1 / 19

Functional Separation: The UK Experience

Functional Separation: The UK Experience. Seminar on the Creation of a Competitive Environment in the Telecoms Sector Karen Northey Director, Global Government Affairs BT Global Services. Overview. BT’s undertakings Functional Separation Equivalence of Input Independent Oversight

marvina
Download Presentation

Functional Separation: The UK Experience

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Functional Separation: The UK Experience Seminar on the Creation of a Competitive Environment in the Telecoms Sector Karen Northey Director, Global Government Affairs BT Global Services

  2. Overview • BT’s undertakings • Functional Separation • Equivalence of Input • Independent Oversight • The Undertaking 3 years later • The “myths” of Functional Separation

  3. Ofcom’s Telecommunications Strategic Review (TSR) • Phase 1 Assessment and prospects .2 months consultation from April 2004 • Phase 2: Options “The current market and regulatory structure is unsustainable” 2 months consultation from November 2004 • February 2005 BT proposes detailed Undertakings. • February to June Undertakings refined in discussion with Ofcom • June 2005 Ofcom consult on proposed Undertakings • June - September BT and Ofcom review Undertakings in light of industry response. • Phase 3: September 2005 Final Statements and Undertakings

  4. Primary Issues • Competition is restricted in wholesale markets for access and backhaul services • BT has substantial wholesale market power and is a vertically integrated provider with a presence in the directly related retail markets • this combination gives BT the ability and the incentive to discriminate against downstream competitors who are also wholesale customers

  5. Key elements of BT’s Undertakings • Functional Separation – Openreach • Equivalence of inputs (EoI) with Transparency and separate accounting • Independent audit and oversight • Legally binding - breaches can lead to: • Directions from Ofcom &/or court enforcement • Reference to the Competition Commission • Third party action for damages

  6. Functional Separation – the UK Model • Key elements of BT’s Undertakings • Establishment of “functionally separate” business unit: Openreach • Focus on key access and backhaul bottlenecks • Provision on an equivalence of inputs (EoI) basis • Transparency, information sharing constraints and duty of confidentiality • Clear separation between upstream and downstream divisions: operational separation, systems separation, asset register split and accounting separation • Independent oversight and enforcement • Next Generation Networks to be implemented in an “equivalent” manner • Equivalence of Input • Same products & services • Same time-scales, Ts and Cs, incl. price • Same systems & processes • Same reliability & performance • Same commercial information • Subject only to trivial or agreed differences

  7. Scale and scope of Openreach Customer premises ~26m homes Local Telephone Exchange 5,600 Core Node. DistributionPoint (DP)~8m poles Main Primary Distribution Secondary Connection Point Connection Point CP Core Node Frame ~90,000 cabinets LLUO Space Line Card Overheadand underground distribution BTW Core Node E-side Cables D-side Cables Backplate of NTE Backhaul products Copper Cables openreach Openreach is also responsible for all duct, access fibre and copper & fibre backhaul Regulated asset value c.£ 9.6 billion Demarcation Points

  8. Openreach- product set • Wholesale Analogue Line Rental • customer access for analogue voice services • Wholesale ISDN2 and ISDN 30 Line Rental • customer access for digital voice services • Local Loop Unbundling (full and shared) • copper pairs • Wholesale Extension Service • Ethernet partial private circuits from customer to first exchange • Backhaul Extension Service • Ethernet partial private circuits from first exchange to POP or second exchange

  9. Equivalence of Inputs The same: • products & services for BT & others • time-scales, terms & conditions, incl. price • systems & processes • reliability & performance • commercial information and influence Backed by • Enhanced monitoring • Separate management incentives • Transparent accounting Creating a pro-competitive incentive structure

  10. Independent Monitoring and Oversight • Equality of Access Board • Monitors, reports and advises on BT’s compliance with the Undertakings; • Chaired by BT Group non-exec director, with three independent members plus one senior BT manager • reports directly to BT Group plc Board • reports annually to Ofcom and publishes a summary report as part of BT’s annual compliance report • Ofcom • Quarterly implementation reports • Annual Report on impact of TSR

  11. Openreach: Organisation and governance • Equality of Access Board • Monitors, reports and advises on BT’s compliance with the Undertakings • Chaired by BT Group non-exec director, with three independent members plus one senior BT manager • reports directly to BT Group plc Board • reports annually to Ofcom and publishes a summary report as part of BT’s annual compliance report • Ofcom • Existing regulatory and competition frameworkremains • Review implementation plus agree anyUndertakings variations

  12. The Undertakings – 3 Years Later

  13. Separation +3: Financial performance

  14. Separation +3: Market and Regulatory Impacts • Clear focus on access and backhaul network • Improved service levels • Greater transparency and confidence for our customers • Regulation focused on bottlenecks with scope for downstream deregulation • Clear incentives for BT and industry to invest and innovate • Openreach provides platform for development of NGA products and services

  15. The “Myths” of Functional Separation

  16. The Myths of Functional Separation • Destroys the efficiency of vertical integration • Where is the evidence that a vertically integrated incumbent is efficient? • Many businesses choose: outsourcing, right-sourcing • Suppresses investment • Return on investment is determined independent of FS • Greater certainty supports wider investment from incumbent and entrants • Suppresses investment in fibre • UK is leading in fibre deployment • UK committed to green-fields FTTP on an EOI basis – no “Regulatory Holidays” • Creates a monopoly • EOI only for enduring bottlenecks – i.e. exiting monopoly • Entrants free to invest where opportunities exist / business case work

  17. The Myths of Functional Separation 5. Duct sharing is a better alternative • Practical issues rule it out for more than a select few • How is equivalence of access to be delivered? FS? 6. Too costly • To whom ? Costs of competition always “too costly” when imposed • Incremental cost of EOI not significant vs other systems costs 7. Destroys the share value of the incumbent • Ask the shareholders and the analysts • Not the experience of BT 8. Eliminates jobs and results in worse pay and conditions • Openreach: increased number of employees employed, increased the value of individual remuneration provided

  18. For more information • About BT’s Undertakings to Ofcom • http://www.undertakingsbulletin.com • Ofcom • http://www.ofcom.org.uk/telecoms/btundertakings/ • About the EAB • http://www.btplc.com/Thegroup/Theboard/Boardcommittees/EqualityofAccessBoard/EqualityofAccessBoard.htm • Office of the Telecoms Adjudicator http://www.offta.org.uk/

  19. Thank you

More Related