THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS

1. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS Wm Gawthrop william.gawthrop@us.army.mil The views expressed in this presentation are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of any entity of the United States Government. This briefing may (may) be further disseminated.

2. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • 9/11 Attacks on World Trade Center and Pentagon • Initiated multiple law enforcement and intelligence investigations • Evidence accumulated that Subjects, victims, witnesses, translators and even investigators themselves were struggling with the competing demands of the sharia and the protocols of a criminal investigation.

3. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • The Sharia • intertwined with the early history of Islam • Meccan Period • Medina Period

4. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • The Sharia • Meccan Period • Believers threatened, assaulted • Developed defensive social doctrines • These doctrines gained scholarly acceptance and became precedence codified in Islamic law

5. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • The Sharia • Meccan Period • Mohammad prescribed • moral and ethical mandates • discouraged confrontation and • advocated polite disassociation to reduce adversarial confrontations

6. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • The Sharia • Medina Period • After the Hirja or flight to Medina • Muhammad gave practical guidance for the resolution of conflicts by encouraging Muslims to carefully gauge contact with Non Muslims to protect against hostile and subversive forces

7. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • The Sharia • Medina Period • Applicable Suras include 3:28 9:29 4:139 60:1 4:144 60:2 5: 57 60:3 9:23 60:13

8. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • The central themes with secular law enforcement implications are: • do not take disbelievers as protectors, helpers or friends (Sura 3:28) (4:144) (5:57) (60-1) (60:3) (60:13) • those who do take disbelievers as protectors, helpers or friends are untrustworthy (4:139) • avoid family members who take disbelievers as protectors, helpers or friends (9:23) • fight disbelievers (9:29) • If disbelievers gain the upper hand over you they will behave as enemies and stretch forth their hands and tongues against you with evil to induce disbelief. (60:2)

9. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Mohammad: • Sought to foster forbearance and tolerance among the faithful and mandated the reduction or elimination of undue social inquisitiveness about private matters. • gave clear guidance on issues of propriety, appropriate and inappropriate social inquiry, preservation of confidences and secrets, prohibitions on slander, and the exigencies of dissimulation

10. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • These prescriptions can be found in • the Koran, • traditional accounts of Mohammad’s life (the Sira), • the example of Mohammad (the Sunna) and • the traditions associated with his sayings (the Haddiths). • The Koran, the Sunna, and the Haddiths are foundational to Islamic Law.

11. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Islamic Law (The sharia). • Four major Sunni Schools • Hanafi • Hanbali • Maliki • Shafi

12. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Islamic Law (The sharia). • Codified in fiqh manuals • Identify behaviors • obligatory (wajib) • recommended (mandub) • permissible (mubah) • prohibited (haram) • repugnant (makrub)

13. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Islamic Law (The sharia). • Codified in fiqh manuals • Riyad-us-Saliheen, • The Distinguished Jurists Primer • The Book of Revenue • Al-Masqasid: Nawawi’s Manual of Islam • Umdat al salik (Reliance of the Traveller)

14. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Reliance of the Traveller

15. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Reliance of the Traveller • Al Azhar University: founded in Cairo, Egypt, in 971 AD, is the world’s oldest university and Islam’s center of excellence. • On 11 February 1991, the General Director of Research, Writing and Translation of Al Azhar University, fath Allah Ya Sin Jazar, certified: “that the above mentioned (English) translation (of the book Umdat al-salik wa ‘uddat al nasik by Amhad ibn Naqi) corresponds to the Arabic original and conforms to the practice and faith of the orthodox Sunni Community (Ahl al-Sunna wa al-Jama’a).”

16. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Reliance of the Traveller • 18 December 1990, Dr Taha Jabir al-Alwani, President of the International Institute of Islamic Thought, (Herndon, Virginia) and President of the Fiqh Council of North America: • the translation is a valuable and important work, whether as a text book for teaching Islamic jurisprudence to English speakers, or as a legal reference for use by scholars, educated laymen and students in this language; • the translation presents the legal questions in a faithful and precise idiom that clearly delivers the complete meaning in a sound English style;

17. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Reliance of the Traveller • Dr Taha Jabir al-Alwani, continued: • the book will be of great use in Southeast Asia in particular, and in America, Britain and Canada; • from a purely academic point of vie, this translation is superior to anything produced by orientalists in the way of translations of major Islamic works in that while faithfully maintaining the required scholarly level, its aim is to imbue the consciousness of the non Arabic speaking Muslim with a sound understanding of Sacred Law…”

18. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Reliance of the Traveller • Relevant Chapter: • Holding One’s Tongue • Comprised of 40 sections, • Eleven (11) sections are relevant to Law Enforcement and Intelligence

19. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Reliance of the Traveller • Holding One’s Tongue • Slander • Two People Conversing So That A Third Cannot Hear, • Informing on Another • Lying • Giving a Positive Interpretation to Another's Seeming Mistakes • Giving a Misleading Impression • Picking Apart a Brother’s Words • Asking About Another’s Mistakes • Searching Out a Persons Faults • Rejecting a Brother’s Excuse, and • Revealing a Secret

20. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Slander • "Slander means to mention anything concerning a person that he would dislike, whether about his body, religion, everyday life, self, disposition, property, son, father, wife, servant, turban, garment, gait, movements, smiling, dissolution, frowning, cheerfulness, or anything else connected with him." al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller, p. 730.

21. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Slander • “Do you know what slander is?” They answered, “Allah and His Messenger know best.” He said, “It is to mention of your brother that which he would dislike.” Someone asked, “What if he is as I say?” And he replied, “If he is as you say, you have slandered him, and if not, you have calumniated him.” al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller, p. 732.

22. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Slander • “The Muslim is the brother of the Muslim. He does not betray him, lie to him, or hang back from coming to his aid. All of the Muslim is inviolable to his fellow Muslim: his reputation, his property, his blood. Godfearingness is here (the heart). It is sufficiently wicked for someone to belittle his fellow Muslim.” al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller, p. 732.

23. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Two People Conversing So That A Third Cannot Hear • “When there are only three of you, two of you may not speak together apart from the third unless you join a group of others, lest your doing so sadden him.” • “The prohibition indicates its unlawfulness, it being impermissible for a group to converse apart from a single individual unless he gives his permission.” al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller, p. 743,

24. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Informing on Another • The Prophet … said, “Let none of my Companions inform me of anything another of them has said, for I wish to come to you without disquiet in my heart.” al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller, p. 742

25. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Lying • In general, it is unlawful to lie • it is among the ugliest sins and most disgusting faults • Exceptions, however, do exist al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller,p. 744.

26. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Exceptions • ‘He who settles disagreements between people to bring about good or says something commendable is a not a liar.’ al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller,p. 744.

27. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Exceptions • Abu Hamid Ghazali (1058-1111) • "If a praiseworthy aim is attainable by lying but not telling the truth, it is permissible to lie if attaining the goal is permissible.” • “It is obligatory to lie if the goal is obligatory.” • “When, for example, one is concealing a Muslim from an oppressor who asks where he is, it is obligatory to lie about him being hidden.”

28. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Exceptions • Abu Hamid Ghazali (1058-1111) • Or when a person deposits an article with one for safekeeping and an oppressor wanting to appropriate it inquires about it, it is obligatory to lie about having concealed it, for if one informs him about the article and he then seizes it, one is financially liable (to the owner) to cover the article’s cost.

29. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Exceptions • Abu Hamid Ghazali (1058-1111) • Whether the purpose is war, settling a disagreement, or gaining sympathy of a victim legally entitled to retaliate against one so that he will forbear to do so; it is not unlawful to lie when any of these aims can be obtained through lying.

30. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Exceptions • Abu Hamid Ghazali (1058-1111) • “But, it is religiously more precautionary in all cases to employ words that give a misleading impression, meaning to intend by one’s words something that is literally true, in respect to which one is not lying, while the outward purport of the words deceives the hearer, though even if one does not have such an intention and merely lies without intending anything else, it is not unlawful in the above circumstances.”

31. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Exceptions • Abu Hamid Ghazali (1058-1111) • "Lying is permissible when there is a legitimate desired end.“ • "The legitimate desired end may be a personal one.“ al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller, p. 746

32. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Exceptions • Abu Hamid Ghazali (1058-1111) • "When an oppressor intending to appropriate one’s property inquires about it, one may deny it. • Or, if a ruler asks one about a wicked act one has committed that is solely between one’s self and Allah (e.g. does not concern the rights of another) one can disclaim it…. • There are many well known hadiths in which those who admitted they deserved punishment were given prompting (by Mohammed) to retract their confessions.…

33. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Exceptions • Abu Hamid Ghazali (1058-1111) • One should compare the bad consequences entailed by lying to those by telling the truth, and if the consequences of telling the truth are more damaging, one is entitled to lie though if the reverse is true or if one does not know which entails more damage, then lying is unlawful. • Whenever lying is permissible, if the factor which permits it is a desired end of one’s own, it is recommended not to lie, but when the fact that permits it is the desired end of another, it is not lawful to infringe on his rights. • Strictness opposed to the above dispensations is to forgo lying in every case where it is not legally obligatory.”

34. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Lying • In general, it is unlawful to lie • it being among the ugliest sins and most disgusting faults. • Exceptions, however, do exist • Because of the scholarly consensus of the Community (Umma) that it is prohibited and the unanimity and amount of the primary textual evidence, there is little need to cite particular examples thereof, our only concern here being to explain the exceptions to what is considered lying, and appraise of the details.”[1][1] al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller,p. 744.

35. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Giving a Positive Interpretation to Another's Seeming Mistakes • Nawawi opined that with regard to the responses of students to their teachers, “it is obligatory for a student to give a positive interpretation to every utterance of his brothers that seems to be wrong until he has exhausted seventy excuses. No one is incapable of this except a failure.” al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller, p. 757

36. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Giving a Misleading Impression • “Giving a misleading impression is among the most important topics, being frequently met with and often abused. It befits us to examine the matter closely, and whoever learns of it should reflect upon it and apply it.” • “Giving a misleading impression means to utter an expression that ostensibly means to utter an expression that ostensibly implies one meaning while intending a different meaning the expression may also have, one that contradicts the ostensive purport. It is a kind of deception.” al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller,p. 759

37. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Giving a Misleading Impression • “It often takes the form of the speaker intending a specific referent while the hearer understands a more general one, as when a person asks a householder, • “Is So and so here?” to which the householder, intending the space between himself and the questioner rather than the space inside the house, replies, “He is not here.” • “Scholars say that there is no harm in giving a misleading impression if required by an interest countenanced by Sacred Law that is more important than not misleading the person being addressed, or if there is a pressing need which could not otherwise be fulfilled except through lying.” al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller,p. 758-9

38. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Picking Apart a Brother’s Words • “Picking apart another’s words consists of attacking another’s speech by revealing the mistakes in it, whether its weak Arabic, meaning, or the intention of the speaker, as when one says, “this is true, but you do not intend the truth by it, when such an attack involves no other motive than contempt for the other and displaying ones cleverness, it is unlawful.” al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller,p. 756

39. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Picking Apart a Brother’s Words • When one “hears something true, it befits him to accept it. If it is not true, but is unconnected with religious matters, he should remain silent, though if connected with religious matters, he is obliged to show that it is false and to condemn it if there is a chance that anyone will believe him, because this is forbidding the wrong.” al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller,p. 756

40. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Asking About Another’s Mistakes • “It is forbidden to ask about another’s errors and blunders in order to tell them they have made a mistake or to embarrass them, being unlawful because it entails injury to another and belittling him in front of people.” • “But when one’s asking about mistakes is to learn or teach, or to test or sharpen student’s minds or make them reflect, then it is recommended and desirable, because it facilitates the comprehension of religious knowledge.” al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller, p. 759

41. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Asking About Another’s Mistakes • Asking about and searching out the faults of others is spying, which … has forbidden by saying: “Do not spy” (Sura 49:12), meaning to look for the shameful points of Muslims. • “If you search for people’s shameful points, you corrupt them…” al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller, p. 759

42. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Asking About Another’s Mistakes • “…do not slander people, and do not ferret out people’s shameful points. • “Whoever searches out the shameful points of his brother, Allah will search out his own shameful points, be sure that He will disgrace him even if he should remain in the middle of his house.” • al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller, p. 759

43. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Searching Out a Persons Faults • Asking about and searching out the faults of others is spying, which … has forbidden by saying: “Do not spy” (Sura 49:12), meaning to look for shameful points of Muslims. • “If you search for people’s shameful points, you corrupt them…” • “do not slander people, and do not ferret out people’s shameful points.” [1] al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller,p. 759

44. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Rejecting a Brother’s Excuse • “When someone offers an excuse to his fellow Muslim and the latter does not accept it, his sin is like the crime of imposing taxes.” • By way of comparison, “He who imposes taxes resembles a highwayman, and is worse than a thief.” • al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller,p. 763, 674

45. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Revealing a Secret • “When a man says something. Then glances left or right, his words are a confidence to be kept.” • “Telling a secret means to inform others of a remark, action, or state which one learns of from someone who wants to remain hidden, whether it be good or bad. This is hurting him, and hurting others is unlawful. • When two people meet, it is obligatory to keep secret any act that occurs, any word spoken, or any state attributable to someone, when these concern something one would normally wish to remain confidential, while not being unlawful. al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller,p. 771-772

46. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Revealing a Secret • If it is against Allah Most High alone and does not involve legal measures such as prescribed legal penalties or disciplinary action, then it must be kept secret. • If it involves legal measure, as do fornication and drinking, then one has a choice between revealing it or not, though it is superior to conceal it. al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller,p. 771-772

47. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Revealing a Secret • If it involves another person’s rights, then if concealing it entails harm to anyone, or if it concerns prescribed legal measures such as retaliation for an injury or death, or covering the cost of an article destroyed through negligence, then if the person whose rights have been infringed is ignorant of it, one is obliged to make the matter known, and must testify to it if asked to. al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller,p. 771-772

48. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Revealing a Secret • If it involves another’s rights, but concealing it does not entail harm to anyone and it does not concern prescribed legal measures, or it entails one of these two, but the person concerned already knows of it through another and one has not been asked to testify about it, then one is obliged to conceal the matter.” al-Misri, Reliance of the Traveller,p. 771-772

49. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS • Summary • The above mentioned provisions have a direct and negative influence on interviews, interrogationsand the collection of evidence.

50. THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC LAW ON INTELLIGENCE AND LAW ENFORCEMENT INVESTIGATIONS Discussion