1 / 14

Alexes Harris

Alexes Harris. Presidential Term Professor John Jay University Department of Sociology March 5 th , 2019 University of Washington. Outline. Understanding Monetary Sanctions Consequences of Monetary Sanctions Next Line of Research.

eriley
Download Presentation

Alexes Harris

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Alexes Harris Presidential Term Professor John Jay University Department of Sociology March 5th, 2019 University of Washington

  2. Outline • Understanding Monetary Sanctions • Consequences of Monetary Sanctions • Next Line of Research

  3. I. Understanding Monetary Sanctions Legal Financial Obligations (LFOs) • Costs associated with justice system contact • People are required to pay for services and sentences • An involuntary system • Court supervision and control extend until people pay in full • Certain rights limited until paid • Leads to a two-tiered system of justice

  4. POLICE ARREST • Cost of defense attorney • Cash Bond/BailBond • “Pre-pay Release Cards” • Asset forfeiture • Jail booking fee • Expungement of record • Deferred prosecution • IMMIGRATION • Detention release bond • PRE/POST INCARCERATION • Phone calls, internet, visits Jail/prison cost • LFO deduction • FINANCIAL RELATED CONSEQUENCES • Loss of driver’s license • Wage garnishment • CONVICTION • Jail/prison cost Restitution • LFOs – fines, fees, costs Black = Private Underline= w/o conviction Figure 1. The “Buckets” of Monetary Sanctions • “ALTERNATIVE” SENTENCES Victim panel class Community supervision Drug/Alcohol Assessment & Treatment • Electronic Home Monitoring • Work Release • COSTS IF CAN’T PAY Collections fee “Convenience” fee • Interest • Per payment cost, min. Alexes Harris, 2018

  5. Figure 2. The Layers of Monetary Sanctions Alexes Harris, 2018

  6. The “Exceptional” U.S. system of “Justice” Incarceration has increased by 500% in last 40 years (BJS 2016) • 1 in 115 adults were in jail or prison in 2015 • 2.2 million people are in jail or prison currently • 4.6 million people on probation or parole (6.7 on supervision) Rate of incarceration (sentencingproject.org) • 1/17 Black, 1/42 Latino, 1/91 White men 30-34 in prison • Black women is 2x, Latina women is 1.2x that of White women 2010 Estimates (Shannon et al. 2018) • 3% Adult pop, 15% African American adult male pop have been to prison • 8% Adult pop, 33% African American adult male pop has had a felony

  7. Example Legislative Growth in Fees • Jury Fee (Washington State RCW 10.46.190) • Existed since 1869 • Modified: • 1881 • 1961 - $12 Jury fee codified • 1977 - $25 jury fee • 2005 - $150/$250 (9 vs. 12)

  8. II. Consequences of Monetary Sanctions • Individual (Purposeful Consequences) • Criminal justice – continual supervision, re-incarceration • Economic – debt, decreased resources, already strained economically • Personal – health, stress, family and social network strain Society • Potential decrease in public safety (misguided attention, “desistance disrupter”) • Fiscal costs to courts and other services • Delegitimization of our systems of justice

  9. “Vilma” – A Case Study • Could be anyone of us • Incarcerated for 5 years, with over $50K debt • Loss of children • New relationship with child, in apprenticeship program • Facing debt • Strain on family networks – “economic liability”

  10. Stratifying Mechanism • Distinct population – disadvantaged pre- and post- conviction and incarceration • The process “perfectly” labels, stigmatizes, financially burdens and imposes further legal consequences to poor people • “Perfectly” sorts the already marginalized and further cements them to lives of inequality • Allows perpetual state surveillance, intervention and control of poor people

  11. III. Next Line of Research • I. Data limitations: Accessing court automated data • Difficulty accessing • Consistency within and across states of quality data (missing, different data elements) • II. Open questions: Development of legal statute within states over time to illustrate expansion • Is this within states or certain states, at county or muni levels? • What are arguments for expansion? • III. Open questions: Relationship (or lack there of) between: • Juvenile, traffic, lower courts (misdemeanor, district, village), Superior and Federal courts • Do, and if so, how do courts theoretically and practically use the sentencing of monetary sanctions differently? • Revenue generation (what are differences in ROR), punishment, control mechanism

  12. On-Going Research 2015-2020 Multi-StateProject on Monetary Sanctions (Laura and John Arnold Foundation) • Washington (Harris, PI), California (B. Sykes), Texas (B. Pettit), Missouri (B. Huebner), Minnesota (C. Uggen), Georgia (S. Shannon), New York (K. Martin), Illinois (M. Pattillo) • Multilayers of systems of justice (municipal, “lower courts”, superior courts) • Observations of sentencing hearings and sanctioning hearings (~2400 hours) • Interviews with debtors (480), prosecutors, judges, defense attorneys, clerks, probation officers (total ~500) • Compilation of multi-year, multi-state court automated data, including data on fines and fees (sentenced, paid, outstanding, interest, race/ethnicity, priors, current offense) • Currently at case-level, cleaning to individual-level • Will use with Census data for HLM analyses For more information see monetarysanctions.org

  13. Working papers and book manuscripts •  “Justice “Cost Points”: An Examination of Privatization Within Public Systems of Justice” (Crime and Public Policy, Forthcoming 2019), w/ Tyler Smith, Emmi Obara • “Monetary Sanctions: A Review of Revenue Generation, Legal Challenges, and Reform” (An Rev LSS, Forthcoming 2019, w/ April Fernandes, Frank Edwards, Michele Cadigan) • “Policing, Mortality and Monetary Sanctions” w/ Frank Edwards • “The World of Monetary Sanctions” w/ team • “Desistance Disrupter” w/ Chris Uggen and team (cj, financial, family and health strain) • Replication of ASR 2011 w/ Frank Edwards and team (race, ethnicity) • Estimating rate of debtors and average debt amounts w/ Sarah Shannon and team • Two Edited Books 1) across and within state analyses 2) methods outline

  14. Alexes HarrisPresidential Term ProfessorDepartment of SociologyUniversity of Washington Contact: yharris@uw.edu Website: alexesharris.com Twitter: @alexesharris

More Related