1 / 16

Broken Windows or Broken Logic?

Broken Windows or Broken Logic?. Supervising Offenders in the Community. Broken Windows Probation. 3 Million In Our Midst “Hundreds and thousands of violent crimes are committed each year by people on probation” The public wants to reduce violent crime now

dex
Download Presentation

Broken Windows or Broken Logic?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Broken Windows orBroken Logic? Supervising Offenders in the Community

  2. Broken Windows Probation • 3 Million In Our Midst • “Hundreds and thousands of violent crimes are committed each year by people on probation” • The public wants to reduce violent crime now • 2/3 of probationers commit another crime within three years of their sentence • In 1991 (nationally), 6,400 murders, 7,400 rapes, 11,400 assaults, 17,000 robberies • Conditions not “rigorously enforced” • Absconders run amok

  3. Why is Probation “Broke(N)?” • Funding Levels • 2/3 of the people, 1/3 of the corrections dollar • $20-50K per year for prison, $200 for probation • Caseloads of 100-500 offenders • Bad Practices • Drug testing that is scheduled in advance • Supervision in Office (doesn’t manage risk) • Average of one contact per month

  4. The Solution:Placing Public Safety First • Supervise in neighborhood, not office • More “surveillance,” ability to monitor and control • “Meaningful” supervision occurs at all hours • Rationally allocate Resources • Better risk and need assessment • Supervision based on Geography • Enforce violations quickly/strongly • “Deterrent Effect,” Track down absconders

  5. More Goals • Develop partners in the Community • Work with police, victims, schools, neighborhood groups, inform public… • PO’s act like “C.O.P.s” (attend “neighborhood meetings, adopt “placed-based” supervision • Establish “Performance Based Initiatives” • Good research with clearly measured outcomes

  6. Structural Issues in Re-thinking • Case Assignments, Job Responsibilities • Job Description and Training • Caseload, Resource, Technical Support • Community Involvement and Support

  7. Fixing “Broken Windows” • General Criticisms: • Ignores single most consistent finding in probation literature: treatment works, surveillance and control does not • “Community Supervision” • Publicity stunt to get funding • Is this based on any evidence? • Short-term thinking

  8. Improve Public Safety • P.O.s should be asked to do LESS, not more • Cannot be held responsible for community safety—focus on offender • Develop sanctioning strategies that do not result in a significant # of offenders in jail • Treatment is the only known way to improve safety

  9. Supervise in Community? • Location, location, location only for houses • Any evidence this will work? (not really) • How monitor P.O.s? • “Supervision” becomes main role of P.O. • “Monitor and Control” emphasis • Union/staff resistance to hours/job

  10. Rationally Allocate Resources • Council focuses on existing $ • Improve assessment? • Cost of this? • Treatment availability, cost, quality? • Shift (back) to “place-based” supervision • Generalist vs. Specialist • There are reasons for the “specialist”

  11. Strong Enforcement of Conditions • Past decade? Increase in number and type of conditions • Use better judgment with conditions • Develop system of graduated sanctions • Council still relies on incarceration as a “general deterrent” to others…support for this is weak • Probation Based “Absconder Units” • $ for this? What to do when we catch them? • Why do probationers abscond?

  12. Partners in the Community • Operation Night Light • Allows probation to appear more “police-like” • Appear “tougher” • IRONY can be pretty ironic sometimes • COP envisions police acting as “resource brokers” • Dumja Vu • Council claims that “ONL” reduced homicide • Exaggerated claims unsupported by sound research • Ends ($) justify the means (use crappy research as “evidence”

  13. Final Comments on BW’s • Council ignores the fact that over 70% of offenders placed on probation will complete their term without new arrest • More effective than: • JAIL • Prison • Intermediate Sanctions • Core technology of probation? Individual Offender Change

  14. Supervision Models • Casework Era • Brokerage Model • Justice Model • “Supervision and Control” • Integrated • Control and Treatment are not incompatible • Pg. 117 = Martinson Blasphemy

  15. Probation Officer Work Styles • The “Law Enforcer” • The “Time Server” • The “Therapeutic Agent” • The “Synthetic”

  16. Caseloads and Workloads • “Average Caseload” not that important • Most jurisdictions have different levels • Specialized Caseloads (sex offenders, drugs, etc.) • “Regular” • Parole = 67 • Probation = 124 • “Intensive” • Parole = 38 • Probation = 25 • Assigning Cases: “workload standard”

More Related