120 likes | 298 Views
Effective Price Modeling How to Discover and Implement Profitable Underwriting Factors. Stephen J. Streff, ACAS, MAAA Consulting Actuary Streff Insurance Services www.streffinsurance.com 651-385-7500. Outline.
E N D
Effective Price ModelingHow to Discover and Implement Profitable Underwriting Factors Stephen J. Streff, ACAS, MAAA Consulting Actuary Streff Insurance Services www.streffinsurance.com 651-385-7500
Outline Purpose: Explore pricing techniques with an emphasis on adjusting underwriting factors • Overview of pricing models • Demonstrate sample analysis in Excel • Model impact of new rates on profits
Pricing Models • Macro models tell us how much the overall rates need to change. • Restate premium and losses to current level • Indicated rate change often used as guide; not always filed • By line, state; any finer and most models break down Historical Losses Projected Losses Trend for IBNR development and inflation Earned Premium Put past premium on current level Restated Premium
Pricing Models • Micro models tell us where the specific rates need to change. • Help adjust discounts and surcharges • Can find new rating parameters, too (credit score, loyalty, claims free) • Good for transition markets when only some factors need adjusting • Used to make rating systems more dispersed, finer
Macro vs. Micro • Both sample models achieve +5% overall increase • Macro moves all rates by the same amount • Micro models are flexible Rate Rate Macro Micro Risk Level Risk Level
Database Essentials • Excel format is standard • Link premium and loss files by policy • Key items: premium, losses, policy # • Analysis depends heavily on quality of data • Pivot tables
Sample Database • Midwestern home insurer; premium = $50 million • One underwriting year of data • No surcharges; only discounts (better marketing?) • Discounts for: Extra Info: Credit score Alarm Zip code Construction type Multi policy Mortgage free Agency Protection class New home Non smoker Policy status Coverage A, C & E Claim free Groups Policy form Deductible Loyalty Senior Year built Endorsements
Common Database Adjustments • Cap losses • Group categories • Exclude catastrophes • Lookup tables • Rounding • Not necessary to adjust losses & premium
Pivot Table Analysis • Look for trends in loss ratios, frequency and other statistics • Verify apparent trends • Make adjustments to discounts • Review impact of changes • Check reasonableness
Impact Models • Some policies will renew; others won’t • Randomly model renewals • Is expiring business worse than renewals? • What about new business?
Caveats and Warnings • Correlation does not prove causation • Do not over-react to indications • Watch data credibility • Need to be aware of marketplace
No Database? Don’t Give Up • Even tiny companies can implement discounts • Random sampling of policies can help • Use your intuition • Smaller and frequent rate changes are best