Anticonvulsants diabetic neuropathic pain
Download
1 / 20

Anticonvulsants ?? diabetic neuropathic pain ??? - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


  • 146 Views
  • Uploaded on

Anticonvulsants 治療 diabetic neuropathic pain 的效果. 小港醫院 R2 董錦松. 臨床問題. Anticonvulsants 對 diabetic neuropathic pain 的治療效果如何? 若 anticonvulsants 治療 diabetic neuropathic pain 有效,那一種 anticonvulsant 為最佳選擇?. 背景說明.

loader
I am the owner, or an agent authorized to act on behalf of the owner, of the copyrighted work described.
capcha
Download Presentation

PowerPoint Slideshow about 'Anticonvulsants ?? diabetic neuropathic pain ???' - eloise


An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation

Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author.While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript
Anticonvulsants diabetic neuropathic pain

Anticonvulsants治療diabetic neuropathic pain的效果

小港醫院 R2董錦松


Anticonvulsants diabetic neuropathic pain
臨床問題

  • Anticonvulsants對diabetic neuropathic pain的治療效果如何?

  • 若anticonvulsants治療diabetic neuropathic pain有效,那一種anticonvulsant為最佳選擇?


Anticonvulsants diabetic neuropathic pain
背景說明

  • 1960年代起,即開始使用anticonvulsants來治療neuropathic pain,如diabetic neuropathy,trigeminal neuralgia,post-herpetic neuralgia等。

  • Diabetic neuropathic pain是臨床上常見之病症,困擾許多DM病人,近年來多種新的anticonvulsants上市,是否也代表治療diabetic neuropathic pain的選擇更多,副作用更少,因此找尋文獻比較各種anticonvulsants對diabetic neuropathic pain的療效。


Diabetic peripheral neuropathy
Diabetic peripheral neuropathy

  • 15% DM p’t have S/S of neuropathy

    • DM>25 years affect nearly 50% p’t

  • Pathogenesis: unknown

    • Hyperglycemia

    • Microvascular diasease

  • Treatment: TCAs, NSAID, anticonvulsants, opioids, topical anesthetic agents, nerve block


Anticonvulsants diabetic neuropathic pain
期待目標

  • anticonvulsants對diabetic neuropathic pain的治療效果,並找出何種anticonvulsants 是最佳的選擇。


Anticonvulsants diabetic neuropathic pain
搜尋步驟

  • 搜尋字串:

    • Neuropathy

    • anticonvulsant, anticonvulsants, carbamazepine, oxcarbazepine, valproate, phenytoin, lamotrigine, vigabatrin, gabapentin, topiramate

    • Clinical trial (PubMed)

  • 搜尋範圍:

    • ACP Journal Club -- 1

    • Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews -- 1

    • Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, PubMed -- 15



Anticonvulsants diabetic neuropathic pain
結果摘要(I)

Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews

  • Anticonvulsant drugs for acute and chronic pain (2000)

    • Diabetic Neuropathy: Four placebo-controlled studies

      • one with carbamazepine (Rull 1969), two with phenytoin (Chadda 1978, Saudek 1977), and one with gabapentin (Backonja 1998)).

      • Rull (Rull 1969) and Chadda (Chadda 1978) found that with two weeks' treatment between 30 and 50% more patients improved on anticonvulsant than on placebo.

      • Saudek 1977, using phenytoin (300 mg/day) for 23 weeks of treatment found no difference in mean pain intensity compared with placebo

      • Backonja (Backonja 1998) reported a 60% improvement on a global scale for patients on gabapentin (up to 3.6 grams per day) after four weeks' treatment in a study of 165 participants.

      • one active control study comparing carbamazepine 200 mg versus a nortriptyline 10 mg/fluphenazine 0.5 mg combination (Gomez -Perez 1996). Only mean data were reported and the authors could not show a difference between the two treatments although it is stated that all patients improved

    • Conclusion: gabapentin is effective in post-herpetic neuralgia and diabetic neuropathy but does not appear to be superior to carbamazepine, a cheaper alternative in many countries. There were, however, no direct comparisons between these two drugs


Anticonvulsants diabetic neuropathic pain
結果摘要(II)

ACP journal (2002)

  • Review: Anticonvulsant drugs relieve chronic but not acute pain

    • 6 drugs: carbamazepine (12 trials), phenytoin (6 trials), sodium valproate (2 trials), gabapentin (2 trials), clonazepam (1 trial), and lamotrigine (1 trial)

    • Carbamazepine, phenytoin, and gabapentin were more effective than was placebo in relieving the pain of diabetic neuropathy

    • all caused such minor side effects as drowsiness, dizziness, constipation, nausea, and ataxia (numbers needed to harm [NNHs] ranged from 3 to 4). The NNHs for major harm were not statistically significant for any drug


Carbamazepine
結果摘要-Carbamazepine

  • 3 randomized clinical trial

  • 2 with placebo (Rull, 1969; Wilton, 1974)

    • More effective then placebo

  • 1 with nortriptyline and fluphenazine (Gomez-Perez, 1996)

    • Both drugs: improvements from baseline, but no significant difference between 2 drugs

  • Dose: 300-1000mg/d

  • Adverse events (up to 70%): Somnolence, dizziness, gait disturbance

  • Withdrawal rate: 0-7%


Phenytoin
結果摘要-Phenytoin

  • 2 randomized clinical trial(Chadda, 1978; Saude, 1977)

  • Conflicting result


Sodium valproate
結果摘要-Sodium valproate

  • 2 randomized clinical trial(91 p’t)(Kochar, 2002; 2004)

    • Significant improvement then placebo

      • SF-MPQ: 53.41 (1 month)

      • VAS: 6 3, SF-MPQ: 19.479.66, PPI: 2.711.33 (3 months)

    • Side effect: nausea:2, sedation:1, liver change:2

    • Dose: 1200mg, 1000mg/d


Gabapentin i
結果摘要-Gabapentin I

  • 4 randomized clinical trial

    • 3 with placebo, 1 with morphine, 1 with amitriptyline

  • Backonja, 1998 (165p’t)

    • 900 titrated to 3600mg/d

    • Significant pain relief than placebo, improvement of sleep, mood (pain score: 6.43.9; placebo:6.55.1)

    • Pain relief was observed during 2nd week when dose reached 1800mg/d

    • Dizziness 24%, somnolence 23%, headache 11%, diarrhea 11%

  • Gorsen, 1999 (40 p’t)

    • 900mg/d

    • Ineffective at dose of 900mg/d


Gabapentin ii
結果摘要-Gabapentin II

  • Morello, 1999 (28 p’t)

    • Gabapentin 900-1800mg, or Amitriptyline 25-75 mg /d

    • No significant different in pain relief

    • No significant difference in occurrence of adverse effects (17 in amitriptyline, 18 in gabapentin)

  • Gilron, 2005 (57p’t)

    • Gabapentin (3200mg), Morphine(120mg), combine(G 2400mg, M 60mg), placebo

    • Gabapentin and Morphine combined achieved better analgesia at lower dose of each drug

    • Adverse effect:

      • Combination: contipation↑than gabapentin, dry mouth↑than morphin


Lamotrigine
結果摘要-Lamotrigine

  • 1 randomized clinical trial (53 p’t)(Eisenberg, 2001)

  • Lamotrigine attenuates painful diabetic neuropathy at a daily dose of 200-400mg then placebo (NPS: 6.44.2, MPQ, PDI, BDI: unchanged)

  • Maximal pain reduction:37%, 12 p’t 50% pain reduction

  • Adverse events: similar to placebo (exception 2 rash developed)


Topiramate
結果摘要-Topiramate

  • 2 randomized clinical trial

  • Topiramate diabetic neuropathic pain study group, 2004 (3 trial)(1259 p’t)

    • 100mg, 200mg, 300mg

    • 1 effective, 2 no significant (placebo effect high, 38% and 48%)

    • Overall: no significant more effective than placebo

    • 16 ~ 31% discontinuation due to adverse events

  • Raskin, 2004 (12weeks, 323 p’t, 400mg)

    • ½ - 30%, 1/3 - 50% pain reduction

    • Reduced pain and body weight more effective than placebo

    • Adverse event: nausea, somnolence, dizziness, paresthesia, cognition dysfunction, appetite decrease

    • 48% dropout rate


Oxcarbazepine
結果摘要-Oxcarbazepine

  • 1 open-label trial (30p’t)(Beydoun, 2004)

    • Significant improvement in total pain score, and present pain intensity (VAS score: 66.334.3, 48.3%)

    • Dose: up to 1200mg/d (mean 814mg)

    • Adverse events(>10%): drowsiness, dizziness, headache, nausea, vomiting, diarrhea


Anticonvulsants diabetic neuropathic pain
總結(I)

  • 目前證據顯示carbamazepine, sodium valproate, lamotrigine, gabapentin在治療diabetic neuropathic pain可以顯著改善臨床症狀,但並無試驗直接比較不同anticonvulssants間的差別。

  • Topiramate, phenytoin在不同的臨床試驗出現不同的結果,對於diabetic neuropathic pain的效果尚無定論。

  • Oxcarbazepine, vigabatrin並無RCT來支持治療diabetic neuropathic pain的效果。

  • 新的anticonvulsants (gabapentin, topiramate, oxcarbazepine),仍有許多常見adverse effects如dizziness, somnolence, sedation的作用。

  • Sodium valproate及Lamitrigine的小型試驗中,有較少的副作用。


Anticonvulsants diabetic neuropathic pain
總結(II)

  • 對於治療diabetic neuropathic pain,anticonvulsants可以有效減緩疼痛症狀,但需注意治療所引起的不適及副作用。

  • 目前無證據顯示何種anticonvusants為最佳選擇,若考量花費,傳統anticonvulsants仍是優先選擇,若病患不能忍受副作用或是有過敏反應,則可給予不同的anticonvulsants。