Organization. Econometric Identification. A central issue in IO. Estimate demand (and/or supply) parameters For example: 1/b is the price elasticity of demand. A common exercise is to infer market power using b , because:. Maybe unobservable. The Problem, more generally.

merv
Download Presentation

Industrial Organization

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Industrial Organization Econometric Identification

  2. A central issue in IO • Estimate demand (and/or supply) parameters • For example: • 1/b is the price elasticity of demand. A common exercise is to infer market power using b, because: Maybe unobservable.

  3. The Problem, more generally • Empirical economists mainly concerned with identification • Understanding what is the causal relationship between variables • This is perhaps the MOST important issue in empirical work • “Correlations are a good place to start but not a good place end.”

  4. The Problem • Identification problems come in different flavors: • Structural models: Example is identifying demand slope. Would regressing quantity on price tell us something reliable (theoretically)? • Policy questions: • Does increasing number of policemen decrease crime? • Does the government interest rate affect GDP? • Management questions: • Does the type of management affect productivity?

  5. Does this mean demand slopes up? $ Q

  6. Correlation v. Causation • Let’s assume variables Yt and Xt are correlated • How do we make sure we have causation? (i.e. are we measuring something meaningful?) • Key assumption in OLS regression: • E(u|x)=0 • Also known as the “orthogonality” condition

  7. Ways to Achieve E(u|x) • Experiments – you generate the x • Natural Experiments – nature (or luck) generates the x for you • Instrumental variables – if E(u|x)=0 is violated, you look (and find!) a z that can proxy for x and complies with E(u|z)=0

  8. Experiments • Experiments are standard in Science & Medicine • For example: • Set up a treatment and control group for a new drug, making sure these are comparable (or randomly selected) • Ensure the sample sizes are large enough to obtain statistical significance • Ensure there are no confounding effects: i.e. placebo and treatment groups are treated equally in every respect (except for “injection”) • Run the experiment and compare the differential effects.

  9. Experiments • Hypothetical example (1): • Choose two similar regions (e.g. Portici and Naples) • Increase police force in Naples, keep the same in Portici • Look at how much crime decreased in Naples, after accounting for common crime trends (provided by control group – Portici)

  10. Experiments • Hypothetical example (2): • Interested in the effect of entry on prices (or performance) • Randomly “mandate” that a new firm enters several industries in Italy • Measure the effect of entry (or new concentration) on prices (or performance)

  11. Experiments (Lab and Field) • Experiments are rare in economics, they are expensive. Although they are becoming more popular: • Development economics – cheaper to run experiments in the third World • Consumer economics – small stakes experiments that are easy to administer • Individual business applications – firms can finance these

  12. Natural Experiments • Fortunate situations that allow identification • Essence is similar to experiments, but not as ideal • There might be confounding effects because the experiment was not designed for our purposes • Example: Beer tax • In January 1991, beer tax doubled from $9 to $18/ barrel, increasing all brewers’ marginal cost by the same amount • Unfortunately, there is no control group, but you can study firm behavior (for example) • How are costs passed-through consumers?

  13. Natural Experiments • Example: Want to understand the impact of small firms employment tax credit • Assume credit introduced in 2000 for firms with 250 or less employees • So could look at firms before and after credit • But other things also changing (2000 peak of dotcom boom, etc.) • So need to set up a control group of companies look similar to firms getting the credit except don’t get the credit • Compare firms with 240 employees to those with 260 • Compare differences: • Between pre and post the credit (1999 versus 2001) • Between the treated (240 employees) and untreated firms (260 employees)

  14. Instrumental Variables • Assume estimating equation below in Ordinary Least Squares: Y = βX + u • The estimate of βo = (X’X)-1X’Y = (X’X)-1X’ (βX + u) E(βo) = β + E(u’X)/E(X’X) = β only if u and X are independent • But if u and X are correlated then the estimated is biased, and X is called “endogenous” (correlated with the error)

  15. Instrumental Variables • Thus, estimation of the following demand equation would be biased: Qi = a + b1 Pi + ui because Pi and ui are correlated (due to simulteneity) E[b1]≠b1 • Because we ignore simultaneity (supply and demand usually move together), this makes the error term correlated with price and we get a biased estimate of the demand slope.

  16. Instrumental Variables • Imagine we had a variable – called an instrument Z – that was correlated with price but not with the demand error term (ui). • Basically, what we want is to come up with a variable that gives us the equivalent of an experiment: • In the case of demand, we can use supply shifters: • Cost shock (e.g. technological shock) • Weather?

  17. Instrumental Variables • In the case of schooling and earnings (where ability is unobserved), one could use a variable such as “born on Tuesday” (Government told everyone born on Tuesday to spend 1 more year in school)

  18. Instrumental Variables • In practice instruments are often hard to find. • IV’s are central to empirical work that we will see in this class. • No good instruments = unreliable inference.

  19. Instrumental Variables • In practice instruments are often hard to find. • IV’s are central to empirical work that we will see in this class. • No good instruments = unreliable inference.

  20. Experiments • Hypothetical example (1): • Monopolist knows demand will not move for 1 month • Changes prices every day • Records the quantity sold at each price • Unrealistic example but doable (i.e. controlling for trends, seasonalities, etc.)

More Related