1 / 18

TGad Editor Report

TGad Editor Report. Authors:. Date: 2011-03-13. Draft update and next steps. TGad draft D1.2 released on March 01, 2011 D1.2 = D1.1 + speculative implementation of all technical and editorial comments resolved since the January/11 mtg

jpatel
Download Presentation

TGad Editor Report

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. TGad Editor Report Authors: Date: 2011-03-13 Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

  2. Draft update and next steps • TGad draft D1.2 released on March 01, 2011 • D1.2 = D1.1 + speculative implementation of all technical and editorial comments resolved since the January/11 mtg • All comments as part of LB168 have now been resolved and implemented into D1.2 • D1.2 has gone has gone through an editorial review by TGad’s editorial panel before its release • Goals for this mtg with respect to the draft • Approve creation of D2.0 on the basis of D1.2 • Start a recirculation LB on D2.0 Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

  3. LB168 update (10/1220r21) • Editorial comments were resolved by Editor and reviewed by the editorial panel • The latest comment database is 802.11-10/1220r21, and contains the resolution to all comments Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

  4. Report for January 2011 Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

  5. Draft update and schedule • TGad draft D1.1 released on January 16, 2011 • Speculative implementation of all technical, and some editorial, comments resolved to date (10/1220r12) • Targeting March/11 session to conclude LB168 comment resolution • TGad draft D2.0 will be generated weeks later, which will trigger the start of a recirculation LB Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

  6. LB168 update (10/1220r12) • Editorial comments will be resolved by Editor after all technical comments are resolved • Some technical comments will resolve editorials • Contact the Editor if you want to volunteer to resolve Open CIDs Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

  7. Report for November 2010 Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

  8. TGad draft specification update • Draft 1.0 was released on September 24, 2010 • Implements the approved comments indicated in the D0.1 comment database (10/717r15) • Following the release of D1.0, a 30-day WG letter ballot (LB168) was initiated on D1.0 • LB168 closed on October 24, 2010 Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

  9. LB168 update (10/1220r1) • LB168 received 1229 comments • Resolution to CID1162 was presented on Oct 14th conf call (802.11-10/1200r1) • Approximately another 160 T/TR CIDs already have proposed resolutions to be presented and are indicated 1220r1 • Contact me if you want to volunteer to resolve CIDs Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

  10. Report for September 2010 Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

  11. TGad draft specification update • Draft 0.2 was released on August 05, 2010 • Implements editorial comments and technical comments that passed motion at the July/10 TGad mtg (10/777r0) • Draft 0.3 was released on September 02, 2010 • Speculative draft that implements comments that received no objection during conference calls held after the July/10 TGad mtg • Draft 0.4 was released on September 10, 2010 • Implements corrections identified by the editorial panel • Drafts are publicly available at http://www.ieee802.org/11/TGad/index.html Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

  12. Comment resolution update (10/717r14) • TGad come out of the July/10 mtg with 120 (out of a total of 513) open comments • Since then, 94 comments had resolutions proposed and received no objections (see list in next slide) • As a result, TGad starts the Sept/10 mtg with 26 open comments • MAC: 1 CID (CID91) • MIB: 16 CIDs • Security: 7 CIDs • Beamforming: 2 CIDs (CID98 and CID292) Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

  13. CIDs with proposed resolutions which received no objection • Discussed in San Diego, but not motioned: • 320, 330, 331 (BF): 10/717r11 • Conference calls: • 3, 405, 406, 407, 408, 412, 414, 416, 417, 56, 418, 346 (PHY): 10/944r1 • 447, 448, 449, 316, 58, 59, 317, 318, 319, 461, 438, 386, 413 (PHY): 10/894r1 • 112, 113, 141, 232, 247, 378 (MAC): 10/947r1 • 382, 384, 385, 387, 388, 435, 439, 454, 465, 466, 471, 472, 473, 475, 476, 479, 480 (MAC): 10/948r2 • 323, 422, 445, 326, 328, 332, 333, 375, 433, 13, 100, 288, 289, 290, 291, 314, 340, 312, 374, 381, 427, 434, 452, 453, 464, 481, 482 (MAC/BF): 10/977r5 • 159, 256, 225 (MAC): 10/983r0 • 371, 372 (MAC): 10/946r0 • 321, 477 (MAC): 10/1010r0 • 84, 88, 89, 90 (MAC): 10/1007r2 • 175 (MAC): 10/999r0 • 389 (MAC): 10/1014r0 • 368 (MAC): 10/995r5 • 345 (PHY): 10/1029r0 • 487 (General): 10/1004r0, 10/1002r0, 10/1005r0, 10/1013r0, 10/1012r0, 10/1019r0, 10/1026r0, 10/1031r1, 10/1023r1 • 348 (PICS): 10/978r1 Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

  14. Editorial panel • Email sent to TGad reflector on September 03, 2010, soliciting volunteers for an editorial panel responsible to: • Review drafts for: • Mistakes made by the editor when implementing contributions; and • Editorials • Report those to editor, so that they can be fixed before the TG approves a new draft • Typically, there will be an editorial review for a few days before a new draft is intended to be posted • Volunteers so far: B. Lynch, J. Barr, J. Yee, S. Trainin, S. Grandhi, P. Loc, S. Shankar, T. Derham, L. Chu and I. Toyoda (?) • Contact the editor if you’d like to volunteer Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

  15. Report for July 2010 Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

  16. TGad draft specification update • Draft 0.1 was released on May 28, 2010 • Draft is publicly available at http://www.ieee802.org/11/TGad/index.html Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

  17. Comment submission • Following the release of D0.1, a 3 week commenting period was opened on D0.1 • A total of 513 comments were received – comment database is document 802.11-10/717 • Comments were reviewed during the July 1st conference call and classified into (sub)groups: • 236 editorial comments (ER) = handled directly by the Editor • 277 technical comments (TR) = resolutions to be proposed by volunteers • 2 in the General comment group • 24 in the Beamforming comment group • 207 in the MAC comment group • 41 in the PHY comment group • 3 in the Coexistence comment group Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

  18. Comment resolution • Comment resolution will take place starting at the July/10 session • Via submissions • Via proposed resolutions suggested by assignees • Via comment review sessions led by the Editor • As per the TGad timeline, goal is to complete comment resolution at the September/10 session and enter WG letter ballot • Any motions to approve comment resolutions should be done by September/10 Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation

More Related