New institutional economics nie
Download
1 / 25

NEW INSTITUTIONAL ECONOMICS (NIE): - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 132 Views
  • Uploaded on

NEW INSTITUTIONAL ECONOMICS (NIE):. Slides are from a presentation made by: Mylène Kherallah, John Maluccio, & Nancy McCarthy IFP RI. Every school of thought is like a man who has talked to himself for a hundred years and is delighted with his own mind, however stupid it may be.

loader
I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
capcha
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about 'NEW INSTITUTIONAL ECONOMICS (NIE):' - helga


An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
New institutional economics nie

NEW INSTITUTIONAL ECONOMICS (NIE):

Slides are from a presentation made by:

Mylène Kherallah, John Maluccio,

& Nancy McCarthy

IFPRI


New institutional economics nie

Every school of thought is like a man who has talked to himself for a hundred years and is delighted with his own mind, however stupid it may be.

(J.W.Goethe, 1817, Principles of Natural Science)

NIE: A NEW SCHOOL OF THOUGHT

“There you go gentlemen. According to this, we are now a “school of thought.”


What is nie
WHAT IS NIE? himself for a hundred years and is delighted with his own mind, however stupid it may be.

  • No commonly agreed upon definition

  • Basic premise: Institutions matter for economic performance

  • Purpose is to explain the determinants of institutions and their evolution over time, and to evaluate their impact on economic performance, efficiency and distribution


What are institutions
What are Institutions? himself for a hundred years and is delighted with his own mind, however stupid it may be.

A set of formal and informal rules of conduct that facilitate coordination or govern relationships between individuals.


Why is it called new
Why is it called “New”? himself for a hundred years and is delighted with his own mind, however stupid it may be.

  • To distinguish it from the “old” institutionalist school (Veblen, Commons)

  • NIE operates within the framework of neo-classical economics, but it relaxes some of its assumptions and incorporates institutions as an additional constraint.


Nie economic activities are embedded in a framework of institutions formal informal
NIE: Economic activities are embedded in a framework of institutions, formal & informal

NIE

“Old”

Institutionalist

school

Neo-classical

Economics


New institutional economics nie

New Economic History institutions, formal & informal

(North, Fogel, Rutheford)

Public Choice & Political Economy

(Buchanan, Tullock, Olson, Bates)

(Social Capital)

(Putnam, Coleman)

New Social Economics

(Becker)

NIE

Property rights literature

(Alchian, Demsetz)

Transaction Costs Economics

(Coase, North, Williamson)

Economics of information

(Akerlof, Stigler, Stiglitz)

Theory of Collective Action

(Ostrom, Olson, Hardin)

Law and Economics

(Posner)


Transaction cost economics
Transaction cost economics institutions, formal & informal

  • Defining transaction costs:

    • Cost of screening and selecting a buyer or seller

    • Cost of obtaining information on the good or service

    • Cost of bargaining & negotiating a contract

    • Cost of monitoring & enforcing the contract


Transaction cost economics1
Transaction cost economics institutions, formal & informal

  • Coase (1937)

    • Market exchange is not costless

    • Firms emerge to economize on transaction costs

    • Boundary of the firm determined by nature and extent of transaction costs


Transaction cost economics2
Transaction cost economics institutions, formal & informal

  • Williamson (1996, 2000)

    • Combines the concepts of bounded rationality & opportunistic behavior to explain contracts & ownership structure of firms

    • Continuum of organizational form (from vertical integration to cash markets) that depends largely on the magnitude of transaction costs


Transaction cost economics3
Transaction cost economics institutions, formal & informal

  • North (1986, 1989, 1994)

    • Institutions that evolve to reduce transaction costs are key to the performance of economies

    • Not all institutions that emerge are efficient

    • Role of government is crucial in specifying property rights and enforcing contracts


Transaction cost economics4
Transaction cost economics institutions, formal & informal

  • North (1990)

    “The inability of societies to develop effective, low-cost enforcement of contracts is the most important source of both historical stagnation and contemporary underdevelopment in the third world.”


How is transaction cost econ relevan t
How is transaction cost econ. relevan institutions, formal & informalt?

Globalization & industrialization

Market liberalization & government devolution

Increasing reliance on vertical linkages, long-term contracts, and coordinated relationships


New institutional economics social capital
New Institutional Economics: Social Capital institutions, formal & informal

  • Isn’t “standard” economics enough?

  • What is social capital? How does it operate?

  • How is it currently measured?

  • Empirical examples

  • The (many?) problems


Beyond neo classical economics
Beyond neo-classical economics institutions, formal & informal

  • Objective is modeling behavior

  • Other social sciences, social relations matter

    A need to extend the models economists use and to incorporate findings from other fields

    - in fact already exist many examples


Social capital definition part 1
Social Capital definition: part 1 institutions, formal & informal

  • “Social capital refers to features of social organization [in particular, horizontal associations] such as networks, norms and social trust that facilitate coordination and cooperation for mutual benefit.” Putnam (1995)

  • “a variety of different entities, with two elements in common: they all consist of some aspect of social structure, and they facilitate certain actions of actors … within the structure” Coleman (1988)


Social capital definition part 2
Social Capital definition: part 2 institutions, formal & informal

  • “includes the social and political environment that enables norms to develop and shapes social structure. .. Includes the more formalized institutional relationships and structures, such as government, the political regime, the rule of law, the court system and civil an political liberties” Grootaert (1998)

  • “Social capital is defined as the norms and social relations embedded in the social structures of societies that enable people to coordinate action to achieve desired goals.” The World Bank (2000)


Social capital definitions part n
Social Capital Definitions: part N institutions, formal & informal

  • Enough already!


Social capital definition deconstruction

Norms institutions, formal & informal

Networks

Trust

 Coordination and cooperation

Individual/Household

Local/Community

National

International

Private versus Public good

Social Capital definition: deconstruction


How is social capital hypothesized to work
How is social capital hypothesized to work? institutions, formal & informal

  • lowers transactions costs of exchange

  • improved diffusion of information and innovations

  • strengthens informal insurance mechanisms

  • increases the probability of trust-sensitive exchanges being made

  • improves local authority performance by drawing them into networks


Social capital
Social? Capital? institutions, formal & informal

  • Is it Social?

    • Social in sense of society

    • But this does not necessarily mean public good

  • Is it Capital?

    • Analogy to other forms of capital useful

    • Don’t push too hard on this, especially distinction between stocks and flows


How is social capital quantified at micro level
How is social capital quantified (at “micro” level)? institutions, formal & informal

  • Contacts & other network measures

  • Group membership (and characteristics)

  • Degree of civic engagement and/or responsibility

  • Strength of family networks

  • Trust measures

  • (Absence of) Violence


What s the purpose of institutional research
What’s the purpose of Institutional Research institutions, formal & informal

  • To sufficiently capture the institutional context so that we can more accurately predict how other policies are likely to impact on households (&/or members in the household)?

  • To capture the institutional context, and to capture how any particular policy may in turn affect the functioning of the institution?

  • To determine factors that directly affect the institution, and so derive policy recommendations to directly change the institution?


Concluding questions
Concluding Questions: institutions, formal & informal

  • How useful is transaction cost economics to inform public policy beyond enforcing property rights & contracts, improving public market information, investing in infrastructure, etc.?

  • Is there a benefit to separating social capital out, or should we just focus on the individual mechanism being studied in each case?


Concluding questions1
Concluding Questions: institutions, formal & informal

  • Who decides on the criteria for assessing institutions? Especially when distribution is important?

  • Where’s the “demand” for these types of analysis? Not just property rights, but broader “socio-cultural” institutions?