1 / 18

The Public Pension Crisis

The Public Pension Crisis. Josh Rauh Kellogg School of Management October 2011. A State and Local Fiscal Crisis in the US?. Pensions represent large off-balance-sheet debts for state and local governments Government accounting standards board (GASB) procedures understate liabilities

boone
Download Presentation

The Public Pension Crisis

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. The Public Pension Crisis Josh Rauh Kellogg School of Management October 2011

  2. A State and Local Fiscal Crisis in the US? • Pensions represent large off-balance-sheet debts for state and local governments • Government accounting standards board (GASB) procedures understate liabilities • Allowing circumvention of balanced budget requirements • Threatens solvency of many state and local governmental entities

  3. Outline of Questions • What are the cash flows that have been and are being promised? • What is the present value of these promises? • GASB accounting for liabilities: $3.8 trillion • Assets are around $2.7 trillion • Suggests ~$1 trillion gap… is this right? • What would be the impact of different policy reforms?

  4. 1. What are the Cash Flows? • For each entity, starting point should be annual cash benefit outflow • Unfortunately not disclosed • Plans only disclose a (present value) liability and the discount rate they used • Actuarial reports contain demographic data and detailed description of plan rules • With much work, can approximately reverse engineer cash flows

  5. Benefit Payments: 50 States $ billion (nominal) Our model ensures that discounting this stream at state-chosen rates (usually 8%) yields stated liability and first-year benefit flow Source: Novy-Marx, Robert and Joshua Rauh, 2011, “Public Pension Liabilities: How Big Are They and What Are They Worth,” Journal of Finance, forthcoming. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1352608.

  6. Benefit Payments: 77 Cities and Counties $ billion (nominal) Our model ensures that discounting this stream at state-chosen rates (usually 8%) yields stated liability and first-year benefit flow Source: Novy-Marx, Robert and Joshua Rauh, 2011, “The Crisis in Local Government Pensions in the United States,” in Growing Old: Paying for Retirement and Institutional Money Management after the Financial Crisis, Robert Litan and Richard Herring, eds., Brookings Institution. http://www.kellogg.northwestern.edu/faculty/rauh/research/NMRLocal20101011.pdf

  7. 2. The Financial Value of Liabilities • Need to discount these payouts, translate into a present value number • What do the plans themselves use? • GASB: long-term average expected return of plan assets is used as discount rate • Most plans aim for 8% • Major GA state plans use 7.5%, low end of spectrum • Is this a logical approach?

  8. Is GASB Approach Appropriate? • Actuaries say… • Yes! • With long horizons stocks have high average returns • Asset income will (may) pay for lots of benefits • Economists say… • No! • Need to discount liabilities accounting for the nature of the liabilities (not the asset) • A dollar of stock is worth same as a dollar of bonds • Whom should you believe?

  9. Example #1: Why Expected Return is Wrong • Consider the following example • You have promised to make a lump-sum payment of $100,000, due 10 years from now • That is your only debt • You have $35,000 in cash and no other assets • You want to take out a loan from a bank • Bank will assess your net worth • Suppose you move the $35,000 from cash into stocks. Does that change your net worth? • Common sense: No • GASB Implication: You can discount your debts at an (11%) expected equity return  no debt, since $35,000 will grow in 10 years to repay $100,000

  10. Example #2: Two Identical Workers • To each, you have promised a lump sum of $200,000 in 30 years • Plan A set up for Worker #1 Liabilities: $200,000 in 30 years Assets: $10,000 invested in stock market • Plan B set up for Worker #2 Liabilities: $200,000 in 30 years Assets: $10,000 invested in stock market PLUS $10,000 in bonds • Question: Which plan is better funded?

  11. GASB’s Answer • According to GASB • Suppose stock targeted return = 11%, bonds = 3% • Plan A PV of liability = $200,000 / (1.11)30 = $8,737Net position is $10,000 - $8,737 = $1,263 [surplus] • Plan B PV of liability = $200,000 / (1.07)30 = $26,273Net position is $20,000 - $26,273 = -$6,273 [deficit] • Plan A is better funded! • Absolutely defies all common sense • Identical liabilities • Identical stock holdings • Plan with additional assets is “less funded” • So how underfunded are the plans really?

  12. Appropriate Discount Rates • Focus on already-promised benefits (ABO) • Consider liability from taxpayer perspective • Right discount rate depends on assumptions about default and recovery • If assuming that benefits are default-free, need a default-free discount rate • Only justification for higher rate is if states are to be credited for option to default

  13. ABO Liabilities in 2009 were ~$3T • Taking state accounting as given as of June 2009 • $1.0T unfunded at state level + $0.3T unfunded local = $1.3T unfunded in total • Using Treasury yield curve on ABO as of June 2009 • $2.5T unfunded at state level + $0.6T unfunded local = $3.1T unfunded in total • As of October 2011 it is even larger • Assets: up by around 15%, adds around $0.4 trillion • Stated liabilities grew at 5.5% per year from 2007-2009… at that rate would fully offset asset growth • Some policy changes since then, but only a few have affected current employees or retirees • Yield curves lower  liabilities higher

  14. Zero Coupon Treasury Yield Curves 10/11/2011 30yr 10/11/2011 10yr 10/11/2011 5yr Bottom line: Unfunded ABO liability as of Oct-2011 likely over $4 trillion.

  15. Georgia’s Liabilities: Current Workers * Also includes subsidiary plans of the Employees’ Retirement System of Georgia: ERS, PSERS, GJRS, LRS, and MGPF. ** Estimate for all systems within Georgia in the U.S. Census of State and Local Government Retirement Systems: GA ERS (and subsidiaries), GA TRS, GA Firemen, GA Peace Officers, DeKalb County, Fulton County, Atlanta General, Atlanta Police, Atlanta Fire, Columbus ERS, Savannah, Chatham, Albany ERS plus 9 smaller municipal systems.

  16. 3. Policy Options • Most policy changes that have been put in place have hardly dented the unfunded liabilities • If GASB rules are in place, new DB promises continue to be underfunded, debt grows • Even if extent of new benefit promises is less than it was before • True service cost with a benefit factor of 2% of pay is typically around 28-30% of pay, double what is typically recognized • Georgia: fewer unfunded liabilities for new workers under 2009 reform (DC + reduced DB), but still have only slowed growth of debt

  17. List of Possible Measures • Employee contribution increases • Make early retirement actuarially fair • Retirement age increases • Cost of living adjustment reductions • Tax increases or spending cuts to devote more resources to pensions • Soft freeze (or partial soft-freeze) • Hard freeze None of these is politically easy

  18. Conclusions • Absolutely no basis for expected return discounting • Bad question: “what is a reasonable return to expect?” • Good question: “since pension cash flows are like a bond, how should they be valued?” • No easy solutions to large pension debts • Only two ways to stop the borrowing • rewrite GASB, start paying PV of new benefits; OR • stop promising new DB benefits through (hard) freeze

More Related