340 likes | 463 Views
This report examines hurricane intensity, frequency, and duration based on historical data from 1851 to 2006. It explores relationships between maximum wind velocity, minimum central pressure, and landfall patterns, providing Chi-squared statistics and regression analyses. The findings suggest no consistent pattern of increased hurricane frequency or strength, challenge existing theories on global warming's impact on hurricanes, and emphasize the complexities of hurricane formation. The analysis raises questions about measurement techniques and the dynamics influencing storm behavior.
E N D
TEAM TERMINATOR Brian Novak Michael Cleaver Danny Ohrn Emily Ramage
TEAM TERMINATOR • Strength • Power • Frequency • Duration
However, the actual hurricane data tells a different story… Hurricane Intensity as a Function of Maximum Wind Velocity
Chi-Squared Sum Statistic 203.394 Chance Probability 0.0055
Chi-Squared Sum Statistic 3.4198Critical Value for p=0.01 32.00Chance Probability 0.9997
Slopes of Expected Value Regressions 1851-1899 -0.0722 Knots/Year 1900-1949 0.707 Knots/Year 1950-2006 -0.219 Knots/Year
Hurricane Intensity as a Function of Minimum Central Pressure
Chi-Squared Sum Statistic 25.8697 Chance Probability 1.000
Chi-Squared Sum Statistic 0.48922 Critical Value for p=0.01 32.00 Chance Probability 0.9999
Slopes of Expected Value Regressions 1851-1899 0.1754 Millibars/Year 1900-1949 0.352 Millibars/Year 1950-2006 0.1513 Millibars/Year
Slopes of Expected Value Regressions 1851-1899 0.1754 Millibars/Year 1900-1949 0.352 Millibars/Year 1950-2006 0.1513 Millibars/Year
Hurricane Formation • The Three Requirements for Hurricane Formation • Over Land, Hurricanes Die
Our Data • The Percentage of Measurable Storms that Reached Land • The Number of Days on Land Per Land-bound Storm
Standard Deviation was 0.20 days • A Chi2 Test Determined X2 = 0.24 with 14 degrees of freedom • Critical Value = 10.83, The null hypothesis cannot be rejected!
Landfall Conclusions • There is no linear correlation between time and percentage of storms that reach land • The average number of days on land per land-bound storm
Frequency of Damage Insurance Industry takes notice -Al Gore Swiss re sigma report More People in Hazard areas -IWTC report
Frequency of Hurricanes Chi squared value .125254642
Major Hurricanes Absolute #’s increasing Chi squared Value .738022
Category 4&5’s have doubled in the Last Year1 -Al Gore Chi Squared Value 3.449001
Frequency • Increase in destructiveness not correlated • Frequency of major hurricanes is increasing • Shows some correlation to temperature • Al’s short term scare
Duration Categories: • Season Duration • Storm • All Storms • In Hurricane Status • Longest Yearly Storm
10 Year Average Season Duration 1851-2006 Chi-squared: 35.94 Critical value, 16 df, p = 0.001: 39.25
Average Storm Duration vs. Temperature Deviation 1900-2006 Chi squared: 191 Critical Value, 11 df, p = 0.001: 31.26
Average Storm Duration as Hurricane vs. Temperature Variation 1900-2006
Duration Conclusions • Season duration shows a positive correlation over time. • Data does not support a relationship between storm duration and global temperature increase since 1900.
CONCLUSIONS • Data does not consistently support a pattern of increased frequency and strength of hurricanes over time. • Linear relationships remain linear despite increasing temperature trends. • Discrepancies in measurement techniques? • Intricate dynamics of hurricane formation? • Single variable data modeling techniques?
References Raw hurricane data from Greg Bothun’s link on Blackboard.uoregon.edu Atlantic Tropical Storm Tracking by Year http://weather.unisys.com/hurricane/atlantic/ 1Lovgren , Stefan. "Al Gore's "Inconvenient Truth" Movie: Fact or Hype?.” National Geographic News. May 25, 2006. National Geographic. 24 Apr 2007 <http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2006/05/060524-global-warming.html>. IWTC Statement "Global Warming and Hurricanes." Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory. Dec. 7, 2007. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. 24 Apr 2007 <http://www.gfdl.gov/~tk/glob_warm_hurr.html>.