1 / 41

Outpatient Clinics

Outpatient Clinics. HCM 540 – Operations Management. Operational Inputs and Outputs - Clinics. Performance Measures. Input/Decision Variables. Appointment Lead Time Patient Wait Time – initial, for provider, repeat waits Patient Time in Clinic Length of clinic day Exam Room Utilization

dexter
Download Presentation

Outpatient Clinics

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Outpatient Clinics HCM 540 – Operations Management

  2. Operational Inputs and Outputs - Clinics Performance Measures Input/Decision Variables • Appointment Lead Time • Patient Wait Time – initial, for provider, repeat waits • Patient Time in Clinic • Length of clinic day • Exam Room Utilization • Support Space Utilization • Provider and Support Staff Utilization • Patient satisfaction • Staff satisfaction • Profitability • Volume by Patient Type • Provider and Support Staffing • Appointment Scheduling Policies • Exam Room Allocation Policies • Patient Flow Patterns

  3. A High Level Clinic Architecture 2 1 3

  4. A myriad of questions – demand? • Who is the underlying population to serve? • What is the level of demand that can be satisfied by a clinic? • How do you manage panels of patients for providers? • what is the expected workload generated by a given panel of patients? • What are the basic types of patients served? • Appointments, walk-ins, both? • Demand for advance appt’s vs. same-day appointments

  5. The Front Desk? • How should the “front desk” be staffed? • appointment scheduling • patient phone questions • patient check in/out • billing • How long do patients wait on the phone for scheduling appts, medical questions, billing questions? • What about information systems to support patient records, appointment scheduling, billing?

  6. How is appointment capacity organized? • How much appointment vs. walk-in capacity is needed? • appointment templates • how many of each “type” of appointment to offer? • how to best sequence mix of appointments? • how to estimate length of time block for each type of appt? • leave appt slots open for same day appointments? • open access concept (Murray and Tantau) • how many? • how many and how to schedule different specialty “sub-clinics” within an OP Clinic

  7. Start Slot Appointment Patients Time Length Type Per Slot 8:30 30 NEW 1 9:00 15 Postpartum 1 9:15 15 Follow Up 1 9:30 15 Follow Up 1 9:45 15 Follow Up 1 10:00 30 NEW 1 10:30 15 Follow Up 1 10:45 15 Follow Up 1 11:00 15 Follow Up 1 11:15 15 Follow Up 1 11:30 15 Follow Up 1 Appointment Templates 2 Template ID: Phys_Mon_AM_OB Provider Type: Physician Day / Time: Monday AM Clinic: OB • How does one design good templates? • how many each type? • slot length? • sequencing • Template management • Basis for generation of daily appointment schedules

  8. How is other resource capacity organized? • How many exam rooms per provider? • are the rooms assigned? • Do patients get appointments with specific providers? • How much support staff needed? • Where are various clinical interventions done? Who does them? • How much waiting room capacity is needed?

  9. Appointment scheduling? • Do you overbook? By how much? • Performance measures for your overall appointment scheduling process? • How do you measure how long your patients are waiting for an appointment? • do you know when they want the appointment and whether their request was satisfied? • How do you most effectively use appointment scheduling information systems?

  10. The Mathematics of Appt Scheduling • tradeoffs between patient & provider wait, length of clinic day, provider utilization appt time last patient x x x x x idle clinic run over end of exam patient wait • individual appointments or blocks of patients given same appt time? (ex: 2 patients at start of day, then individual)

  11. The Mathematics of Appt Scheduling • Decent amount of research on various simplified versions of the appt scheduling problem • single patient type usually considered • punctuality often assumed (patients and providers) • simple patient care path (one visit to provider) • Important variables • mean exam time, coefficient of variation of exam time • number of appts scheduled in a session • punctuality, no-show rates • relative wait cost ratio between providers and patients • Some findings • need good estimates of exam times • relatively simple rules like scheduling 2 patients at the start of the clinic and then spacing appts out by mean exam time performed well in simulation experiments • the “best” schedule depends on your objectives and parameter values • impact on practice has been limited (O’Keefe, Worthington, Vissers)

  12. More about the math of appt scheduling • Vissers, J. “Selecting a suitable appointment system in an outpatient setting”, Medical Care, XVII, No. 12, Dec. 1979. • Ho and Lau, “Minimizing total cost in scheduling outpatient appointments”, Management Science, 38, 12, Dec 1992. • Vanden Bosch, P.M. and D.C. Dietz, “Scheduling and sequencing arrivals to an appointment system”, http://www.e-optimization.com/resources/uploads/jsr.pdf • Bailey, N.T.J., “A study of queues and appointment systems in hospital outpatient departments”, J. Roy. Stat. Soc. B, 14, 185, 1952 • first paper published about the topic of appt systems • Fetter, R.B. and J.D. Thompson, “Patients waiting time and physicians’ idle time in the outpatient setting”, Health Services Research, 1, 66, 1966. • another early classic

  13. A Partially Successful OR Engagement (Bennett and Worthington) • Ophthalmology clinic • new and follow up patients • Routine, Soon, Urgent • Three ½ day clinic sessions per week • 3 docs (11N, 33FU for regular clinic) • Overbooked, overrun, excessive patient waits • Mr. T suspected the appt system • Fundamental issue of matching capacity to demand • “systems thinking” view Interfaces 28:5 Sep-Oct 1998 (pp.56-69)

  14. Vicious Circle of Insufficient Capacity and Overbooking Interfaces 28:5 Sep-Oct 1998 (pp.56-69)

  15. A Simple Patient Flow Model multiple waits Interfaces 28:5 Sep-Oct 1998 (pp.56-69)

  16. Analysis Highlights • Consideration of both process and organizational issues • Patients were generally punctual • waited on avg 40 mins to see physician (51 mins including repeat waits) • Simple model for “clinic appt build up” • highlighted severity of demand>capacity • vacation notice deadline for providers • Simple model to assess impact of lengthening time between routine visits • an attempt to decrease demand Interfaces 28:5 Sep-Oct 1998 (pp.56-69)

  17. Analysis Highlights • Used specialized queueing model to explore different appt scheduling patterns • as expected, by spacing out appts further, wait to see provider decreased but at increase in provider idleness • of course, less appts will also exacerbate the difficulty in getting an appt • http://www.lums.lancs.ac.uk/MANSCI/Staff/worthing.htm • Developed list of long term and shorter term operational strategies • some were implemented to various degrees • however, not much really changed over 2½ years • OP Clinics are messy, complex, and different constituencies have different goals and objectives • Simple models and “applied common sense” (O’Keefe paper) Interfaces 28:5 Sep-Oct 1998 (pp.56-69)

  18. Patients late/early Doctors late No shows, cancellations Excessive overbooking Inappropriate appt lengths Highly variable consultation times Lack of data about operations Walk-ins Staff absences Understaffing Not enough space Not enough appt capacity Poor information flow Many more... Why might not the clinic be running smoothly?

  19. Open Access • Premise – adjust capacity as needed to meet customer demand • accommodate all appointment requests • developed by Kaiser Permanente (CA) • popularized by Murray and Tantau • Three common models • traditional access • 1st generation open access • 2nd generation open access

  20. Learning More About Open Acces • 1.Improving access to clinical offices.Author: Kilo CM; Triffletti P; Tantau C, and others Source: J Med Pract Manage (The Journal of medical practice management : MPM.) 2000 Nov-Dec; 16(3): 126-32 Libraries: 104   (MEDLINE) • 2.Same-day appointments: exploding the access paradigm.Author: Murray M; Tantau C Source: Fam Pract Manag (Family practice management.) 2000 Sep; 7(8): 45-50 Libraries: 119   (MEDLINE) • 3.Redefining open access to primary care.Author: Murray M; Tantau C Source: Manag Care Q (Managed care quarterly.) 1999 Summer; 7(3): 45-55 Libraries: 158   (MEDLINE) • 4.Must patients wait?Author: Murray M; Tantau C Source: Jt Comm J Qual Improv (The Joint Commission journal on quality improvement.) 1998 Aug; 24(8): 423-5 Libraries: 1015   (MEDLINE)

  21. Traditional Access • Demand controlled by reservoir of supply • Appts booked to end of queue, schedules get saturated, little holding of capacity for short-term demand • Often multiple appt types • Emphasis on matching demand to desired physician • Urgent demand “added on” or “worked in” • May lead to long appt lead times

  22. 1st Generation Open Access • More “patient focused” • I want to see my doc, and I want to see him/her now • Premise: demand can be forecasted with sufficient accuracy to allow better matching of capacity to demand • “Carve out” capacity each day for projected SDA demand • Urgent vs. Routine appt stratification

  23. Some Problems with 1st Generation Open Access • Mismatches between patient and PCP • Definition of “urgent” is fuzzy and changes as day goes on • Creation of new appt types to meet urgent needs of patient who can’t come in today • Queues for routine tend to grow • gets shifted to use urgent capacity • affects phone in capacity and SDA capacity • Black market or “second appt book” which fills “held” appts as they come available

  24. 2nd Generation Open Access • “Create capacity” by doing all today’s work today • No distinction between urgent and routine • Appts are taken for the day the patient wants independent of capacity • Every effort to match patient with PCP • Challenges • predict total demand • provider flexibility • panel management – how big?, how much work generated by a given panel?

  25. Demand Management • Upstream • population mgt • prevention and wellness • self-care • disease mgt • manage chronic conditions • Midstream • walk-in or call-in • coordinate with ancillary providers • maximize visit efficiency • match patient to provider • Downstream • education • telephone follow-up • lengthen visit intervals • change future point of service entry

  26. Many different appt scheduling packages • AppointmentsPro • One-Call (Per-Se Technologies) • Brickell Scheduler • GBS • HealthcareData Link • single appointments vs. series of appointments • comprehensive resource scheduling? • enterprise wide vs. departmental? • integration with existing IS? • remote access? • capacity • price, vendor support, vendor viability

  27. Computer Simulation & OP Clinics Input/Decision Variables • Simulation quite useful for exploring impact of operational inputs on system performance Performance Measures • Volume by Patient Type • clinical type – times for each step in care • routine, soon, urgent • Provider and Support Staffing • MA-provider ratio • pool or dedicated? • Appointment Scheduling Policies • template design • slot length • sequencing • overbooking • Exam Room Allocation Policies • rooms per provider • pool or dedicated • Patient Flow Patterns • what gets done where by whom • Appointment Lead Time • Patient Wait Time – initial, for provider, total • Patient Time in Clinic • Length of Clinic Day • Exam Room Utilization • Support Space Utilization • Provider and Support Staff Utilization

  28. Simulation provides surprising staffing and operation improvements at family practice clinics (Allen, Ballash, and Kimball) • Intermountain Health Care • integrated health system based in Utah • > 70 clinics, 840,000 enrollees, 2000 docs • clinics ranged in size, configuration, operating tactics • Developed generic clinic simulation model to explore impact of different configurations/tactics on performance • MedModel – healthcare specific simulation development tool (like ProcessModel on steroids) • Paper has very nice description of a typical simulation analysis in healthcare Proceedings of the 1997 HIMSS Conference – handed out in class

  29. A few highlights and things to note ( from Allen, Ballash, and Kimball) • Started with “simple” model and added complexity as needed • Obtained “patient treatment profiles” from healthcare consulting firm • Fig 3,6 – “Low” MA utilization is “good” • MA team had dramatic positive effect over assigned MAs – from 6 down to 4 MAs with only 4% ACLOS increase • 3 rooms/doc not better than 2 per doc • wait “moved” from waiting room to exam room • Dedicating exam rooms to docs did not adversely impact performance – not the bottleneck • Patient scheduling matters at higher workloads • Overbooking had significant negative impact on patient waits Proceedings of the 1997 HIMSS Conference – handed out in class

  30. A few highlights and things to note ( from Allen, Ballash, and Kimball) • Used results as springboard to look at IHC clinics and how they operate • Assessed feasibility of implementing insights gained from the modeling process • Noted that significant changes (“reengineering”) of the patient care process will likely change the results of the analysis • so, rerun it, that’s the beauty of having a model. Proceedings of the 1997 HIMSS Conference – handed out in class

  31. Example of a Clinic Simulation Model

  32. Visit Flow Diagram - 1

  33. Visit Flow Diagram - 2

  34. Visit Flow Diagram - 3

  35. Visit Flow Diagram - 4

  36. Input Parameters and Files 1-3 Input Files • Appointment book • Exam room assignments • No-show rates

  37. Experimenting with the Model • Scenario 1 - Current • patient prep done at Vitals Station • one exam room per provider • Scenario 2 - Prep in Exam Room • patient prep done in Exam Room • one exam room per provider • Scenario 3 - Prep in Exam Room and Two Exam Rooms per Provider

  38. Wait Time Components Scenario Comparisons

  39. Another use of Simulation • Ran set of simulation experiments for range of volumes, exam times, staffing levels, rooms/doc, prep location • Developed simple spreadsheet based model using Pivot Tables to find max volume subject to constraints on patient waiting and clinic length • Currently developing regression and neural network based prediction models from the simulation experimental output • FamPractice_clinic.xls

  40. Some Relevant Journals • Journal of Medical Practice Management • Journal of the American Board of Family Practice • Managed Care Quarterly • Family Practice Management • Medical Group Management Journal • http://mpmnetwork.com/

More Related