70 likes | 185 Views
Catching the angora cat - Lessons from Venice. EPLAW Annual Meeting and Congress Brussels , Le Méridien Friday December 2 nd , 2011 By Klaus Haft. Starting point : Art. 69 EPC. Issue in question. Should prosecution history be regarded in claim interpretation?.
E N D
Catching the angora cat-Lessons from Venice. EPLAW Annual Meeting and Congress Brussels, Le Méridien Friday December 2nd, 2011 By Klaus Haft
Startingpoint: Art. 69 EPC www.rokh-ip.com
Issue in question • Should prosecution history be regarded in claim interpretation? • Theory: Claim interpretation is leading to same results during prosecution and litigation • Practice: www.rokh-ip.com
Thinkingthroughout Europe (asdiscussed in Venice) www.rokh-ip.com
Thinking throughout Europe (as gathered by AIPPI in Q175) www.rokh-ip.com
ConclusionsfromVenice • There seems to be a majority in favor of using the file history also in infringement proceedings. • However, there also seems to be a rather broad consensus that this would be relevant or should be regarded - depending on the starting point - only in exceptional cases. www.rokh-ip.com
Klaus Haft REIMANN OSTERRIETH KÖHLER HAFT Steinstraße 20 O7, 16 40212 Düsseldorf 68161 Mannheim Tel. +49 151 1672 2759 Klaus.Haft@rokh-ip.com www.rokh-ip.com Thank you!