can india catch up can australia do better l.
Skip this Video
Loading SlideShow in 5 Seconds..
Can India catch up? Can Australia do better? PowerPoint Presentation
Download Presentation
Can India catch up? Can Australia do better?

Loading in 2 Seconds...

play fullscreen
1 / 18

Can India catch up? Can Australia do better? - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

  • Uploaded on

Can India catch up? Can Australia do better?. By Sanjeev Sabhlok, DRAFT, 1 June 2011. The centre of gravity of the world economy is changing. IMF : The combined real output of China and India now equals US output. Table: Share of world output measured in purchasing power parity.

I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about 'Can India catch up? Can Australia do better?' - jenifer

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
can india catch up can australia do better

Can India catch up? Can Australia do better?

By Sanjeev Sabhlok, DRAFT, 1 June 2011

the centre of gravity of the world economy is changing
The centre of gravity of the world economy is changing

IMF: The combined realoutput of China and India now equals US output

Table: Share of world output measured in purchasing power parity

  • Source: IMF’s World Economic and Financial Surveys: World Economic Outlook Database, April 2011

India’s economy is now as big as Japan.

By 2016 it will be six times that of Australia.

visual depiction
Visual depiction



  • China will become the world’s largest economy by 2016
  • (Maddison thought 2015, but IMF thinks 2016)
    • Per capita in China will still (in 2016) be only a fourth of that of USA
    • Ultimately China could become four times the size of USA
india as the world superpower till 1750
India as the world superpower till 1750
  • India’s performance in recent centuries is atypical
  • It was the wealthiest region during the agricultural age
    • Largest arable area till the USA came to the scene
    • Remained the world’s wealthiest in 12 out of the last 20 centuries
      • First century World GDP share = 33%
      • 11th century World GDP share = 28.9%
      • 1700 world GDP share = 24.4% (similar share of world trade)
  • Has India been a ‘victim’ of its long-standing success?
    • Caste system was well-suited to its agricultural society
      • It is no longer suitable, but is now very difficult to change
  • Intellectual stagnation
    • Major philosophical schools and scientific advance (e.g. number system)
    • Charvaka’s and Buddha’s ideas transmitted to Greece –> Sophists –> Socrates
    • The breakthroughs of the modern world arose in Italy (Renaissance)
key changes since 1400
Key changes since 1400
  • 1: The use of reason
    • Critical thinking
      • Islam, through Cordoba, helped recover Greek thought
    • The questioning of authority
      • Reformation
    • Induction and the scientific method – Francis Bacon
  • 2: Constitutionalism and liberty
    • Origin of democracy
      • Magna Carta -> Glorious Revolution
    • Theory of the modern state: Thomas Hobbes, John Locke
      • Society was earlier the centre. Now the individual
  • 3: The secret of wealth creation (free market)
    • Commercial institutions created
      • Modern banks, corporations (e.g. Medici family of Florence)
    • Invisible hand (Adam Smith)
      • (Refinements by F.A.Hayek)

Detailed discussion

in my draft manuscript,

The Discovery of Freedom

(available on the internet)

removing obstacles to opportunity
Removing obstacles to opportunity

Growth = f (governance, opportunity)






  • Government
  • Bad policy
  • Bad regulation
  • Bad enforcement
  • Society
  • Some religious beliefs
  • Insufficient value placed on
  • critical thinking




out the




come from



Role of government

- to reduce negative effects of excessive government


the result modern economic growth
The result: Modern economic growth

>> The Western economies started growing: an unprecedented phenomenon!

  • Key characteristics
  • Relatively slow till 1820 (10s of times the pre-1000 growh rate)
  • Rapid increase after that (100s of times the pre-1000 growth rate)
    • Effectively, the industrial revolution is less than 200 years old

Source: Madison

the great divergence
The great divergence
  • 1750 marked the end of the Mughals and conquest of (a portion of) India by England
  • India stagnated while the West grew rapidly
    • The British were caretakers, not interested in India’s growth
  • Post-independence socialist policies caused further divergence
    • Nehru was confused by the Fabian socialists including Keynes
  • By 1980, India’s share of world output was 2.5 per cent
    • (China’s share was even less, 2.2 per cent)
    • India’s share of world trade is less than 2 per cent today
    • Per capita income is $3000 (PPP), compared with America’s $50,000
why did india struggle even after the end of colonialism
Why did India struggle even after the end of colonialism?
  • Cause 1: Socialist ideology
    • By quirk of fate, Nehru the Fabian socialists set India’s policies
      • Rejected Milton Friedman’s specific advice
      • Rejected von Mises’s views on India’s productivity
  • Cause 2: New rules of the game not widely understood
    • Indian education system flooded with socialists
    • Economics education extremely poor
  • Cause 3: Arrogance about Indian history and culture
    • False pride that refuses to believe that the West could actually offer any learnings to India
    • Caste system not suited to dynamic societies.
and now the great convergence
And now, the great convergence?
  • China took off like a rocket in the 1980s
    • Now nearly thrice the size of India
      • In just 30 years, China’s economy almost the largest
      • Will overshadow the American economy soon
  • India has rapidly picked up pace after 1991
    • The IMF “medicine” of 1991 has helped
    • But
      • People have not internalised the new rules of the game
      • Socialist political parties continue to misgovern
india positives
India positives
  • Total factor productivity is rising
  • India is the world’s largest free market laboratory today
  • Where the government has privatised (or is absent) significant progress has occurred
    • IT sector and private sector IT education
    • Mobile phone wireless network

Source of the graph:

india negatives
India negatives
  • Severe government failure
    • One of the world’s most corrupt
  • Low levels of freedom
    • Failing institutions e.g. judiciary, press
  • Insufficient focus on infrastructure
    • However, it now has the largest private sector investment in infrastructure
  • Difficult to set up a business
  • Labour market inflexibility
will india catch up
Will India catch up?
  • India is handicapped by poor governance
  • India cannot catch up with the West without radically improving its governance.
  • On current indications India will end up as a middling power
    • Still a much larger economy than it is today
    • Of great interest to Australia
  • With reforms in policy and governance, however, nothing is impossible
    • Hint: Australia (Victoria) can assist India in reforming its governance

(no one thinking on this line: a missed opportunity!)

huge competitive pressure building on the west
Huge competitive pressure building on the West
  • Tsunami of competition from low-cost innovators
    • technical frontier now being pushed out by China and India
      • pressure on costs to expand the market in India creating huge pressure to innovate
      • also the wage differential creates huge competitive advantage

Examples: medical equipment, drug production, medical tourism

  • Impending giant tide of brain drain reversal
    • Ongoing perception of racism likely to prompt giant reversal of (previous) brain drain from China and India
      • Indians not happy with second class treatment by the West
        • Already the best Indians have stopped leaving India
        • Many have already returned permanently
    • The best brains of the West moving to India and China
threat or opportunity
Threat or opportunity?
  • Over a third of the world’s production will occur in India and China in the next few decades
  • Only nations that innovate will lead
  • Very hard to increase productivity in a services economy
    • Australia’s productivity is languishing
    • Growth in the West must necessarily stagnate or decline
  • If the West doesn’t engage, its competitive advantage will be lost
  • If the West assists, it will make friends and be perceived to be a helper
    • Competition will become intense, but this is not a zero-sum game!
    • The West can encourage and promote freedom
      • Tip: Everyone can benefit
what can australia do
What can Australia do?
  • 1. Increase efficiency
    • Minimise unnecessary government intervention
    • Ensure infrastructure is based on CBA
    • Reduce welfare state and churn
    • Stop direct management of schools and hospitals
    • Increase flexibility of labour market
  • 2. Actively reshape the future 
    • Get on the front foot
      • Significant opportunity to set up university and TAFE branches in India
    • Australia doesn’t have the baggage of history
      • (But the current impression of racism is not good)
    • Build strong economic and cultural relations with India
      • Not foreign aid but equal partnership!
    • Strategic networking with India’s governance system to support its modernisation