1 / 40

Gender and Microfinance

Gender and Microfinance. Jonathan Morduch World Bank April 30 th , 2007. Outline. Reaching Women Why Women Evaluating Impact Beyond Credit Looking Forward. Reaching Women. 10.3 million in 1999  69 million in 2005 570% increase 84.2% of total clients.

Download Presentation

Gender and Microfinance

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Gender and Microfinance Jonathan Morduch World Bank April 30th, 2007

  2. Outline • Reaching Women • Why Women • Evaluating Impact • Beyond Credit • Looking Forward

  3. Reaching Women • 10.3 million in 1999  69 million in 2005 • 570% increase • 84.2% of total clients Source: Daley-Harris, Sam (2006). “State of the Microcredit Summit Campaign Report 2006”.

  4. Women Served Source: Daley-Harris, Sam (2006). “State of the Microcredit Summit Campaign Report 2006”.

  5. Why Women? • Women make up a large and growing segment of the informal-sector • Women tend to be more credit constrained • Commercial banks focus on men because men form a larger portion of the formal sector

  6. Source: The United Nations, 2000. The World’s Women 2000: Trends and Statistics. Chart 5.13, p. 122

  7. Financial Impact: Targeting women customers can improve repayment rates

  8. Financial Impact • Women are better customers • Higher repayment rates • Conservative in investment strategy – more risk averse • More vulnerable to peer pressure and threat of public humiliation • Less access to credit which reduces risk of moral hazard • Hossain (1988): 81% of women had no repayment problems versus 74% of men. • Khandker et al., (1995): 15.3 % of male borrowers were “struggling” in 1991 versus 1.4% of female (missing some payments before the final due date)

  9. Financial Impact • Women are better customers • Less mobile • Reduces monitoring costs – for bank as well as peer monitoring • Enables women to attend repayment meetings (if applicable) • Less argumentative • Lower staff costs • Institutions can hire more female staff

  10. Financial Impact: But institutions targeting women have tended to be less profitable as loan sizes remain relatively small

  11. Evaluating Financial Impact • As MFI’s scale, the % of women clients decrease • Small scale – 75.3% women borrowers • Medium scale – 64.5% women borrowers • Large scale – 55.2% women borrowers • For-Profit institutions tend to serve fewer women clients • Not for Profit – 71.9% women borrowers • For Profit – 54.5% women borrowers

  12. Source: MicroBanking Bulletin, Issue No. 12, April 2006

  13. Development Impact: Targeting women has a greater impact on social and economic development

  14. Development Impact • Women are poorer • UNDP Human Development Report (1996): 70% of the world’s poor, about 900 million women • Women spend on household consumption as opposed to personal consumption • Pitt and Khandker (1998): Empirical studies have shown that women are more likely than men to direct additional income to household consumption • Working women contribute to economic growth

  15. Empowerment Impact • Increases women’s decision-making power • Pitt et al., (2006): Women’s participation in credit programs leads to women having greater role in household decisions, social networks, and greater freedom of mobility. Increase spousal communication about family planning and parenting concerns. • Improvement in domestic interactions • Third party scrutiny of household abuse • Intervention with Microfinance for AIDS and Gender Equity (IMAGE) study demonstrated reductions in levels of intimate-partner violence in participants.

  16. Empowering Women with Micro Finance: Evidence from Bangladesh- Mark Pitt, Shahidur Khandker, Jennifer Cartwright • Study estimates the impact of participation in micro credit program on an index of empowerment • Uses data from household survey from 1998-99 • Uses qualitative, self-reported responses to questions around women autonomy and gender relations in household

  17. Study Design • Original 1991-92 survey • 1,789 households -1,538 target (59% participated in program) and 260 nontarget • 40 program villages • 22 female-only groups • 10 male-only groups • 1998-99 follow-up empowerment survey • 2,074 households with married couples • 80% of question were asked only to wives

  18. Study Design • 10 Empowerment Factors • Purchasing • Resource • Finance • Transaction Management • Mobility and Networks • Activism • Household Attitudes • Husband’s Bahavior • Fertility and Parenting • All Variables

  19. Study Results • Female credit produces statistically significant improvements in – • Autonomy with purchasing households assets • Access to and control over economic resources • Ability to raise emergency funds • Role in deciding and implementing household borrowing • Power to oversee and conduct major household economic transactions • Mobility and networking • Awareness and activism • Discussions around family planning and parenting

  20. Study Results • Female credit does not increase husband’s opinions and actions • Male credit effects on women’s empowerments were largely negative – specifically on women’s control of resources, finance, freedom of movement and fertility and parenting decisions

  21. Tying Odysseus to the Mast: Evidence from a Commitment Savings Product in the Philippines- Dean S. Karlan, Nava Ashraf, Wesley Yin • “…but you must bind me hard and fast, so that I cannot stir from the spot where you will stand me… and if I beg you to release me, you must tighten and add to my bonds.” -- The Odyssey

  22. Overview • Developed new “commitment” savings product for Philippine small, semi-rural, for-profit bank • Randomized control evaluation design • Developed survey methodology to identify “hyperbolic” individuals using hypothetical time preference questions • Developed follow-up survey to measure impact on female decision-making power and household outcomes • Sample frame: poor but “banked” (prior clients) of the bank

  23. SEED:A Commitment Savings Product • Withdrawal restriction • Either time-based (140) or amount-based (62) • Decided entirely by client • Deposit incentive • Ganansiya box – 167 out of 202 tookup  • Automatic transfer – 2 tookup  • Same interest rate as regular savings account • Hence, loss of liquidity is uncompensated • Note: Given combination of account features, not possible establish causal link of any one feature to impact • Note: Features could work for self-control OR spousal-control reasons

  24. The Commitment Savings Product

  25. Randomized Experimental Design

  26. Measuring Impact

  27. Magnitude in Real Dollars • Doctor’s visit: 150 pesos • Public school fees are 150 pesos/year, plus ~200 pesos/month for special projects • 1 month supply of rice for a family of 5: 1000 pesos

  28. Follow-Up Survey: Female Empowerment • Conducted one-year after experiment date • Nine decision categories such as family planning, financial and consumption decisions • Record whether principle decision-maker is respondents, the spouse or both for each category • Reponses assigned values of two, zero and one respectively

  29. Measuring Impact: Self-Reporting • Constructed two decision making indices • Equally-weighted mean of each response - 0.14 standard deviation increase for treatment group • Linear combination of individual responses to each question – 0.25 standard deviation increase for treatment group • Average effect is largely driven by increase in decision-making ability for women below the median (initially less empowered)

  30. Measuring Impact: Observing Purchases • Three categories for expenditures • House Repair, Female-oriented Durables (washing machine, kitchen appliances etc), Other Durables • Women below median • Increase in items purchased and total expenditures of consumer durables associated with female use • No increase in other non-female specific durables • Indicates that women were able to use their power in households to purchase goods that were beneficial to them • Women above median • Increase in items purchased is smaller and not statistically significant

  31. Study Results • Average savings increases by 85% for those who took-up • Average savings increases by 24% for those who were offered • ~34% of SEED clients actively using the account • Female empowerment through increase in female decision-making power • Increase in self-reporting by women • Increase in women oriented durable purchases

  32. Evaluating Finance, Development and Empowerment Impact: Critical Perspectives

  33. Evaluating Development Impact • Women do not control all loans • Goetz and Sen Gupta (1996): 40% of women have little or no control over their loans • Difficulty in scaling businesses due to limited resources (including skills and experience) • Difficulty in scaling businesses due to greater risk and debt aversion

  34. Evaluating Development Impact • Income generation responsibility may lead to heavier workload and more stress • Mayoux (1999): Lack of substitute care for children and elderly leads to added pressure

  35. Evaluating Empowerment Impact • Pressure to pay back loans can lead to domestic pressure and violence • Contrary to the IMAGE study, per Rahman’s study 70% of women expressed increase in violence (based on one village) • Limited empowerment outside the household • Mayoux (1999): Less evidence of socio-political empowerment due to presence of inflexible social norms and traditions

  36. Evaluating Empowerment Impact • Unclear evidence on endogeneity of empowerment and microfinance • Are women involved in microfinance already empowered?

  37. Beyond Credit: Toward cost-effective ways to enhance development and empowerment impact on women

  38. Beyond Credit • Johnson (2000): Mainstreaming and institutionalizing gender • Incorporate gender issues in normal service delivery • Equality of women’s access to services and mechanisms • Require asset registration in woman’s name • Equal employment opportunity for women as staff • Products and programs that respond to women’s needs and demand • Commitment Savings Product • Karlan et al., (2006): Access to commitment savings product in Philippines had positive impact on female decision-making power within household

  39. Beyond Credit • Education and consciousness-raising programs • Pro Mujer - Health Education • BRAC Bangladesh – Integrated Training • Support collective group learning for both men and women • RADAR IMAGE Collaboration in South Africa

More Related