290 likes | 390 Views
Explore the impact of social cues on arousal, pleasure, and flow in online shopping experiences, influencing website patronage intentions and value perceptions. Two studies test and validate the conceptual model.
E N D
“Can A Retail Website Be Social?” …A Statistical Analysis Bolivar DePeña Kathleen Kirk John Warren
Social Response Theory • The Computer as a Social Actor • Computers possess human-like attributes • Human Responses: • Politeness • Reciprocity • Interdependency • Interaction between similar and dissimilar personalities • Gender Stereotype • Flattery • Attribution Responsibility
Social Response Theory (continued) • H1: Consumers perceive a Web site that uses language, voice, interactivity, and social role as being significantly more social than a Web site that uses only text and limited interactivity.
The Effects of Web Site Socialness Perceptions • Assuming social cues are perceived positively • H2: Web site socialness perceptions have a positive effect on arousal. • H3: Web site socialness perceptions have a positive effect on pleasure. • H4: Web site socialness perceptions have a positive effect on flow.
Flow • Composed of four dimensions: • 1. The user feels a sense of control over the computer interaction. • 2. The user’s attention is focused on the interaction. • 3. The user’s interest is increased during the interaction. • 4. The user’s curiosity is evoked.
Relationship Among Pleasure Arousal and Flow • Flow cannot occur when a person is in a low-arousal • H5: Arousal has a positive effect on flow • H6: Arousal has a positive effect on pleasure • H7: Flow has a positive effect on pleasure
Hedonic and Utilitarian Value • Hedonic value: entertainment and emotional worth of shopping experience • Utilitarian value: efficiency and timeliness with minimum irritation • H8: Flow has a positive effect on hedonic value. • H9: Flow has a positive effect on utilitarian value. • H10: Pleasure has a positive effect on (a) hedonic value and (b)utilitarian value. • H11: Arousal has a positive effect on (a) hedonic value and (b)utilitarian value.
Website Patronage Intentions • Consumers’ online experience is a critical determinant of shopping behavior. • H12: Hedonic value has a positive effect on Web site patronage intentions. • H13: Utilitarian value has a positive effect on Web site patronage intentions.
Preparation • Two content-identical CTN sites created • High Social • Graphical female tour guide • Incorporates voice, interactivity, etc. • Politeness, professionalism, customized responses, etc. • Low Social • No character tour guide • All information was written • Very little interactivity • Pretests • Participants found the high-social website to be more social than the low-social website • (Xhigh social = 5.84 > Xlow social = 5.34, p = .027).
Procedure & Sample • Survey conducted in controlled lab setting • Each computer was identical • Participants wore headphones • Randomly assigned • Browsed site then took questionnaire on paper • The Participants • 337 undergraduate business students • Extra credit incentive • 49% F, 51% M • 97% ages 18-35 • ~80% had prior online shopping experience
Measures • Website Socialness Perceptions • Polite, helpful, intelligent, useful, & interactive • Pleasure & Arousal • Scales from negative reaction to positive reaction • Flow • Interest, curiosity, attention, & control • Hedonic & Utilitarian Value • Specific scale questions • Website Patronage Intentions • Likelihood to shop, willingness to buy, & willingness to recommend to friends
Analysis & Results • Website Socialness Perceptions • Analysis of Variance test confirms H1 • Mhighsocialness= 5.60, Mlowsocialness= 5.27, F = 11.68, p < .01 • Ratings for interactive character above midpoint • Confirmatory Factor Analysis • Found significant chi-square • X²(474) = 950.2, p = .00 • GFI = .85, TLI = .91, CFI = .93, RMSEA = .05 • Structural Model • GFI = .84, TLI = .91, CFI = .93, RMSEA = .06 • Less linkage between arousal or pleasure and patronage intention (.031, t = .633)
Preparation • Two custom blinds websites created • High Social • Interactive video of female shopping guide • Narration of page summaries • Click on character to find out more • Low Social • No shopping guide • No voice • No interactivity • New alternative hypothesis presented • H14: Arousal leads to higher levels of pleasure for consumers who are more involved with the product category than for those who are less involved
Procedures & Sample • Survey conducted in the field • Random recruits from a national online panel • Non-homeowners were omitted • 48-hour data collection period • Online survey after website browsing • Participants • 250 adult, non-student homeowners • Gender was even split • Ages were all over the place • 99% had shopped online (38.5% at least once a week) • 80% Caucasian
Measures • Website Socialness Perceptions • Polite, helpful, intelligent, useful, & interactive • Pleasure & Arousal • Scales from negative reaction to positive reaction • Flow • Interest, curiosity, attention, & control • Hedonic & Utilitarian Value • Specific scale questions • Website Patronage Intentions • Likelihood to shop, willingness to buy, & willingness to recommend to friends
Analysis & Results • Website Socialness Perceptions • Analysis of Variance confirms H1 • Mhighsocialness= 5.47, Mlowsocialness= 5.06, F = 4.96, p = .03 • Structural • Largely similar to Study 1, except for H11 (arousal leads to utilitarian value, .002, t = .003) • Involvement • (Δχ² = 4.90, p < .05) (.329; t = 4.09, p < .01) for those involved with product category • Demographics • Link between arousal and hedonic value higher for F • Older participants (>50) differed from younger participants in some categories
DiscussionHow Consumers Emotionally Process Online Social Cues
Example • IKEA's Ask Anna
ANALYSIS OF TESTS STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES • Multiple Measures • Thorough • Large amount of Alternative Hypothesis (clarifies what they were looking for) • Scale is not explained • Specification of age groups • Results are generalizable • Gloss over inconsistencies with their model
Theoretical Implications • Studies encourage further consideration of social cues • Customer-employee interactions are induced • Positive impact on customer responses • Just as important online as in brick and mortar • Pleasure is positively related to flow • Hedonic and Utilitarian values serve as good predictors of patrons (not used in brick and mortar) • Moderating effects of individual differences (gender and age)
Managerial Implications • Business investment in technology is increasing • Website design: attract retain • Human connection perception • Powerful marketing tools • Elements of fun in retail (not just completing transactions)
Managerial Implications (cont.) • Retailers contribute to online experience • Important to test social cues (robot vs. human) • Older markets need utilitarian cues (legibility/design) • Increase emotional bonds • Heightened for females – worth increasing cues • Other elements potentially important (color, navigation, pictures)
Limitations & Further Research • Better understanding of appropriate websites is needed • Other responses needed to be researched: service, satisfaction, and overall value • Results are generalizable – Teens and PreTeens need to be discussed in the future • Search strategies toward hedonic/utilitarian value • Environmental elements and ambient design affecting flow
References • Ikea. (2009). Retrieved October 10, 2009, from Ask Anna: www.ikea.com/us/en • Liz C. Wang, J. B. (2007). Can A Retail Website Be Social? Journal of Marketing , 143-157.