370 likes | 508 Views
The recent Calice Collaboration meeting at LAPP highlighted significant progress in AHCAL (Analog Hadron Calorimeter) mass assembly. Key developments include the successful build and power-up tests of the AHCAL wing data aggregator, integration efforts, and initial firmware tests for Kintex FPGAs and Zynq processors. The need for automated placement systems is emphasized due to the extensive assembly requirements of approximately 8 million tiles on HBU boards, with innovative pick-and-place machines and vision systems being explored to enhance efficiency and precision.
E N D
MassAssembly 10.9.13 – CaliceCollaboration Meeting LAPP Annecy JGU Mainz - Phi Chau Bruno Bauss, Volker Büscher, Julien Caudron, Reinhold Degele, Karl Heinz Geib, Sascha Krause, Yong Liu, Lucia Masetti, Uli Schäfer, Rouven Spreckels, Stefan Tapprogge, Rainer Wanke
Wing LDA/CCC Status • AHCAL wing data aggregator has been built • Initial power-up tests successful • System integration started (André, Rouven,…), but further effort required • Firmware for Kintex FPGAs • Firmware / Software for Zynq processor (“MARS ZX3”) • VME-sized clock/control unit acting as MARS test bench • Issues in firmware load stage observed on engineering sample • Further effort required to debug on production silicon available now • For the time being cover all immediate needs (AHCAL LDA/CCC) with adapter modules on “Zedboard” • Clock/control adapters available • Data aggregator adapter ready for production • New batch of clock fan-out units in production • Julien working on software integration
Need for an automaticproduction • AHCAL (final design) • About 8.000.000 tileshavetobeplaced on HBU boards • With an effortof 10 s per tile ~ 8 yearsarenecessaryfortheassembling • Weneed an automaticplacement • With 1 second per placementweneed 1 year MassAssembly
Massproduction • DESY: Productionof HBU boards • ITEP: Productionofthetiles • Heidelberg University: Characterisationoftiles/SiPM • Wuppertal: LEDs • Mainz University: Placement ofthetiles on the HBU board, functionalitytestsoftheassembledboards MassAssembly
Automaticplacement • Pick-and-place machine • Cameradetectstiles/SiPMsandsuctioncupplacesthem on the HBU (SiPMpinsthroughthepinholes) • Vision systemdetectstilesandtheSiPMpinsqualityassurance • Problem: Reflectivesurfaceofthetiles • Pick-and-place maschineswith Vision systems workswithlight todetectthepins Pick-and-place machine MassAssembly
Cameratests • Wehaveproduceddummytilesforcameratestsatmachinemanufactors • 3 companieshaveconfirmed, thatvisionsystemcan handle thetiles MassAssembly
Current design • Mountingoftile on HBU board: • Tileshavetobeenpushedintothealignmentpinholes • Verysmalltolerancesareneededto fit • With 4 pins (2 SiPMpins, 2 allignmentpins), toleranceshavetobequitebig Original design: Alignmentpins HBU Pin (SiPM) SiPM Reflectorfoil Absorption layer MassAssembly
Modified design: Option 1 – Not wrappedtile • Mountingofmodifiedtile on HBU board: • Plane tileswithoutalignmentpins • Requires: Fixation ofthetilewithgluepointbetweentileandreflectorfoil • Just 2 pins(fromSiPM) tolerancesarelessdemanding Original design: Gluepoint HBU Pin (SiPM) SiPM Reflectorfoil Absorption layer MassAssembly
Modified design: Option 2 – wrappedtile (Uni Hamburg) • Mountingofmodifiedwrappedtileon HBU board: • Tileiswrappedwithreflectorfoilandflexpinconnector • Fixation ofthetilewithgluepointbetweenHBU andreflectorfoil Hamburg design: Gluepoint HBU Pin (SiPM) Withreflectorfoilwrappedtile SiPM Absorption layer MassAssembly
Automaticplacement • Screen printer • Sets gluepoints on thesurfaceofthe HBU • High adhesiveglueisneeded, becausewedon‘twantany time fordrying-out theglue • Silicone • Potential issue: DoesGluepointreduce light yield? Tests Pick-and-place machine Screen printer MassAssembly
Measurement Set-up • Measurement oftheinfluence on theopticalpropertieswithcosmics Amplifier Trigger scintillator MassAssembly
Measurement Set-up • Measurement oftheinfluence on theopticalpropertieswithcosmics Trigger scintillator Amplifier Tilebetweentwolayersofreflectorfoil SiPM MassAssembly
First measurement • The firstmeasurementsarefinished • 2 ITEP tileswith 2 Hamamatsu MPPC S10943-8584(X) aremeasuredwithcosmics • Unmodifiedwithoutgluepoints • Withoutallignmentpinswithgluepoints (allignmentpinsareremoved, << 1 ml siliconeisplacedon tile) Tileglued on reflectorfoil Gluepoints MassAssembly
First results MassAssembly
Result • Light yieldofthemodified design isbetterthan light yieldofcurrent design • Latertestscandeterminatetheconfigurationwiththebestopticalproperties. Wewanttotest different settingswith • Different glue • Glueshapes • Quantityofglue • Position oftheglue MassAssembly
Automaticplacement • Conveyor • Transports theboardsfrom Pick-and-place machinetosolderingmaschine • Problem: Board iscompletelyfilledwithtiles Transportation is not possible Pick-and-place machine Screen printer MassAssembly
5 mm Perforation • Solution: theexistingperforatedframeshouldstayuntilthewholeplacementprocessisfinished • After thatitcanberemoved Proposalformodificationsofmassproduction
Automaticplacement selectivesolderingwouldtake 3-8s per solderingposition (x144 solderingpositions per board) Wave solderingmachine • Fastest solderingtechnique Pick-and-place machine Wave solderingmachine Screen printer MassAssembly
Wave solderingmachine https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=inHzaJIE7-4 MassAssembly
Automaticplacement • Wave solderingmachine • Problem: Board isallreadyassembled Weneed a solderingmask Pick-and-place machine Wave solderingmachine Screen printer MassAssembly
Solderingmask Solderingpositions Protectivebagfor SMD components MassAssembly
Automaticplacement • Wave solderingmachine • Solderingprocessdefines (andlimits) the design ofthe HBU boardandthestructureoftheSiPMpins: • thediameteroftheSiPMpinsandboreholes • positionofcomponents • SiPMpin hole position Modificationsofthe HBU boardisneeded Pick-and-place machine Wave solderingmachine Screen printer MassAssembly
SiPMpin-, boreholediameterandshape • pinholesshouldbe 3 mm larger thanthepins • We also wantmaximally robust pins • Pins couldbepushedawayfromthesolder Pins with ~ 0,5 mm diameterare optimal • The pinlengthshouldbearound1 mm outside thehole 3 mm Pin Pin hole 1 mm MassAssembly
SiPMpin-, boreholediameterandshape • Recommended Area aroundtheSiPMholeswithoutany SMD components: 3 mm radius • Asymmetric Area aroundtheSiPMholeswithout SMD componentsarepossiblewith a minimumradiusof 1 mm and 3 mm on theotherside 3 mm Pin hole 1 mm Area without SMD components MassAssembly
Additional advice: • Components neartheSiPMconnectorsshouldbeplacedwiththeshortsidetotheholes • The componentsstayfixed on oneside, evenifone pad isheatedup • componentsnearthepinholescan‘tbesoldered out good bad
Bridge effect In thisorientation problematicforsomewavesolderingmachines 2 1 3 Soldering Wave pins Solderingbridge pinholes Withthisorientation, thebridgeeffectcanoccur The pinholesarefilledwithsolder The HBU boardistransportedfromrighttoleft (In thecoordinatesystemoftheboard Wave movedfromlefttoright) MassAssembly
Solderingdirection Forexample: atthisposition a rotationis not possible • Ideal conditions: Pin holeshavepreferreddirections • Newerwavesolderingmachinescan handle thiswithoutdesign changes • SolderingmaskcanberotatedEffectivesizeoftheboardin transportationdirectionisbigger (just withbigsolderingmachines)
Additional testsforsoldering • Temperaturetestsforeverycomponent (simulationofSolderingwave) • If HBU boardcouldbechange Create a solderingmaskandsolderingtests MassAssembly
SMD SiPMs • With SMD SiPMstheassemblingwouldbeeasier • Wewon‘tneed a solderingmachineandthe THT optimization • More s. nextpresentationfrom Yong Liu MassAssembly
Automaticplacement • Functionalitytests • Fullyassembled HBU testset-up (with LEDs on the Board) • Currentlysettingup AHCAL DAQ for fast testing Pick-and-place machine Wave solderingmachine Screen printer Functionalitytests MassAssembly
Conclusion • Procedurefor fast massassemblyhasbeendefined • Massassemblyrequiresnumerous design modifications • Initial testssucessful • Fullproductionline will besetup in Mainz fordemonstratingmassassemblywiththe large prototype MassAssembly
Reference labels • Finetuningadvice: More referencelabels on theperforatedframe (Mydata) • Existinglabelscan‘tberecognized after assembling • Reference labelsshouldbe on thesideofthetilesandtheyshouldbe on theframe MassAssembly
Tiles/SiPM • Mountingof Hamburg tileon HBU board: • Black surfaceofthewrappedtile opticalcapturewithcamerasiseasiertorealize Hamburg design: Gluepoint HBU Pin (SiPM) Withreflectorfoilwrappedtile SiPM PborFeabsorptionlayer MassAssembly
Tiles/SiPM • MountingofHamburg tileon HBU board: • Noteststillnowforwrappedsurface (testsofsuctioncupof pick-and-place machine) Hamburg design: Gluepoint HBU Pin (SiPM) Withreflectorfoilwrappedtile SiPM PborFeabsorptionlayer MassAssembly
SiPMpinshape • Round pinsare easy, rectangularpinsaremoredifficulttosolder ( distances in the hole aren‘tconstant) MassAssembly