1 / 42

Criminal Investigation

Criminal Investigation. Interview Process Part 8. Interview Process. Interview application - questioning people - cooperative a. Purpose - obtain knowledge - interview / physical evidence - most cases rely on both b. Goal. Interview, cont.

ktrader
Download Presentation

Criminal Investigation

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Criminal Investigation Interview Process Part 8

  2. Interview Process • Interview application - questioning people - cooperative a. Purpose - obtain knowledge - interview / physical evidence - most cases rely on both b. Goal

  3. Interview, cont. - identify those responsible - eliminate the innocent c. Information received: - prove elements - provide leads • Three primary sources: a. People - complainant: reported crime / incident

  4. Interview, cont. - witness: some information - victim: person injured - informant: personal benefit / desire - suspect: can be / cooperative b. Physical evidence - suspect items on victim - victim items on suspect - suspect items at scene

  5. Interview, cont. c. Reports / records - information source - police records - other records • Preparation - establish rapport - maintain privacy - psychological advantage - quiet interview room

  6. Preparation, cont. a. Verbal behavior analysis - listen - not just what / but how - timing / rate / pitch / clarity - truthful attitude vs. deceptive attitude b. Truthful - spontaneous - helpful - concerned - sincere

  7. Preparation, cont. c. Deceptive - guarded - unhelpful - unconcerned - insincere (1) Truthful - sincere / direct / spontaneous / no delay / realistic words / consistent / no qualifications

  8. Preparation, cont. (2) Deceptive - delay response / evasive / rapid pace / talk unclearly / change pitch / levity or nervous laughter / bolster answers / sophisticated • Witness interview - interview separately - victim / complainant - eyewitnesses - others

  9. Preparation, cont. a. Time / place - may not have opportunity b. Identify - keep separate - confidential - not used / unless court c. Reactions - may forget - change story

  10. Beginning Interview • How starts / very important a. Size each other up - police: understand witness - witness: holding back b. Establish barriers - our own space - officer encroachment - officer attitude

  11. Beginning, cont. c. Friendly / professional - smile / apologize - identify / identification d. Rapport - friend - not adversary - understanding - non-judgmental - good listener

  12. Interview Techniques • Location - interview room - home of witness - not at workplace a. Small talk - put at ease - safe / comfortable b. Reciprocity

  13. Techniques, cont. - exchange of information - part of investigation c. Deception - be truthful - only when necessary d. Listen / empathize - show concern - there to help

  14. Techniques, cont. e. Help recall events - do not suggest answers - guide answers f. Choose questions - keep short - confined g. Point out conflicts - statements from others - not change mind / influence

  15. Techniques, cont. h. Be observant - signs of lying - initial statement i. Body language - be conscious of • Interview Guidelines a. One question - do not confuse

  16. Guidelines, cont. - no multiple questions b. Responses simple / direct - do not ramble - or compare c. Avoid “yes” or “no” questions - narrative - reveal inconsistencies d. Positive approach

  17. Guidelines, cont. e. Be positive - let “save face” f. Time to answer - ask - not demanding g. Listen - understand - repeat if necessary - prepare from response

  18. Guidelines, cont. h. Body language / tone of voice - anger or offend - want cooperation i. Neutral territory - how they feel - you know j. Caution recording - agree - pertinent information

  19. Guidelines, cont. k. React - notes / head nod / verbal inclinations - important l. Professional distance - no personal involvement • Direct / indirect questions - two types to ask a. Direct

  20. Guidelines, cont. - to the point b. Indirect - skirts the issue • Two sources of information a. Investigative - witness saw / heard - establish alibi - validity of statements made

  21. Information, cont. b. Behavioral - posture / attitude - hand / leg movements - eye contact - way statements made (1) Person telling truth - fear of detection (2) Innocent person fears - not believed

  22. Information, cont. - retribution - loss of esteem c. Privacy - important element - exists in the mind (1) Isolation best - not necessary - no time / location

  23. Information, cont. (2) Separate on street - back to back (3) Demeanor - talk softly - reassure confidentiality (4) Officer appearance - interested - approachable - non-judgmental

  24. Body Language • When questions asked a. Barriers - folded arms / crossed or extended legs - timing important - incriminating questions b. Protective gestures - elbow on desk - hand on chin / over mouth - hide eyes

  25. Language, cont. c. Grooming gestures - picking lent - smooth hair - straighten tie • Non-verbal illustrations a. Untruthful - use hands to illustrate - clarify / recreate activity - truthful don’t use

  26. Language, cont. b. Deceptive posture - non-frontal - hand on chin / arms crossed - rigid / retracted feet - sitting on hands - slouched / feet extended - position unchanging - static c. Eye contact - 30 % to 60 %

  27. Language, cont. (1) Truthful - mutual gaze - direct eye contact (1) Deceptive - incriminating questions - look away • Evaluate attitude a. Truthful person

  28. Attitude, cont. - anxious to resolve - freely discuss (suspicions / theories / and speculations) b. Deceptive person - reluctant (1) No crime occurred - making up story - self-committed (suicide) - money will turn up

  29. Attitude, cont. (2) Volunteer nothing - careful thought / words used - overly friendly / polite b. Evaluate responses - attempt to avoid anxiety - avoidance means: verbal / nonverbal c. Four possible responses - truth / omission / evasion / denial

  30. Attitude, cont. - example: “Did you steal the $5000.00?” (1) Truth: “Yes, I did.” (2) Omission: No verbal response (3) Evasion: “Why would I do that? I like my job too much.” (4) Denial: “No, I did not.”

  31. Attitude, cont. • Anxiety - omission / evasion = than denial a. Evasive answer: “Did you shoot the victim?” - “I was home all day.” - “I don’t even own a gun.” b. Speak in irrational manner - fragmented / incomplete sentences - “It’s important that . . . , if you think . . . , I hope that you . . . .”

  32. Attitude, cont. c. Feign memory failure / half-lie - “I don’t remember.” - “As far as I know.” - “I don’t recall.” d. Bolster answer - “To be perfectly honest with you, . . . .” - “To be quite frank, . . . .” e. Sophisticated answer - they have thought about their answer

  33. Attitude, cont. - “At this point in time, . . . .” - “I may be mistaken, but . . . .” f. Use of religion - “I swear to God.” - “As God is my witness.” - “I swear on a stack of bibles.” • Nonverbal responses / behavior - body movement / position change / gestures / facial expressions / eye contact

  34. Nonverbal, cont. - communication level: more than ½ nonverbal a. Verbal statements - carefully thought out - conscious control b. Do not pay attention - physical movements / gestures - more than ½ of meaning c. Examples:

  35. Nonverbal, cont. (1) Suspect: “Did you commit the robbery?” - Firm voice: “Absolutely not, I had nothing to do with it.” - leans forward / open posture / maintain eye contact - shows sincerity / directness (2) Suspect 2: same question - weak voice: “No, I . . . , it wasn’t . . . , I didn’t do it.” - shifts position / cross arms / look away - shows deception

  36. Nonverbal, cont. d. Posture / attitude - forms foundation (1) Evaluating posture - reflects: emotions / interest level / confidence (2) Truthful person - high interest / emotionally involved / expresses confidence

  37. Nonverbal, cont. (3) Deceptive person - emotionally withdrawn - preoccupied - less interest - lacks confidence • Time considerations - most fundamental concept - indicators of deception a. Occurs in 4 stages

  38. Time, cont. - during questions / response (1) First stage - asking of questions by investigator - person interpreting contents - obvious threat to them - form verbal response (2) Second stage - “response latency” - last word question / first word response

  39. Time, cont. (3) Third stage - subject responding to question (4) Fourth stage - post response period - completes verbal response - still exhibits nonverbal indicators (a) Relief interview is over (b) Concern whether believed or not

  40. Time, cont. b. Factors affecting nonverbal behavior - individual’s personality (1) Level of socialization - educational - interaction with others - people interact with (2) Motivation - what is right - unfriendly witness

  41. Time, cont. - want to get suspect arrested (3) Psychological problems - mentally incompetent (4) Physiological problems - alcoholic / drug addict (5) Emotional state - family member killed - accomplice killed by police

  42. Time, cont. c. Behavioral analysis - valid / reliable means - not 100% (1) Evaluate behavior - findings not support guilt - view with caution (2) Exhibit truthful indicators - findings show guilt - pathological liar

More Related