1 / 15

Are “In-the-box data centers” Out-of-the-box Thinking?

Are “In-the-box data centers” Out-of-the-box Thinking?. A summary of a GSA/LBNL white paper discussing the energy efficiency and deployment attributes of container data centers. Mark Bramfitt, P.E. www.markbramfitt.com. Why Containers?.

charo
Download Presentation

Are “In-the-box data centers” Out-of-the-box Thinking?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Are “In-the-box data centers” Out-of-the-box Thinking? A summary of a GSA/LBNL white paper discussing the energy efficiency and deployment attributes of container data centers. Mark Bramfitt, P.E. www.markbramfitt.com

  2. Why Containers? • Modular data centers, often in standard shipping container form factors, are being marketed by a host of vendors • They are notably being deployed by “utility scale” data center operators • The “sell”: energy efficiency and rapid deployment, and a solution to capacity shortfalls

  3. Why GSA Interest • Many (most?, all?) federal agencies are being solicited • Many federal agencies are doing the solicitation! • GSA response was to commission Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory to produce report: Modular/Container Data Centers Selection Guide: Optimizing for Energy Efficiency and Quick Deployment

  4. Modular Data Centers: Topologies HP's POD Unit Featuring a Single Row of IT Rack Space. Cooling Design Uses Overhead Water-Cooled Coils SGI Ice Cube Air Modular Data Center Featuring Air-Side Economizer Cooling Oracle Sun Modular Data Center, Featuring a Unique IT Rack Layout

  5. Energy Efficiency Attributes • All solutions offer the advantages of full airflow containment and close-coupled cooling • “First Generation” units require chilled water supply, or use on-board DX • Use of water-side economizer can dramatically improve efficiency • “Second Generation” units feature air-side economizer, supplemented as needed by direct evaporative or other cooling system

  6. Not Another Efficiency Metric! Energy Efficiency Analysis PUE* = (total power supplied to the module + power to produce externally acquired chilled fluid) / IT power

  7. For The Purposes of Comparison… • We used a highly-efficient chilled water plant, meeting California energy codes for new construction: • 0.7 kW per ton • Water-side economizer • Modeled with San Jose, CA climate conditions • (These assumptions give an edge to “first gen” units compared to “second gen”, with climate conditions favorable to both) • Note that power delivery and conditioning are excluded

  8. A Peek at the Results

  9. Efficiency Comparison in Summary Modular Data Center Thermal Analysis Results

  10. Upshot On Efficiency • Even the poorest-performing units (DX) are pretty good compared to typical enterprise DCs • With the right chiller plant (high eff. & water-side econ), “first generation” plants can deliver very good efficiency performance • “Second generation” units squeeze out every bit of efficiency advantage in the cooling category

  11. And Now a Word from LBNL… • Worried about outside air? Particulate? Humidity and corrosion? • Check out LBNL reports: • “Air-Side Economizer Cooling Is Safe for Most California Data Centers” • “Air Corrosivity in U.S. Outdoor-Air-Cooled Data Centers is Similar to That in Conventional Data Centers” • “Particle concentrations in data centers” • Visit: http://hightech.lbl.gov/library.html#Publications

  12. What of Deployment? • Most vendors claim six-to-eight week delivery schedules! • Your deployment pain-point will therefore be on-site support infrastructure: • If you don’t have power capacity, it will likely take six-to-eight months, at best, to secure • How long does it take to get back-up generators? Other distribution equipment? • Built a chiller plant lately? • This pain likely holds true for individual installations as much or more so than for utility-scale deployment

  13. “Second Gen” has Dual Advantages Brick and Mortar vs. Containers

  14. Conclusions • Container data centers have inherent efficiency attributes • Deployment may be quicker, but pain points remain • Capex comparison remains elusive • “Second generation” units have highest efficiency, and lower deployment costs due to a reduced need for support infrastructure

  15. Presentation posted at www.markbramfitt.com

More Related