1 / 46

Searching for Solar Shocks

Searching for Solar Shocks. Including a brief history of X-ray astronomy H. Hudson, SPRC/UCSD/ISAS. Beautiful Chandra shock. (E0102-72). How X-ray astronomy began. September 21, 1859 (Carrington) Kew Gardens - magnetic effects The proper conservatism of L. Kelvin of Largs.

colman
Download Presentation

Searching for Solar Shocks

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Searching for Solar Shocks Including a brief history of X-ray astronomy H. Hudson, SPRC/UCSD/ISAS

  2. Beautiful Chandra shock (E0102-72)

  3. How X-ray astronomy began • September 21, 1859 (Carrington) • Kew Gardens - magnetic effects • The proper conservatism of L. Kelvin of Largs

  4. Latent discoveries • X-rays (Roentgen, 1895) • The ionosphere (Heaviside, 1902) • Collisionless shock waves - ? • “Space weather” - ??

  5. Oliver Heaviside • Maxwell’s equations • Laplace transforms • The Heaviside function • Telegraph equation - Pupin Laboratory • Heavy opposition to quaternions • T.S. Eliot, Cats, “Journey to the Heaviside Layer” • Not the father of X-ray astronomy (due credit to B. Rossi, of course) • “Why should I refuse a good dinner simply because I don't understand the digestive processes involved.”

  6. We’re in a golden era of coronal observation

  7. The dynamic corona

  8. The boundary between Photosphere and corona • Density plummets precipitously • Collisionality diminishes • Radiation decouples • Plasma beta drops drastically

  9. T.R. T B 0 Height in corona

  10. Solar shock: Type II burst

  11. A Type II burst is the same thing as a “slow drift” burst - perhaps discovered by early military radars; explained by J. P. Wild and Y. Uchida (recall l-2 ~ ne) III Wavelength II Time

  12. Meter-waves and soft X-rays • Megahertz vs Exahertz • Radiative transfer vs direct view • Magnetic effects vs Bremsstrahlung • Inherent fuzziness vs sharp resolution • But - by 1998, we’d seen Types I, III, IV and others

  13. But not the simplest and most obvious: Type II!

  14. X-ray observation of a global wave • Wave propagation tells us about coronal structure • The innermost (earliest) motions tell us about the flare process itself

  15. Moreton-Ramsey wave and EIT wave

  16. Why didn’t SXT discover “SXT waves”? • SXT views the whole corona • Fast-mode MHD waves must involve compressional heating • SXT response increases monotonically with temperature • So… why did it take 8 years and the competitive example of EIT?

  17. Factors abetting wave detectionin soft X-rays • The wave needn’t be shocked • The SXT response strongly favors detection of a temperature increase (adiabatic law)

  18. Sensitivity estimation 2 R (n,T ) = const £ n £ S (T ), i e i e e @ ( l n ( R )) d ( l n ( S )) i i = ¢ ( T ) = 3 + , i e @ ( l n ( T )) d ( l n ( T )) e e

  19. SXT and TRACE responses Courtesy N. V. Nitta

  20. Factors reducing sensitivity • Poor CCD dynamic range (AEC) • Limited SXT telemetry(“Velocity filter”) • Photon counting statistics • Scattering from grazing-incidence mirror • Flare mode

  21. May 6, 1998 FOV 10 arc min

  22. FOV 5 arc min

  23. Gas pressure in flare loops

  24. SOHO/ EIT

  25. Uchida’s 1968 model

  26. A.R. Uchida S.W.

  27. OK, so what caused the wave? • In principle we can see it all in soft X-rays • The earliest manifestation of the wave is within 20,000 km of the flare core • But… it is significantly displaced from the soft X-ray core of the flare

  28. Mysteries of low b plasma • Everything seems to expand (cf. Aly) • The Virial Theorem looks goofy too

  29. Implosion conjecture • At low b, the coronal energy is purely B2/8p • During a flare, there’s no time for energy transport through the photosphere • Therefore, some field lines must shorten

  30. Open field lines Closed field lines Isomagnetobars How low-b implosions must work

  31. MHD Virial Theorem

  32. The end, thanks

  33. The end, thanks

More Related