1 / 43

Economic and Investment Outlook CIA Conference, Toronto September 2009 Warren A. Thomson

Economic and Investment Outlook CIA Conference, Toronto September 2009 Warren A. Thomson SEVP & Chief Investment Officer. Overview. Economic Indicators Canadian Equities Canadian Fixed Income Alternative Assets Commercial Real Estate Oil & Gas Timber Agriculture. Economic Indicators.

caelan
Download Presentation

Economic and Investment Outlook CIA Conference, Toronto September 2009 Warren A. Thomson

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Economic and Investment Outlook CIA Conference, Toronto September 2009 Warren A. Thomson SEVP & Chief Investment Officer

  2. Overview • Economic Indicators • Canadian Equities • Canadian Fixed Income • Alternative Assets • Commercial Real Estate • Oil & Gas • Timber • Agriculture

  3. Economic Indicators

  4. Is The Recession Over? • Signs of growth in China, Europe and Japan in Q2 2009 • The US: • Growth may be resuming as we speak (Q3 2009) • Worst downturn since WWII – even a partial rebound could deliver startling % growth rates • GDP: 2.5% loss vs. 3% trend growth implies at least 5.5% below potential now

  5. The Worst Seems To Be Behind UsHome Sales Finding A Bottom

  6. Initial Unemployment Claims Turn The Corner

  7. Retail Inventories Still Excessive, But Getting Less So

  8. ISM Indexes Still Below 50, But Past The Worst

  9. Canada: Basically Sound, But Tied To The US • Negatives: in a bad neighborhood • Too integrated with the US to avoid tracking US cycle • Spillovers from the demise of Detroit, particularly in Ontario • Positives: living within one’s means • Commodities will bounce back with global growth • Closer than other countries to sustainable budget and trade balances • Systemically important financial institutions are sound • Bottom line: less trauma than elsewhere • Slightly healthier GDP growth than the US • Employment probably not rebounding until 2010 • Strengthening CAD may limit manufacturing competitiveness

  10. Canadian Economy Improving ) June 2009

  11. Household Debt Levels Resulting in Paradox of Thrift Canada Personal Savings ( ) and Household Debt ( ) ) ) As Percent of Disposable Income 25 130 128.6 120 20 110 100 15 90 80 10 70 60 5 4.5 50 0 40 1960 1965 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 Consumer credit plus mortgage debt Q239 2009:2

  12. MFC GIM’s Forecast Source: MFC Global Investment Management, as at August 24, 2009

  13. Canadian Equities

  14. Commodity Prices Recovering September 2009 2008 2009

  15. Equity Valuations are Reasonable September 2009 50-yr Average

  16. S&P/TSX Earnings Near Trough August 2009

  17. Earnings Yield Still Above Government Bond Yields ) ) September 2009

  18. S&P/TSX Bear Markets – 1957 to 2009 Source: CPMS/ Bloomberg

  19. Summary • The worst is likely behind us from an equity market perspective • Markets are supported by: • A resumption of global growth • Commodity price recovery • Earnings recovery • Attractive valuations

  20. Canadian Fixed Income

  21. Short Term Rates at Record Lows Canadian Government Yield Curves Pre-Crisis (June 30, 2007) Post-Crisis (September 9, 2009) Source: Bloomberg

  22. Spread Between LIBOR and T-Bills has Returned to More Normal Levels US Interest Rates – September 17, 2004 to September 9, 2009 Lehman failure Beginning of crisis 3 month US LIBOR 3 month US T-Bill Source: Bloomberg

  23. Strong Corporate Bond Returns as of August 31, 2009 Canadian Bond Total Rates of Return Mid Crisis December 31, 2008 (0.3%) Post Crisis August 31, 2009 Source: PC Bond Analytics, TSX

  24. Corporate Spread Compression Continues Canadian Investment Grade Corporate Spreads US High Yield Spreads Source: PC-Bond Analytics, Merrill Lynch, June 30, 2009

  25. Canadian Bonds Are Expected to Perform Well Going Forward • Interest rates should increase modestly over time • Corporate spreads may tighten further • Modest improvement over time in line with economic conditions • Corporate bond class should continue to outperform, but relative performance will moderate

  26. Alternative Assets:Prospects and Challenges

  27. Commercial Real Estate

  28. US Market Is Stressed • Most property types and regions experiencing difficulty from increased vacancy and tight credit markets • Office market has settled into a stable but soft cycle • Duration tied to the start of job creation • Erosion of operating income and valuations is increasing pressure on owners struggling to refinance their loans • Upcoming loan maturities and lower values necessitate new equity • Excessive use of leverage (debt) is the core problem

  29. Canadian Market A Relatively Strong Performer • Market remains relatively healthy compared to rest of the world • Foreign buyers showing interest in acquiring institutional-grade commercial real estate • Concentrated institutional ownership of large properties reduces the likelihood of trades and value declines (due in part to reduced use of leverage) • Pockets of weakness remain contained

  30. Asian MarketOutlook Uncertain • Asia has benefited from financial easing during the first half of 2009 • Lower rental rates have resulted from weak space demand and threat of rising vacancy rates • Continued high acquisition activity expected • Property fundamentals remain uncertain into 2010 • Risks are lower due to decreased use of leverage relative to rest of world

  31. Oil & Gas

  32. Oil Price Stability Expected to Resume in 2010 • Short term oil prices likely to remain volatile • Bloated inventory levels • Tighter oil supply than at start of the year • Some signs of global economic improvement • Oil price stability should replace volatility in 2010 • Global economic recovery signs begin to take hold • No suitable substitute for transportation fuel Source: FirstEnergy Capital, World Crude Oil Markets, August 27, 2009

  33. Natural Gas Price Outlook Remains Weak • Short Term – Natural gas currently challenged by: • High inventories • Weak industrial demand • Growing US domestic production • Long Term – Few catalysts for a rebound in prices • Inventory continues to build • Increasing unconventional supply may insulate price spikes • Weak natural gas prices are a stimulus to the broader economy Source: BMO Capital Markets, Monthly Commodity Watch, August 2009; IHS CERA – Monthly Briefing “North American Natural Gas”, August 2009

  34. Timber

  35. Timber Markets in a Deep Cyclical Trough US Housing Starts and US Lumber Consumption Source: Resource Information Systems, Inc. (RISI)

  36. Demand For Pulp Has Also Declined GlobalPulpwood Demand and Pricing Source: Wood Resources International and Hawkins Wright Ltd.

  37. Timberland Values Are Stressed Operating Cash and Value for Prototypical All Age US Timberland Property (nominal $ per acre) Sources: NCRIEF and HTRG Research. Methodology detailed in “Explaining Timberland Values in the United States,” Journal of Forestry, December 2004.

  38. Agriculture

  39. Farmland Market Fundamentals • US farmland values are expected to moderate in near-term and grow in long-term driven by: • Strong US net farm income • Healthy balance sheet fundamentals • Continued strength in the agricultural export markets

  40. Long-Term Upward Trend in Farmland Value Average Value per Acre of US Farmland, 1940–2008 US Aggregate Net Farm Income (billions), 1940–2018F Source: USDA Economic Research Service. Actual numbers through 2008, forecast through 2018

  41. Strong Financials and Balance Sheets For the US Farm Sector US Farm Sector Balance Sheet, 1970-2008 US Farm Sector Debt Ratios 1970-2008 Source: USDA Economic Research Service 1970-2008

  42. Summary • Canada remains sound, but tied to the US • Commodity prices are recovering and equity valuations are reasonable • Short term rates at record lows, with interest rates expected to rise modestly over time • The worst may be behind us, but it is still too soon to declare that the recession is over

  43. Questions & Answers

More Related