Decision making in the context of the administrative sanctions procedure
1 / 31

Decision Making in the Context of the Administrative Sanctions Procedure - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

  • Uploaded on

Decision Making in the Context of the Administrative Sanctions Procedure. A programme for Inquiry Members of the Financial Service Regulatory Authority 19 and 26 May, 2007 G Brian Hutchinson, BCL LLM DAL FCIArb BL Vice Dean, School of Law. Award Writing in Arbitrations.

I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about 'Decision Making in the Context of the Administrative Sanctions Procedure' - marina

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
Decision making in the context of the administrative sanctions procedure

Decision Making in the Context of the Administrative Sanctions Procedure

A programme for Inquiry Members of the Financial Service Regulatory Authority

19 and 26 May, 2007

G Brian Hutchinson, BCL LLM DAL FCIArb BL

Vice Dean, School of Law

Award writing in arbitrations
Award Writing in Arbitrations Sanctions Procedure

Preparing to write the award decision
Preparing to Write The Award (Decision) Sanctions Procedure

  • Remember the Substantive Requirements:

    • Cogent

    • Complete

    • Certain

    • Final

    • Enforceable

Summarising the claims
Summarising the Claims Sanctions Procedure

Status of the decision
Status of the Decision Sanctions Procedure

  • Final?

  • Interim on some heads of claim?

  • Interim on Liability?

  • Final?

  • Suggestion that Specific Performance Awards should be interim?

Presentation of the case
Presentation of the Case Sanctions Procedure

  • Formal Pleadings?

  • Statement of Case?

  • Scott Schedule?

  • Correspondence?

Proof: Sanctions Procedure

  • Burden of Proof:

    • he who asserts must prove

    • Normally claimant

  • Standard of Proof

    • more likely than not.

    • Equal, then fails.

The factual evidence
The Factual Evidence Sanctions Procedure

  • Documents and Witnesses

  • Is witness testimony consistent and coherent?

  • Is reaction under cross-examination convincing?

Opinion evidence
Opinion Evidence Sanctions Procedure

  • Are experts qualified?

  • What common ground is there?

  • Has expert remained impartial?

Points of law
Points of Law Sanctions Procedure

  • Are relevant authorities cited?

  • Are they biding or merely persuasive?

  • Where there is conflict, which comes closest to the case?

  • Has a full report of each authority been produced?

Closing points
Closing Points Sanctions Procedure

  • Can provide a useful starting point and agenda for writing the award.

Costs Sanctions Procedure

  • Do they follow the event

  • What is the event?

    • Offers? Nature of the offer?

  • Are there any interlocutory matters which could affect costs?

  • Give reasons for unusual award of costs.

  • Costs of the Reference

  • Costs of the Award

Reasons Sanctions Procedure

  • All that is required is that arbitrators should set out what, in their view of the evidence, did or did not happen and should explain succinctly why, in the light of what happened, they have reached their decision and what that decision is. That is all that’s meant by “reasoned award”. -Bremer Handelsgesellschaft v. Westzucker (No. 2) [1981] 2 Lloyd’s, per Donaldson LJ.

  • (In the Meadowsweet v. Bindweed handout)

Reasoned awards
Reasoned Awards Sanctions Procedure

  • “ A reasoned award is one which states the reasons for the award in sufficient detail for the court to consider any question of law arising therefrom” . “The Ninemia” [1986] QB 802

  • Note context, however.

Reasoning Sanctions Procedure



Fact or Law?




Identification & Evaluation

Submissions, Authorities, Application

Finding / Holding

Final check by analogy
Final Check (by analogy): Sanctions Procedure

  • Have all heads of claim been dealt with?

  • Have all heads of counterclaim been dealt with?

  • Has anything which was not claimed been awarded?

  • Has interest been properly dealt with?

  • Have the costs of the reference been dealt with?

  • Have the costs of the award been dealt with?

Drafting the decision
Drafting the Decision Sanctions Procedure

Remember the formal requirements particularly
Remember the Formal Requirements, particularly Sanctions Procedure:

  • Writing

  • Reasons

  • Recitals

  • Date

  • Signature

Pointer: Sanctions Procedure

  • “There are nine and sixty ways of constructing tribal lays and every single one of them is right” - Kipling.

Heading: Sanctions Procedure

In the matter of the Arbitration Acts 1954 to 1998,

and in the matter of an Arbitration







Sub heading
Sub-Heading: Sanctions Procedure

  • Final Award

  • Interim Award

  • Second Interim Award

  • Final Consent Award

Introduction Sanctions Procedure

  • Recitals: “Whereas…”

  • Remember Christopher Brown v. Genossenschaft Osterreichiser, particularly:

    • Agreement (set-out, mention rules)

    • Dispute within Scope (more to follow)

    • Arbitrator Appointed (say how and when accepted)

Identify procedure adopted
Identify Procedure Adopted Sanctions Procedure

  • pleadings

  • meetings

  • discovery

  • (Think Costs – were they reserved or were costs awarded “in any event?”)

Outline of dispute
Outline of Dispute Sanctions Procedure

  • Could be taken from the pleadings.

  • Short approach quite acceptable:

    • “The claimant claims:

      • £73,798 for loss and expense allegedly incurred as a direct consequence of delay and disruption to its work by the respondents

      • £6,196.25 for reimbursement of monies allegedly wrongfully deducted from valuation no 3.

      • Interest

      • Costs

    • “The Respondent denies any of the relief sought by the claimant and counterclaims:

      • etc…”

Summarising the evidence
Summarising the Evidence Sanctions Procedure

  • “First, even where a judge knows that the losing party is almost bound to appeal, the prospect of appeal has no effect on the contents of the judgment. Second, it is not necessary – and probably not even desirable – that an arbitrator should attempt, as a judge does, to summarise the evidence given by the parties on each disputed factual issue. Nor, save perhaps where the arbitrator has been asked before making his award to set out in his reasons the evidence upon which a particular finding of fact is based, should the arbitrator set out all the relevant evidence on a point.” – Lord Justice Bingham, in an address to the CIArb.

Giving your reasons
Giving your reasons Sanctions Procedure

  • State the Issue & its Significance

  • Mention the Evidence or Submissions

  • Evaluate the evidence or apply the law

  • State your decision.

  • (Alternatives…)

Giving your reasons1
Giving your reasons Sanctions Procedure

  • O’Reilly & Sfaniaki 66 Arbitration 79

    • Advise the parties:

      • Why the winning party one AND

      • Why the losing party lost (on what basis were their contentions rejected?)

    • Explain the legal reasons

      • Normally requested to fuel appeal.

Award Sanctions Procedure

  • “having considered the evidence and the submissions adduced by and on behalf of the parties I HEREBY PUBLISH MY FINAL AWARD:”

  • Analytical approach to each claim and counterclaim most useful.

  • “I Hereby award and Direct that...”

  • “Full and final satisfaction”

  • Time for Payment?

Costs Sanctions Procedure

  • Of Reference, liability not quantum

  • Of Award, liability and Quantum?

Final formalities
Final Formalities: Sanctions Procedure

  • Signature

  • Date

  • Witnesses

  • Place