160 likes | 333 Views
Overview. Papers174 submitted169 reviewed36 acceptedTutorials4 tutorialsPosters15 postersAttendanceLatest count: 304. WorkshopsTransactional Memory WorkloadsPL and Analysis for SecurityLang. Comp.
E N D
1. PLDI 2006Core Dump Thomas Ball
PLDI Program Chair
2. Overview Papers
174 submitted
169 reviewed
36 accepted
Tutorials
4 tutorials
Posters
15 posters
Attendance
Latest count: 304
3. Program Committee
4. Distribution of PC Phd Ages
5. Paper Reviewing 20 member PC
26 papers/PC member
4th expert (outside) review on most papers
Physical meeting after POPL in Charleston, SC
No blind review, no author feedback
EasyChair system for reviewing
6. Review Process Set 36 papers as a ceiling, not a goal
First discussed top 60 papers in sort order
PC members proposed other papers
Discussed 90-100 papers
Each paper assigned a champion
7. Distribution of Paper Input
8. Distribution of Paper Input
9. Distribution of Paper Input
10. Does Order Received Matter?
11. Does Order Received Matter?
12. Does Order Received Matter?
13. History
17. Accepting More Quality Papers Critical mass, maturity, diversity
Depth and breadth
It’s about community
exclusive
lower acceptance rate (15-20%)
minor deviations lead to rejecting quality papers
focus on rejection rather than acceptance
inclusive
higher acceptance rate (20-25%)
minor deviations have less effect
focus on acceptance rather than rejection