1 / 58

Charmonium and Charm Spectroscopy at the e + e - B-Factories

Charmonium and Charm Spectroscopy at the e + e - B-Factories. FPCP 2006, Vancouver April 10, 2006 Helmut Marsiske , SLAC. Outline. Note Microsoft convention: underline  overbar. Charmonium-candidate States X(3872), X(3940), Y(3940) Y(4260), Z(3930)

doris-hurley
Download Presentation

Charmonium and Charm Spectroscopy at the e + e - B-Factories

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Charmonium and Charm Spectroscopy at the e+e- B-Factories FPCP 2006, Vancouver April 10, 2006 Helmut Marsiske, SLAC

  2. Outline Note Microsoft convention: underline  overbar • Charmonium-candidate States • X(3872), X(3940), Y(3940) Y(4260), Z(3930) • Charmed-strange Mesons • DsJ*(2317), DsJ(2460) • Charmed Baryons • Λc(2940), Ξcx(2980), Ξcx(3077) Tetraquarks, D*D molecules, ccg hybrids, etc. No (charmed) Pentaquarks @ B-factories Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  3. Continuum production: √s ≤ 10.58 GeV e+e-cc (ISR, double charmonium) two-photon Production in B decay: √s ≈ 5.28 GeV bc transition B(cc)K(*) Charm/onium Productionat BABAR, Belle, and CLEO • Very large data samples • 450-700M cc events, • 380-590M BB events Detectors with excellent tracking, vertexing, e.m. calorimetry, and particle ID Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  4. X(3872)+-J/ Belle: 152M BB PRL 91, 262001 (2003) • Observed in B-decay Belle: 275M BB hep-ex/0505038 BABAR: 232M BB PRD 73, 011101 (2006) N=61.2±15.3 (6.1 σ) N=49.1±8.4 B± only Solid hist.: mES sidebands B± and B0 Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  5. Inclusive Search for BK X(3872) BABAR: 232M BB PRL 96, 052002 (2006) • BB sample with one B fully reconstructed • Two-body decay of other B  monochromatic line in the kaon momentum spectrum in the B-meson center-of-mass (CM) frame No charged X(3872) observed Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  6. X(3872)J/  C(X)=+1 BABAR: 287M BB Preliminary N=19.4±5.7 (3.4 σ) Belle: 275M BB hep-ex/0505037 #B’s in 64MeV bins of M(J/) N=13.6±4.4 (4.0 σ) S=1.3 Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  7. +- Invariant Mass Spectrumin X(3872)+-J/ Belle: 275M BB hep-ex/0505038 • C(X)=+1  IG(JPC)[+-]= 1+(1--)  0 • Expect +- invariant mass spectrum to peak near the upper kinematic boundary • [+-] - J/ in relative S-wave or P-wave • M(+-) centrifugal suppression • S-wave: JPC(X)= 0++, 1++, 2++ • P-wave: JPC(X)= 0-+, 1-+, 2-+ • P(X(3872))=+1 preferred Shaded: X(3872) sidebands S-wave P-wave 2/d.o.f = 43.1/39 2/d.o.f = 71.0/39 Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  8. X(3872) Isospin BABAR: 234M BB PRD 71, 031501 (2005) • Isospin=1 for C=+1 +-J/ final state, but no charged partners X±(3872)  Initial state X0(3872) isospin=0  X(3872)+-J/ isospin-violating decay • Isospin-allowed decay X(3872)+- 0 J/ suppressed by kinematics • C(X)=+1  IG(JPC)[+- 0]= 0-(1--)   Belle: 275M BB hep-ex/0505037 Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  9. BK X(3872), X(3872)+-J/ Decay Angular Distributions c2/dof = 11/9 ql |cosql| K c2/dof = 5/9 c |cosc| Belle: 275M BB hep-ex/0505038 • Exclude JPC = 0-+, 0++ with 2/d.o.f = 34.2/9, 31.0/9 • Consistent with JPC = 1++ • Inconclusive for JPC = 2++ Red: X(3872)sidebands Angles in the X(3872)rest frame J.L. Rosner, PRD 70, 094023 (2004) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  10. X(3872)D0D00 (D0D*0) N=12.5±3.9 (>5) Preliminary Belle: ~270M BB MoriondQCD06 M(D0D00) in B signal region: |ΔE|<10 MeV; shaded: |ΔE| sidebands M(D0D0p0) ≈ M(X) JPC=2++ D-wave required  very unlikely so close to threshold No DD decay for JP=1+ Decay into 3 pseudoscalars excludes JP=0+ Everything consistent with I=0, JPC=1++ for X(3872) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  11. X0(3940) Belle: 375 fb-1 hep-ex/0507019 • Observed in the recoil against J/ in cc continuum events together with three known C=+1 cc states: c , c0 , c (2S) N=266±63 (5.0 σ) Possible interpretation: X(3940) = c(3S) DD threshold JPC=0-+ for c(3S) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy Surprisingly large J/-(cc) cross section for NRQCD

  12. X0(3940)D*D Mrec(J/yD)=M(D) Mrec(J/yD)=M(D*) Belle: 375 fb-1 hep-ex/0507019 • Above D(*)D threshold  search for DD and D*D decay [constrain recoil against (J/ D)] Shaded: D sidebands DD No DD decay for JPC=0-+ D*- D P-wave for JPC=0-+ N=24.5±6.9 (5.0 σ) D*D No large decay into J/ : Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  13. Y(3940)J/ C(Y)=+1 Belle: 275M BB PRL 94, 182002 (2005) • Large threshold enhancement observed in B-decay • If interpreted as S-wave resonance • Unlikely decay mode for cc state above D(*)D threshold • Different from X(3940)? #B’s in bins of M(J/) N=58±11 (>8 σ) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  14. Z(3930)D0D0, D+D- Belle: 395 fb-1 PRL 96, 082003 (2006) • Observed in two-photon interactions  C=+1 N=64±18 (5.3 σ) Solid line: J = 2, =2 2/d.o.f= 1.9/9 Dashed line: no signal Dashed line: J = 0 2/d.o.f= 23.4/9 Solid hists.: Dsidebands |cos*|: D angle w.r.t. beam axis in  CM Likely 23P2 cc state: c2(2P) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  15. Y(4260)+-J/ (2S) BABAR: 233 fb-1 PRL 95, 142001 (2005) • Observed in ISR events  JPC = 1-- • Indication in B-decay  needs confirmation Assuming single resonance N=123±23 (>8 σ) BABAR: 232 fb-1 PRD 73, 012005 (2006) Peak cross section: σ(e+e-Y)=(51±12) pb BABAR: 232M BB PRD 73, 011101 (2006) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  16. Confirmation of Y(4260) in CLEO-c Scan √s=3.77 - 4.26 GeV CLEO-c: 13.2 pb-1 hep-ex/0602034 • Enhanced cross section for e+e-J/ @ √s=4.26 GeV NB: BABAR +-J/ peak cross section: (51±12) pb N=37 (11 σ) N=8 (5.1 σ) No sign of (4040)=(3S) decay to+-J/  Y(4260)= (4S) assignment less likely Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  17. More Confirmation of Y(4260)from CLEO-III CLEO-III: 13.3 fb-1 Preliminary • ISR production of +-J/ events in CLEO-III data near √s=10.58 GeV Note: CLEO-III efficiency is ~1.7 times BABAR. Boost? Detector?? N≈12 (4.9 σ) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  18. No Indication for Y(4260) in Other ISR-produced Final States (3770) DD(3900) (4040) (4160) Shaded: D sidebands M(K+K-) (4415) Y(4260) Shaded:  sidebands BABAR: 232 fb-1 To.b.subm.to PRD BABAR: 289 fb-1 To.b.subm.to PRL Preliminary Preliminary BABAR: 232 fb-1 PRD 73, 012005 (2006) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  19. Charmonium-candidate States Tetraquarks, D*D molecules, ccg hybrids, etc. Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  20. Update on Charmed-strange MesonsDsJ*(2317)+ and DsJ(2460)+ BABAR: 232 fb-1 Submitted to PRD • Comprehensive study of decays to Ds+ plus one or two ±, 0, or ’s • Decay pattern if JP=0+ and JP=1+, respectively Preliminary Ds+0 only decay mode observed for DsJ*(2317)+ NB: all “Seen” modes are also “Allowed” Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  21. No indication of neutral or doubly-charged partner near 2317 MeV  I=0 DsJ*(2317)+Ds+0 BABAR: 232 fb-1 Submitted to PRD N=3180±80 Preliminary Ds*(2112) signal Preliminary Ds*(2112) reflection Dark shade: DsJ(2460) reflection Circles: Ds sidebands Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  22. BDDsJ*(2317)+,DsJ*(2317)+Ds+0 0 Belle: 274M BB BELLE-CONF- 0461 (2004) • DsJ*(2317) decay mode  natural spin-parity • DsJ*(2317) decay angular distribution  spin 0 Dotted line: J = 1 2/d.o.f = 38/8 Natural spin- parity  JP = 0+ Solid line: J = 0 2/d.o.f = 3/8 Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  23. DsJ(2460)+Ds+  / Ds*(2112)+0 Ds*+Ds+ DsJ(2460)+Ds+ Preliminary Preliminary N=560±40 Open points: Ds sidebands Light shade: Ds*(2112) reflection Dark shade: DsJ*(2317) reflection N=920±60 Open points: Ds sidebands BABAR: 232 fb-1 Submitted to PRD Preliminary Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  24. BDDsJ(2460)+ Belle: 274M BB BELLE-CONF-0461 (2004) (b): DsJ(2460)+Ds+ (c): DsJ(2460)+Ds *(2112) +0 Ds*+ Ds+ No Ds  decay for J=0 Ds*0 Dashed line: J = 2 2/d.o.f = 89/8 Solid line: J = 1 S-wave Solid line: J = 1 2/d.o.f = 4/8 JP = 1+ cos(Ds*0) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  25. No indication of DsJ*(2317)+ Also observe Ds1(2536)+ DsJ(2460)+Ds++- BABAR: 232 fb-1 Submitted to PRD N=6±3 Preliminary DsJ*(2317) N=193±22 N=123±15 Ds1(2536) DsJ(2460) Preliminary Preliminary Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  26. DsJ(2460)+ Absolute Branching Fractions (BFs) p e- D* Breco e+ Bsignal D* X BABAR: 230M BB To.b.subm.to PRL • BB sample with one B fully reconstructed  study decays of other BD(*)+,0 X • Observe DsJ(2460) signals in the recoil mass, mX Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  27. DsJ(2460)+ Absolute BFs, cont. BABAR: 122M BB PRL 93, 181801 (2004) • Combine with previously measured, exclusive product BFs BD(*) DsJ(2460)+, DsJ(2460)+Ds+ / Ds*(2112)+0to obtain absolute BFs: • Sum of known BFs: 0.70±0.15 Preliminary (Ds*+ Ds+) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  28. Charmed-strange Mesons cs P-wave, tetraquarks, etc. DsJ(2460) absolute branching fractions (BFs) BABAR: 232 fb-1 Preliminary BABAR: 230M BB Preliminary Belle: 274M BB BELLE-CONF-0461 (2004) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  29. New Charmed Baryon: Λc(2940)+ Λc(2880) Λc(2940) Shaded: D0 sidebands Blue: D0p BABAR: 287 fb-1 Submitted to PRL • Observed in cc continuum events in the decay mode D0p (D0K-+, K-++-) • First observation of Λc(2880)+D0p • No structure in D+p • No doubly-charged partner for either state Preliminary N=2280±310 (>7 σ) N=3020 ±220 Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  30. Two New Charmed-Strange Baryons: Ξcx(2980)+ and Ξcx(3077)+ Belle: 462 fb-1 MoriondQCD06 • Observed in cc continuum events in the decay mode Λc+K-+ (Λc+pK-+) Preliminary No structure in right- sign Λc+ sidebands or wrong-sign Λc+K+-, Λc+K-- modes No indication of doubly-charmed Ξcc(3520) (SELEX) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  31. Summary: Charmed Baryons Belle: 462 fb-1 MoriondQCD06 BABAR: 287 fb-1 Preliminary • Three new states • New decay mode Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  32. Summary: Charmed-strange Mesons • Consistent with cs P-wave states • Masses unexpectedly low Belle: 274M BB BELLE-CONF-0461 (2004) BABAR: 232 fb-1 Preliminary BABAR: 230M BB Preliminary DsJ(2460) absolute branching fractions (BFs) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  33. Summary: Charmonium-candidate States Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  34. Backup slides Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  35. Charmonium-candidate States Tetraquarks, D*D molecules, ccg hybrids, etc. Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  36. Searches for X(3872)+-J/ in other processes • No ISR production  JPC  1-- • No quasi-real two-photon production  JPC 0-+, 0++, 2++ BABAR: 89 fb-1 PRD 71, 052001 (2005) CLEO: 15.1 fb-1 PRL 94, 032004 (2005) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  37. +- Invariant Mass Spectrumin X(3872)+-J/ , cont. CDF II: 360 pb-1 hep-ex/0512074 • C(X)=+1  IG(JPC)[+-]= 1+(1--)  0 • [+-] - J/ in relative S-wave or P-wave • S-wave: JPC(X)= 0++, 1++, 2++ • P-wave: JPC(X)= 0-+, 1-+, 2-+, 3-+ 1260±130 X(3872) candidates Unable to distinguish S-wave (P=+1) and P-wave (P=-1) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  38. X0(3872) in B±and B0 Decays BABAR: 232M BB PRD 73, 011101 (2006) • Charge-specific branching fractions • Mass difference N=8.3±4.5 (2.5 σ) B0 only Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  39. X±(3872) in B±and B0 Decays • Charge-specific branching fractions BABAR: 232M BB PRD 73, 011101 (2006) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  40. X(3872)J/+- JPC= 1  y(2S),y(3770), … • Belle: discovery • Unexpected discovery mode for charmonium state above open-charm threshold • BABAR: search for X(3872)J/+- in Initial State Radiation (ISR) Events • ISR  e+e- collisions with a continuum of center-of-mass (CM) energies below the (4S) • Search final state PRL 91, 262001 (2003) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  41. No evidence for Y(4260) in R-scan Y(4260) R √s (GeV) • Dip in R at √s=4.26GeV R≈3 and σ=(14.2±0.6)nb Y(4260) decay mode  conventional charmonium interpretation does not fit well Factors >10 and >20 larger than J/+- partial width of (2S) and (3770), resp. Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  42. Indication of Y(4260) J/+-in B decay • Search for • 3.1σ significance, assuming mass and width from ISR analysis; needs confirmation PRD 73, 011101 (2006) 232M BB Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  43. +- Invariant Mass Spectrum in Y(4260)+-J/ • C(Y)= -1 IG(JPC)[+-]= 0+(0++, 2++) BABAR: 233 fb-1 PRL 95, 142001 (2005) CLEO-c: 13.2 pb-1 hep-ex/0602034 Submitted to PRL Solid hist: +- phase spacefor (+-) - J/ S-wave Solid hist: +- spectrum likein (2S)+-J/ #Y’s in bins of M(+-) +- invariant mass spectrum inconclusive Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  44. Other Y(4260) Decay Modes? BABAR: 232 fb-1 PRD 73, 012005 (2006) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  45. Discovery of X(3872)J/+- 157M BBbar y(2S) Events/10 MeV/c2 M(J/yp+p-) - M(J/y) (GeV/c2) • Belle: • Confirmed by CDF, D0, and BABAR • X(3872) properties • Mass at DD* threshold • Narrow width • JPC=1++ favored • m(+-) consistent with  • No evidence for charged partner X±(3872) PRL 91, 262001 (2003) 157M BB Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  46. X(3872) Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  47. X(3872) • Some DD molecule predictions: Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  48. Charmed-strange Mesons BABAR: 91 fb-1 PRL 90, 242001 (2003) CLEO: 13.5 fb-1 PRD 68, 032002 (2003) Belle: 124M BB PRL 91, 262002 (2003) • DsJ*(2317) and DsJ(2460) first observed by BABAR and CLEO in cc continuum events, and by Belle in B-decay • Both masses unexpectedly low: below DK and D*K threshold, respectively • Only isospin-violating or electromagnetic decays kinematically allowed  narrow widths • Decay pattern and decay angular distributions consistent with interpretation as P-wavecs mesons with JP=0+ and JP=1+, respectively Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  49. Charmed-strange Mesons Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

  50. Summary of DsJ*(2317)+ and DsJ(2460)+ Branching Ratio Results BABAR: 232 fb-1 Submitted to PRD Helmut Marsiske, SLAC Charm/onium Spectroscopy

More Related