1 / 11

Learning Objective

Learning Objective. To know and understand the weaknesses of virtue ethics. Key words Ancient values Prohibitive Judgement. Key question What is a virtue?. O ne : Non-normative.

bayle
Download Presentation

Learning Objective

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Learning Objective • To know and understand the weaknesses of virtue ethics Key words Ancient values Prohibitive Judgement Key question What is a virtue?

  2. One : Non-normative • One of the strengths is its weakness. Virtue theory does not give you a list of prohibitive acts nor does it give you a method of formulating such a list. • Therefore, how do you punish people who act immorally? • Virtue ethics claims to be interested in the society but how can a society develop when there are no rules?

  3. Two : Ancient Values • Are ancient values really applicable today? • Can we really apply Aristotle today? • Ancient civilisations were very different from our own. What was good for them might not necessarily be good for us? • Even with the additions of Aquinas are these religious virtues relevant to today’s society? • Examples.

  4. “All paid jobs absorb and degrade the mind.” Two : Ancient Values • As well as these virtues not being applicable it may be that this structure is not possible for the modern age. • Life is not geared towards the contemplative mind. • We have to work and if we can never achieve virtue if we work then what is the point?

  5. Three : Judgement • Virtue theory creates real problems for judgement of people. • If there are four types of people surely the person who acts immoral by accident whilst trying to be virtuous is better than the person who is not trying at all. • If this is the case how do we know they are trying to act virtuously? • It is difficult to decide who is virtuous, as external acts that appear virtuous on the outside may have doubtful inner motives which cannot be perceived and vice-versa.

  6. Three : Judgement • This links to the complaint of non-normativity. • How can you create a society where there are rules and government if there is no set rules on how to live?

  7. Four : Foot • Using virtue ethics you are supposed to aim you life towards the greatest good. A sense of personal flourishing. • My wisdom should benefits both myself and others with whom I have dealings. • However, in cases of charity and justice it may be that I must sacrifice my own interests for those of others. • I may have to give up luxuries so that the basic needs of others can be met.

  8. Four : Foot • Sometimes the right thing for me is not the good for me. • There seem to be situations where there is an absolute sense of goodness. • In which there is always a correct sense of morality. • This refutes Aristotle’s claim that goodness is dependent on humanity.

  9. FIVE : ELITIST • Virtue ethics can be considered quite elitist. • Aristotle claims that a person who does not have a formal education can never reach true morality. • This is because they have not been educated in the virtues. • It is also because they have not had the correct character building experiences

  10. FIVE : ELITIST • It seems that this is not quite true. • it seems wrong that just because someone is uneducated and poor that they cannot be moral. • These people in order to make a moral action will have to overcome a stronger moral dilemma and surely this should be credited.

  11. Weaknesses Overview • Non-normative • Ancient values • Judgement • Foot • ELITIST

More Related