1 / 54

Four Pillars of effective Risk management

Four Pillars of effective Risk management. Session Leader: Randy Thompson, Ph.D. Thompson Consulting & Training Eagle, Idaho Co-presenter Leslie Hoffman LEH Consulting Group Albuquerque, New Mexico. Current Conditions. Slow economic growth Low loan demand from higher credit borrowers

ingrid
Download Presentation

Four Pillars of effective Risk management

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Four Pillars of effective Risk management Session Leader: Randy Thompson, Ph.D. Thompson Consulting & Training Eagle, Idaho Co-presenter Leslie Hoffman LEH Consulting Group Albuquerque, New Mexico

  2. Current Conditions • Slow economic growth • Low loan demand from higher credit borrowers • Decreasing loan to share • Decreasing interest income • Risk aversion

  3. Lender Response • Competitive Environment • High demand from lenders for lowest risk loans • Desire to minimize loss exposure • Tighter underwriting standards

  4. Effect on Lenders • Focus on A+ and A loans for minimum risk • Competition forcing rates lower • Results in declining yields from the loan portfolio

  5. Income tied balance and yield

  6. Many Lenders are on a Collision Course with Disaster

  7. Examples and Impact • Can each organization quantify that the loans they are funding will cover all loan related costs and provide a adequate return? or… • Are they offering loan to simply attract a volume of unprofitable business?

  8. Down-shock and Impact • We have been actively operating in the down shock environment for the past 3 years. • Base Interest Rates • June 2010 4.62% • June 20132.97% • Reduced rates are useful if demand is strong • If demand is stagnate, reduced rates simply reduce yield and income

  9. Strategies to Improve Performance • Maintain current volume of prime grade loans • Add lower grades loans equal to 30%-35% of current volume • Average rate on non-prime loans 12% • Increase ALLL to account for increased risk

  10. Impact on Earnings • Increased non-prime loans carries higher risk • Accommodate risk with higher allowance funding • Estimate of increased risk is 4% of balances annually • Subtract increased allowance from increased earnings to identify net earnings increase.

  11. Applying this methodology and its tools, multiple lenders have turned their yields and income around:

  12. Four Pillars of Effective Risk Management • I: Credit Analysis • II: Empirically Derived Risk Based Pricing • III: Credit Monitoring • IV: Managing Repayment

  13. Pillar I: Credit Analysis • Underwriting that takes into account the risk associated with the loan and the borrower • Identifies risk components to be considered in approving or denying the loan • Creates a loan package that manages risk and return

  14. Pillar I: Credit Analysis • Comprehensive and consistently applied policies • Clarify acceptable loans • Specify the amounts in each grade • Specify terms • Specify maximum loan amounts • Specify minimum rate spreads

  15. Pillar II: Empirically Derived Risk Based Pricing • Accounting for costs • Identifying replacement cost of money • Assuring an adequate margin/return • Regular model validation

  16. Pillar II: Empirically Derived Risk Based Pricing • Account for all costs associated with loan programs • Measure and assign costs to each grade independently • Measure and assign replacement cost of money • Set rates and measure margins • Eliminate unprofitable rates and cross grade subsidies

  17. Pillar II: Empirically Derived Risk Based Pricing • Accurate, Effective Pricing Requires: • Identification of core costs • Cost of Funds • Processing/Maintenance • Collections • Charge-offs • Identification of risk pools • Application of costs to pricing • Strategies to balance loan and share rates • Ongoing validation of the model

  18. Perform Regular and Complete Cost Analyses 1. Cost of Funds • Lease payment for deposits • Average of payment for all deposits • Replacement cost over time 2. Processing/Maintenance • Contribution of staff time • Application of Operational Expenses • Distribution of Administration Costs

  19. Perform Regular and Complete Cost Analyses 3. Collections • Examining collection expenses over time • Grouping by risk pool • Grouping by risk grade 4. Charge-offs • Examining charge-offs over time • Grouping by risk pool • Grouping by risk grade

  20. Risk-based Cost Breakout

  21. Empirically Calculated Risk Based Pricing

  22. Pillar II: Empirically Derived Risk Based Pricing • Assure all loan grades and types are contributing equitably • Measure returns/margins for pools and grades • Eliminate Cross-Grade Subsidies • Identify returns that are reducing over grades

  23. Pillar II: Empirically Derived Risk Based Pricing • We can look at expanded options to address risk • Pricing for Risk Grade • Pricing for LTV • Pricing for Term

  24. Pillar III: Credit Monitoring • Credit Migration of Impaired and Improved Loans • Net Credit Change • Ongoing Loan Decisioning

  25. Credit Migration • Many names for the same concept • Credit migration • Multi-dimensional portfolio management • On-going decisioning • Migration Analysis

  26. Credit Migration • No matter what name you use it is an important tool for managing the risk in your loan portfolio; • Examiners are asking for, and in some cases, requiring it; and • FASBE is currently examining changing guidance to focus on credit migration in allowance calculation

  27. Credit Migration Definition: A measurement of changes in credit scores and risk for individual loans in the loan portfolio of the lending organization. The composite of these changes provides a valid measure of the current risk inherent in the total portfolio.

  28. Understanding Credit Scores • Credit agencies continually monitor multiple risk indicators to calculate credit scores: • Payment history • Amount of credit • Available credit • Employment history • Repossessions • Bankruptcies • Foreclosures

  29. Understanding Credit Scores • Each of these variables is dynamic • Changes in variables may change credit • Credit changes affect risk • Changes in risk may be an predicator of a member’s future performance

  30. Pillar III: Credit Monitoring • Consistent Credit Migration Analysis • Original credit scores on current loans and balances • Recent credit scores on current loans and balances • Measure and identify impaired loans • Measure and identify improved loans • On-going Decisioning with impaired loans

  31. Credit Migration Matrix-Portfolio • Create migration matrix for total portfolio • Original credit and current credit

  32. Credit Migration Matrix-Pools • Create migration matrix for each risk pool

  33. Credit Migration • Understanding your Loan Portfolio • Credit risk can Increase or Decrease • Which risk pools are improving impairing? • What is the net credit change for each pool?

  34. Credit Scores and Loan Types • It is also important to partition loans by risk pools and apply the same analysis individually to each pool.

  35. Net Credit Change • Create net credit change calculation

  36. Credit Migration • Identifying Potential Problems • Isolate impaired loans and react to them early • Reduce Credit Limits • Freeze lines • Adjust rates • Understand the risk in your pools and adjust lending practices • Adjusting debt ratios • Adjusting LTVs • Other underwriting changes

  37. Credit Migration • Why are deteriorating credit scores important to identify? • 70% to 80% of your charge-offs come from loans with deteriorating credit scores

  38. Using Credit Scores to Manage Risk • How Can You Manage risk on an ongoing basis • Monitor changing risk scores and adjust: • Rates • Allowance • Credit limits • Limits on non-prime loans

  39. More on Credit Migration • Identifying Emerging Opportunities • Recognize Members that are making smart decisions • Proactively offer ways to help your members • Understand which pools of loans to take on more risk • Applying Precision in Allowance Calculation • Statistically based calculation • Complying to regulations

  40. Identifying Opportunities • Improving Credit scores are also important • Central mission of helping members • Targeted marketing • Increased loyalty • Upsell opportunities

  41. Process of Credit Migration • Soft pull of credit scores/reports • Create migration matrix • Create net credit change calculation • Update portfolio analysis • Identify percentages of loans by grade • Update allowance • Perform individual loan analysis

  42. Pillar IV: Managing Repayment A Continuous Process

  43. Step 1: The Right Tools and Support

  44. Step 2: The Right Information • Are you pulling regular reports on the aging of your portfolio? • Look for movement between buckets • Are you tracking communication? • That log is a critical tool • Do you know how your client is performing with other creditors? • Pull a credit report

  45. Using Credit Scores to Manage Risk • How Can You Manage risk on an ongoing basis • Monitor changing risk scores and adjust: • Rates • Allowance • Credit limits • Limits on non-prime loans

  46. Step 3: Set Goals, Build a Schedule • Follow a schedule/protocol • That should start the first day of delinquency • Schedule activities • What are the best times to reach clients? • Set goals • No. of calls per day, week or month • Dollars collected per week or month or by staff member

  47. Step 4: Collect with Care and Confidence

  48. Four Pillars of Effective Risk Management • I: Credit Analysis • II: Empirically Derived Risk Based Pricing • III: Credit Monitoring • IV: Managing Repayment

  49. Monitoring Collection Success • List of delinquent loans were collected on a monthly • Included the account number for each loan, the balance of the loan, the days delinquent and any loan balances that had been charged off each month. • Loans were partitioned into five groups representing advanced delinquent loans, as measured by days delinquent.

  50. Monitoring Collection Success • The breakout of loans for these groups was as follows: Group Days Delinquent 1 11-29 2 30-44 3 45-59 4 60-89 5 90+ • Charged off loans were labeled as group 9. • Non-delinquent loans were labeled as 0.

More Related