1 / 24

Strength of Weak Ties in Microfinance

Strength of Weak Ties in Microfinance. PhD Research Sponsored by the Leverhulme Trust Cornell Jackson. Background. Part of Leverhulme Research Project looking at microfinance & social networks PhD Research focused on the networks of microfinance clients

matty
Download Presentation

Strength of Weak Ties in Microfinance

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Strength of Weak Ties in Microfinance PhD Research Sponsored by the Leverhulme Trust Cornell Jackson

  2. Background • Part of Leverhulme Research Project looking at microfinance & social networks • PhD Research focused on the networks of microfinance clients • Research hosted by Bullock Cart Workers Development Association (BWDA) located in Tamil Nadu, India

  3. Social Network Analysis Definition • Social networks are defined and measured as connections among people, organisations, political entities (states and nations) and/or other units. • Social networks are so important is because human beings are ultra-social animals that create social networks (Haidt, 2006) • Social network analysis is a theoretical perspective and a set of techniques used to understand these relationships (Valente 2010).

  4. Social Network Analysis Definition • Social Network Analysis Definition (Freeman, 2004) • Social network analysis is motivated by a structural intuition based on ties linking social actors, • It is grounded in systematic empirical data, • It draws heavily on graphic imagery, and • It relies on the use of mathematical and/or computational models

  5. Social Network Analysis Concepts • Small World Networks • Scale Free Networks • Network Dynamics (individual, network) • Social Capital • Homophily • Diffusion/Contagion • Centrality • Efficient Network Forms • Interventions

  6. Reach of Connection and Influence • Christakis and Fowler (2010) propose the following: • Connection – Six degrees of separation (Travers & Milgram (1969), Dodds, Muhamad and Watts(2003)) • Influence – Three degrees of separation • Intrinsic Decay Explanation • Network Instability Explanation • Evolutionary Purpose Explanation

  7. Visualisations – Who Does the Most Work?

  8. Visualisation – Who Does the Most Work?

  9. Theoretical Background • Strength of Weak Ties (Granovetter, 1973) • Reliance of the poor on strong ties (Granovetter, 1983) • Structural Holes (Burt, 1992) • Brokerage & Closure (Burt, 2005) • Spillover (Burt, 2010) • Social Intermediation (Edgcomb & Barton, 1998) • Inclusive Value Chains (Harper, 2010) • Power Distance Index (Hofstede, 1984)

  10. Research Questions • How does a MFI help its clients bridge structural holes? • How can MFIs socially intermediate to help clients establish weak bridging ties?

  11. Methodology • Population – 111 Sari Sellers MFI Clients in Tamil Nadu • Links to: • Suppliers • Financial Sources • Customers • Market Information • Reverse Small World Method – Who would you talk to first? • More customers • Make your business better • To find info on upcoming weddings and festivals • Kanchipuram Silk Question

  12. Methodology – Cont’d • Social Intermediation – Non-Financial Aid • Jati • Financials • Progress Out of Poverty Index (PPI)

  13. Results • Large reliance on strong ties • The internal network of BWDA, like most Indian organisations, has most links to and from the centre • Very few ties that cross the links to and from the centre • While only 5% of the population, animators (SHG leaders) are 55% of the sari sellers interviewed.

  14. Results – Cont’d • Definition of Strong Ties (Trust): • Finance – Non-collateral loans • Supplier – Credit provided • Relationships – Family, Friends, Neighbours or Long-term • Customers – Relationship > 1 year

  15. Methodology – Cont’d • Kanchipuram Silk Sari Question

  16. Visualisation – Target Method

  17. Preliminary Interpretations • Poor depend mainly on strong ties. Mainly due to insecurity (Granovetter, 1983) • Indian hierarchical cultural ecosystems encourages “command and control” network structures • Sari sellers’ networks are fragile and easy to fragment • Context is important. These sari sellers do not recognise and take advantage of brokerage opportunities • South Railway Colony • Kanchipuram Silk Sari Question • Animators get the most training from BWDA.

  18. Network Fragmentation I

  19. Network Fragmentation II

  20. Network Fragmentation III

  21. Network Fragmentation IV

  22. Intervention • Pilot Test • Attempt to get sari sellers to build weak bridging ties with other sari sellers and see how these impact business, networks and PPI • Use information and skills sari sellers want to entice bridge building • Villupuram treatment group and Pondicherry the control group • Assumption: BWDA internal network is a safe place to build weak, bridging ties

  23. Intervention • Sari sellers have agreed to form an association as a result of this research. • BWDA is seriously consider buying saris in bulk for sari sellers. Will not be part of PhD research. But shows how spillover could work.

  24. Contribution • If research questions can be answered successfully, microfinance institutions in India can help their clients develop the weak, bridging ties that could help increase their businesses and their poverty reduction.

More Related