820 likes | 1.22k Views
Changing Patterns of Reimbursement, can your practice adapt? . Paul BrowerCEO Orange County Urology AssociatesFees used in this presentation are based on the Medicare allowables in California. These fees are on the public record and no proprietary information is included in this presentation..
E N D
1. Young Urologists Forum Effectively Managing Practice Economics and Utilization of Physician Extenders
Program and Lunch sponsored by the Young Urologists Committee and Ortho-McNeil Pharmaceutical, Inc.
2. Changing Patterns of Reimbursement, can your practice adapt?
Paul Brower
CEO Orange County Urology Associates
Fees used in this presentation are based on the Medicare allowables in California. These fees are on the public record and no proprietary information is included in this presentation.
3. Reimbursement History Began with the creation of the Resource-Based Relative Value Scale[RBRVS] by Wm Hsiao in 1988 and adopted by HICFA as part of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act in1992.
This allowed a shift to reward “cognitive” skills vs. procedures particularly those performed in the hospital.
The system of CPT codes,DRGs,and RVUs was created
There have been 3500 corrections and additions since 1992
By manipulating the RVUs and place of service there has been a successful shift to the office for procedures from the more expensive hospital
4. Yotan,YJ.Urology,Vol.172,1958-1962,Nov.2004 Between 1995 and 2004 the reimbursement for E & M codes increased 51% and surgical fees decreased 28%
Reimbursement for office procedures has risen even more than the increase in E & M codes
5. Where we are today? Medicare has indicated they will reduce reimbursement an additional 40% over the next 7 years. A 5% cut was frozen in 2007,but the freeze was “paid for” by imaging cuts including a 40% cut in reimbursement for transrectal ultrasound guidance for prostate biopsy.
Most HMO and PPO contracts are quoted as a % of Medicare’s fee schedule so this will a have profound effect on your practice income
Consolidation of Insurers has lead to concentration of power in the hands of a few resulting in obscene profits
Blue Cross of CA[now Anthem]- $3billion
United Health+Pacific Care-$4billion
6. What can we do ? In today’s economic environment we must understand how and where we make our money.
Gone are the days when we could simply come to work, operate, see patients, have someone run our office and expect to get paid well each month.
There has been tremendous pressure on our income in the last 5 years.
Costs associated with running our practices have risen and reimbursements have fallen.
We are “piece workers” and the only thing we have to sell is our time
We get paid for the number of widgets we produce and this is hard to leverage
If you don’t understand where you make your money you can’t possibly maximize your production and income per unit of time spent
7. What we look at for our practice benchmarking Office
Patient Counts: New patients,Return visits,# days seeing patients,#procedures done,ratio of procedures per patient visit,procedures that require a procedure room[vas,bx,utc,cysto]
Collections total and average per patient visit[always use collections not billings]
Coding:level and ratio for each MD and compared to the group
Hospital
# Consultations
# OR Cases
# Case as Assistant
# Long Cases[> 2 1/2 hrs]
Ratio of OR cases patient[Total, New]
Collections from the OR and Hospital
8. OCUA for 2005 9 MDs
1 new assoc. doing the laparoscopy and building his practice[#9]
2 specializing in female and incontinence[#4,500]
1 male infertility specialist[#400]
1 CEO,seeing patients 1/2 time[#100]
9. Approximate revenues per partner
10. Office Patient Visits
11. OR Cases
12. % Total Collections-OR
13. Income from surgery versus office encounter
14. OCUA 2006 Stats 6,323 New Patients
17,803 Return Visits
24,126 MD - patient encounters
2,000 Surgical Cases
13,200 Office Procedures
9 MDs [1new associate and 1 working 1/2 time]
15. Collections 2006 Office Patients Visits 31%
Office Procedures 39%
Surgery 16%
Other[supplies,meds] 13%
16. Comparative Fees 1986* 2007
TURP $2000 $923
Rad.Neph $3000 $1452
Lap Rad Neph $1536
Rad.Cystectomy $4000 $2185
Ureteroscopy,laser $488
ESL $2500 $639
Rad Px $3500 $1635
Pathology
Prostate bx $144/specimen
Cytology $95
*Balance Billing allowed then and not now
17. Office Fees 2007
Office consult[99244] $223
Return Visit[99213] $76
Cystoscopy[52000] $283
Vasectomy[55250] $742
TUMT[53850] $5214
BT<0.5cm[52224] $1992
Prostate Biopsy[55700] $335
Prostate US[76872] $176
Video Urodynamics $800-1000
Renal US[76770] $168
20. Ultrasound In office US is a very good way to leverage your time
US tech comes to the office on regular basis and performs renal,scrotal,penile,color doppler studies
Most Urologists are already doing their own US of the prostate
Advantages
Does not require dedicated space
Cost of equipment nominal compared to other imaging
Personnel costs are limited[pay per procedure]
Enhanced patient service and satisfaction
Does not require separate contracting with radiologist
21. US Codes and Fees CPT Code Description Fee
51798 PVR $21
76770 Retroperitoneal[complete] $142
76775 Retroperitoneal[limited] $127
76856 Pelvic[complete] $122
76857 Pelvic[limited] $110
76872 Prostate-Transrectal[Bx supervision] $147
76942 Guidance for biopsy $189
55700 Biopsy prostate $145
76873 Prostate Vol. BrachyRx $195
76870 Scrotal & Contents $120
93976 Duplex Scan[limited] $305
93980 Duplex Scan-penile $232
22. Pathology Must be very careful of the structure to avoid Stark issues;must own the equipment,own or lease the space,formal contract with the pathologist.
Bill global fee and split collections per contract with the pathologist
Requires limited dedicated space and funds for equipment:200 sq.ft,$80-$100,000
We are only doing 2 tests tissue histopathology,urine cytology
Medicare fees
CPT Description Fee
88305 Surgical Path[gross & micro] $143/core 88108 Urine Cytology $95
23. PATHOLOGY LAB
24. CT Must lease or purchase the equipment[new or refurbished].Start up costs $300-$600,000
Must have contractual arrangement with radiologist to interpret [on the premises or via PACs system].Bill separately or global.
Requires CT tech and MD to inject contrast
Dedicated space,construction,inspection,license
Certificate of Need[CON]
Pre-certification for procedures
Radiologists and some payors resisting this at the state and federal levels
25. CT Pro forma * Revenue
CT Patients per day 6
Days per month 20.75
Rev/pt- Abd/pelvis $835[may be considerably less]
with & without contrast
Total Revenue $1,248,252
Expenses
Equipment lease $85,000
Service contract $65,000
Technologist[SOCA] $85,000
Radiologist[16% of global[ $200,000
Medical supplies $10,000
Misc[rent,utilities] $20,000
Total $465,000
Potential Cash Flow $783,252
* Hypothetical Pro forma from Neusoft Imaging Systems Solutions[modified by PAB]
26. How can you adapt ? Office is the center for income and expenses-keep it busy. Have the space,equipment,staff to be maximally efficient with your time
Build a grid based on 1/2 day blocks-don’t violate your office block to go to the OR[it costs you lots of money]. Use block time
Develop ancillary sources of income US,Lithotripsy,CT,Pathology,IMRT,Incontinence Center
Built 15,000 sq. ft. office with 23 exam/procedure rooms,pathology lab,research,color doppler US,2 urodynamic rooms,C-arm and flouro table
Must finds ways to leverage your time
Little things matter:
Communicate by email, assign hospitals rounds,whomever is in the hospital sees all of the patients there,who ever lives closest stops in the AM
Review the schedule weekly,look for conflicts,openings,inefficiencies
Try to use RNFA or retired surgeons to assist,utilize surgical blocks
27. Working smarter and being more productive Designing your office
This is where you make your money and where your fixed costs are
Our new office:15,000 sq. ft
23 exam and procedure rooms;2 urodynamics,nurse visit room,fluoroscopy,Clinical Research,Pathology Lab
7 MDs and 2 PAs working simultaneously
Designed to never have to defer a procedure or delay seeing patients
Location
Primary office should be geocentric to the primary hospitals served
Satellite offices-utilize them only if they bring in patients that would go to someone else if you weren’t there. They are expensive and inefficient
28. Size Really Does Matter Group Size
Minimum # MDs - 6
Maximum - None [the larger the group the more potential problems with governance and personalities]
Large groups have access to capital for wholly owned ancillary services-lithotripters,laser,CT,IMRT
Fixed Costs
Most practice costs are fixed[rent,staff]
They don’t go away when you aren’t there
6 MDs -3 or 4 working in the office all of the time
Critical mass is required for capital expenses and overhead
Recruiting Large groups have been successful,small practices have not
Fellowship trained MDs want larger groups
Large groups can support the sub specialist with patient referrals and financial subsidies
29. Office vs OR Office is where you make your money-85% for OCUA
Office procedures are the economic kicker
The $ penalty for the OR is lost income of 1/3 to 20x per unit of time
Don’t stop operating but organize your time
Use block time
Don’t schedule cases in the middle of the day
Office days are office days-don’t leave
Rotate days in the hospital[rounds,operate,call]
Economic Death
Assisting- getting paid $175 for 1/2 day in the OR
Track assists and compensate your partners
Try not to use associates [use RNFA,retired surgeons]
30. Conclusions Do Internal Bench Marking at least annually
The majority of income comes from the office [85% for OCUA]
The system rewards those that stay in the office seeing patients and doing procedures
Group size is critical to survive in the future
A Minimum size is required to keep the office busy,support ancillary services,afford capital expenditures,take economic risk
You must develop ancillary services and learn to leverage your time
31. Physician Assistant Gordon R Gluckman,MD
Residency Director
Northwest Metropolitan Urology Associates
Rosiland Franklin Phycisian Assistant Program
32. Physician Assistant Background
Navy corpsmen trained in Vietnam with considerable medical treatment
Shortage of primary care physicians
Duke University - 1965
Director – Dr. Eugene Stead
Based on fast-track WWII physician training
33. Physician Assistant Current Education
Typical Applicant
Bachelor’s degree
4 years of experience
Extremely Competitive
Nurses, EMTs, Paramedics
Females>Males
34. Physician Assistant Practicing PAs
Graduate of Accredited program
Must pass National Certification Exam “C”
62% females
Final Degree
44% Bachelor’s
35% Master’s
35. Physician Assistant Areas of Practice
Family/General medicine(27%)
General Internal medicine(7%)
General Pediatrics(3%)
OB/GYN (2%)
Surgery/Surgical specialties (25%)
Emergency medicine (10%)
Internal medicine specialty (11%)
Dermatology (3%)
36. Physician Assistant Why Hire??
Shift physician workload
Handling routine office visit, rounds, call
Less time in office
Flexibility
Cost Effectiveness
For every dollar generated by PA 28 cents cost to employer
Physician-PA team concept
37. Northwest Metropolitan Urology Associates 16000 patient visits
4500 hospital consults
4000 hospital patient rounds
2500 post operative visits
38. Northwest Metropolitan Urology Associates 150 nephrectomies/laparoscopic
400 TURP’s/Lasers
200 open/robotic prostatectomies
700 TRUS/BX
400 Urodynamics
39. Northwest Metropolitan Urology Associates Physician Assistant
Hospital rounds
Consults
OR assistant
Calls
Help in office
40. Northwest Metropolitan Urology Associates One year residency
Lectures/OR/rounds/office
Two programs in the country
41. Physican Extenders James C. Ulchaker MD FACS
Co-Director Prostate Center
Glickman Urological and Kidney Institute
Cleveland Clinic Foundation
42. What are APN’s? Master’s prepared registered nurses
Current certification
Certificate of authority from OBN
Certificate to prescribe
Function in collaboration with physicians to provide mid-level care Mid-level provider
Can see pts independently; no need for protocols, standard order sets
No need for physician to see pts; co-sign charts.
Must be available by some form of telecommunication
Mid-level provider
Can see pts independently; no need for protocols, standard order sets
No need for physician to see pts; co-sign charts.
Must be available by some form of telecommunication
43. Titles of APN’s Nurse Practitioners (CRNP)
Certified Nurse Midwives (CNM)
Clinical Nurse Specialists (CNS)
Certified Registered Nurse Anesthetists* (CRNA)
44. Standard Care Arrangement Required for CRNP,CNS,CNM (ORC)
Formal document of collaborative relationship
Must be kept on site
Reviewed and signed annually
Must be kept current
Signed at time of hire
Originals kept in APN office
Signed by dept chair, section heads; must be reviewed in dept mtg
We send letter to OBM annually listing all APN’s and collaborating physicians to help ensure compliance with OBMSigned at time of hire
Originals kept in APN office
Signed by dept chair, section heads; must be reviewed in dept mtg
We send letter to OBM annually listing all APN’s and collaborating physicians to help ensure compliance with OBM
45. APN Core Privileges Patient assessment: History & physical
Develop plan of care:
ordering diagnostic tests & therapies
medication management with CTP
Implement/ re-evaluate plan of care:
perform diagnostic tests as per privileging
Can request special privileges based upon practice, knowledge & skill
Evaluated by collaborating MD thru QM process: chance to sit down, discuss practice, need for addtl trainign etc; ways to increase practiceCan request special privileges based upon practice, knowledge & skill
Evaluated by collaborating MD thru QM process: chance to sit down, discuss practice, need for addtl trainign etc; ways to increase practice
46. Why hire an APN? Promote access
Cost effective provider
Focus on prevention & wellness, patient education, promotion of compliance
Enhance revenue
Continuity of care
Facilitate physician productivity
Mid-level provider
Determinig need for APN
Access: shorter wait times; increased pt satisfaction. Look at pt demand
Less costly than MD; ability to bill for services
Focus on prevention, education, counselling, continuity of care: better outcomes
Enhance revenue
Facilitates physician productivity: allows physician to see more complex, challenging pts; perform proceduresMid-level provider
Determinig need for APN
Access: shorter wait times; increased pt satisfaction. Look at pt demand
Less costly than MD; ability to bill for services
Focus on prevention, education, counselling, continuity of care: better outcomes
Enhance revenue
Facilitates physician productivity: allows physician to see more complex, challenging pts; perform procedures
47. Optimal Use of APN’s Outpatient Setting
Established patients
Pre-op assessments
Post-op visits
Inpatient Setting
Patient evaluation
Facilitate discharge planning
Promote patient satisfaction Outpatient:
New, urgents
Chronically ill pts for follow up, acute visit
Education & counselling
Pre-op evaluations for procedures
Anticoagulation mgmt
Follow ups for services in global period
Need own schedule, own pts to see; not merely to w/u pts for MD
Inpatients:
Daily evaluation; order diagnostic tests & therapies
Discharge planning & coordination of care; education
Timely response to pt needs: higher pt satisfaction
Outpatient:
New, urgents
Chronically ill pts for follow up, acute visit
Education & counselling
Pre-op evaluations for procedures
Anticoagulation mgmt
Follow ups for services in global period
Need own schedule, own pts to see; not merely to w/u pts for MD
Inpatients:
Daily evaluation; order diagnostic tests & therapies
Discharge planning & coordination of care; education
Timely response to pt needs: higher pt satisfaction
48. Reimbursement of APN’s Independent
Incident to
Shared service in hospital setting Independent: news, urgent visits, education & counselling, group visits
Incident to
Shared vistis: hospital or HOPSIndependent: news, urgent visits, education & counselling, group visits
Incident to
Shared vistis: hospital or HOPS
49. Facilitating APN Reimbursement Provider enrollment packet
Medicare
Medicaid
BWC
Masterfile form
PIF for managed care enrollment
Processed once privileging is complete Treat as physician. Admin to ensure that provider enrollment & PIF packet is completed; processed after
Privileging complete. Can then open own schedule and begin billing Treat as physician. Admin to ensure that provider enrollment & PIF packet is completed; processed after
Privileging complete. Can then open own schedule and begin billing
50. Measuring APN Value Patient Satisfaction: QDM
Requires EPIC provider number & billing number
Requires APN to have own schedule
Patient Outcomes
LOS, discharge times, re-admit rates, compliance with standards of care QDM: own schedule. Submitted to QDM once provider number and billing number assigned
Outcomes: looking at APN outcomes in internal medicine pts; important for pay for perfromance
Focus on education, coordination & counseling: leads to better outcomes QDM: own schedule. Submitted to QDM once provider number and billing number assigned
Outcomes: looking at APN outcomes in internal medicine pts; important for pay for perfromance
Focus on education, coordination & counseling: leads to better outcomes
51. Measuring APN Value Productivity
Number of visits
Encounter types (Clarity)
Billed charges
RVU’s
Impact on physician practice
Various methods available
Now focusing on number of visits; can also look at other indicators
Epic: visits
Epicare encounters: appointment, office visit, phone call, med refill, orders only etcVarious methods available
Now focusing on number of visits; can also look at other indicators
Epic: visits
Epicare encounters: appointment, office visit, phone call, med refill, orders only etc
52. What is a Physician Assistant? Physician Assistants are health care professionals licensed to practice medicine with physician supervision. PAs are educated in the medical model designed to complement physician training.
(www.aapa.org)
53. Physician Assistants: Conduct physical exams
Diagnose and treat illnesses
Order and interpret tests
Counsel on preventive health care
Assist in surgery
And in 49 states, write prescriptions
As of May 17, 2006, Ohio passed legislation enabling PA’s to have RX authority.
54. Physician Assistant Demographics: There are just over 59,000 individuals who practice full-time as physician assistants.
59% female; 41% male
41 years old
The average PA has been in practice as a PA 9.1 years
(AAPA 2005 census)
55. Physician Assistant Demographics: AT THE CLEVELAND CLINIC:
Over 140 PA’s employed at CCF
Average years of clinical experience: 13yrs
Average years of employment: 8yrs
Range from 1yr to 32yrs
56. Demographics at CCF:
57. Division of Surgery
58. Physician Assistant in The Work Place 43.3% work in a solo physician or group practice
11.6% in a rural clinic, community health center, or freestanding urgent care or surgical facility
34.5% in a hospital
Less than 1% work in a nursing home or long-term care facility
(AAPA 2004 Annual PA Census Survey)
59. Physician Assistant On The Job: Perform invasive procedures: 43.6%
Precept PA students: 38.3%
Educate other providers: 36.6%
Assist in surgery: 26.6%
Precept other students: 26.5%
Make decisions about procurement: 24.6%
Perform quality assurance: 22.2%
Supervise other clinical staff: 20.2%
100% or respondents provide direct patient care
(AAPA 2004 Annual Census Survey)
60. Methods of measuring productivity: Average number of visits per unit of time
Charges generated
Increased physician activity
Number of office visits or procedures
Overhead reduction
Time spent per patient visit
61. Lori B. Lerner, MD
Assistant Professor of Surgery
Chief, Section of Urology
White River Junction VAMC
Dartmouth Medical School
White River Junction, VT
62. White River VAMC 27 NP’s and PA’s employed by the hospital
Surgical Service
3 in General Surgery
One each in GU, Vascular, Ortho
Approx 50% of primary care clinics staffed by PA’s and NP’s
63. Urology Service 2 attendings, 1 senior level resident and one NP
Since losing our intern 8 yrs ago, we have had a PA or NP
Daily rounds and half day clinic, pre-operative history and physicals, prostate biopsies, in-patient consults, discharge planning, pt phone calls, prescription renewals
64. Surgical Service 3 PA’s
40 hour work week
Daily rounds, discharges, assist in the OR, H & P’s, post operative orders and post-op checks
No assigned clinic patients, but they attend and assist
When 80 hr work week was instituted, PA’s began overnite call
65. Salary Range Very wide range depending on provider experience, yrs at the VA
NP: $45,520-83,927
PA: $43,731-82,446
With yearly raises in the VA system, some providers are above this range
66. Contact Information:Physician Assistants http://www.clinicianreviews.com/index.asp?ArticleType=SiteSpec&page=body/PAorganizations.htm
American Academy of Physician Assistants
http://www.aapa.org
http://www.healthecareers.com/site_templates/AAPA/index.asp?aff=AAPA&SPLD=AAPA
American Association of Surgical Physician Assistants
http://www.aaspa.com/SurgInfo.asp
E-mail: aaspa@aaspa.com
PMB 201 4267 NW Federal HighwayJensen Beach, FL 34957
888.882.2772
772.388.3457 (fax)
67. Contact Information:Physician Assistants http://www.paworld.net/
http://www.advancedpracticejobs.com/
http://www.medhunters.com/jobs/healthcare.allied.pa.urology-pa.2519.html
http://www.careermd.com/newsletters/
currentnewsletters/CareerPA_1.htm
68. Contact Information:Nurse Practioners http://www.clinicianreviews.com/index.asp?ArticleType=SiteSpec&page=body/NPorganizations.htm
State NP organizations
American Academy of NPs
PO Box 12846 Austin, TX 78711 512.276.5906
http://www.aanp.org
American College of NPs
1111 19th St NW, Ste 404 Washington, DC 20036 202.659.2190
E-mail: acnp@acnpweb.org
69. Contact Information:Nurse Practioners National Association of Pediatric NPs
20 Brace Rd, Ste 200 Cherry Hill, NJ 08034 877.662.7627
http://www.napnap.org
National Conference of Gerontological NPs
4824 Edgemoor Ln Bethesda, MD 20814 301.654.3776
http://www.ncgnp.org
70. Effectively Managing Practice Economics and Utilization of Physician Extenders Young Urologists Committee
Kevin Spear MD Chair
71. What was the reason you hired a physician extender?
72. How long did it take for you to hire a physician extender?
73. What resources did you utilize to assist you in the hiring process?
74. Was the hiring process difficult?
75. How did you formulate the salary and benefit package?
76. Was credentialing difficult?
77. How do you utilize your physician extender?
78. How do your patients perceive the physician extender?
79. Was your initial plan different than your current utilization plan?
80. How do you supervise and assure quality control?
81. Are there any liability concerns?
82. What were the trials and tribulations of the physician extender process?
83. Do you have any recommendations for physicians to consider when hiring a physician extender?