1 / 31

Introduction to WG syntax

Word-word relations are concepts. Introduction to WG syntax. Richard Hudson Joensuu November 2010. The challenge. How to go beyond single words to combinations of words to general patterns This is the domain of syntax the study of how words combine including general rules.

Download Presentation

Introduction to WG syntax

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Word-word relations are concepts Introduction to WG syntax Richard Hudson Joensuu November 2010

  2. The challenge • How to go beyond single words • to combinations of words • to general patterns • This is the domain of syntax • the study of how words combine • including general rules

  3. Influences on Word Grammar syntax • Tesnière (France, 1893-1954) • dependency structure, not phrase structure • Halliday (UK, 1925-) • labeled grammatical functions • Chomsky (USA, 1928-) • abstract structures

  4. An example Try using dependency structures! object subject pre- adjunct predic- ative [you] subject

  5. Dependency grammar • History • Panini (350 BC) • Arabic grammarians (700s+) • Some traditional school grammar (1800s) • Russia (e.g. Mel’cuk) • Germany (e.g. Kunze) • Finland (e.g. Karlsson)

  6. Why not phrase structure? • Basic assumption of PS: • We cannot relate words directly to each other. • Why not? • What about other areas of thought? • Social relations: we relate people to each other. • Spatial relations: we relate objects to each other.

  7. My family network me Gretta John father mother mother father brother Gaynor Colin daughter daughter grandson Lucy Alice son Peter

  8. Relations in WG • Relations are classified • ‘mother’, ‘son’, etc. • Each relation is a concept • just like entities such as ‘dog’ or ‘running’ • but relations have an ‘argument’ and a ‘value’ • Similarly, we classify dependencies • ‘subject’, ‘adjunct’, etc. • Traditional 'grammatical functions'.

  9. Generalising in syntax • Words are classified by word classes • Dependencies are classified by functions • Each of these classifications forms a taxonomy • a hierarchy of increasingly specific categories

  10. The word-class taxonomy word verb adjective …. noun auxiliary common BIG CAN DOG

  11. Generalising in a network • A 'rule' is a property applied by inheritance • e.g. 'A word has a meaning' • Rules are more or less general, but combine freely by inheritance • A verb has a subject • TAKE has an object • So: takes has a subject and an object • and a meaning

  12. The grammatical-function hierarchy dependent valent adjunct subject complement object predicative

  13. Generalising across dependencies • Again, rules may be more or less general • a word stands before its dependents • a verb stands after its subject • an interrogative auxiliary verb stands before its subject. • Thanks to default inheritance, the most specific rule always wins. • In other words, rules have exceptions.

  14. Abstractrelations in syntax • Syntax is abstract! • Dependencies are very abstract • defined by many different properties • Dependencies can also be complex • One word may depend on many others. • Mutual dependency is possible.

  15. A complex syntactic network What did you say? extractee predicative subject subject complement extractee & object

  16. Simple syntax a book about the idea of a life after death

  17. Abstract words in syntax • Maybe a complete analysis should recognise abstract, unrealised, words? • E.g. [you] as the subject of an imperative? • Why not, if words are concepts? • We have a concept for 'Superman' • But we also know he doesn't exist • Similarly for the realisation of [you].

  18. Researching syntax Here too, networks are everywhere. • Inside syntax • What about constructions? • Between syntax and morphology • Between syntax and semantics • Between syntax and sociolinguistics • Between syntax and psycholinguistics • Between syntax and education

  19. Constructions are dependency networks

  20. Researching syntax and morphology • Syntactic words are realized by morphological structures • e.g. 'WALK, past' realized by {{walk}{ed}} • Words usually have their own morphology. • But clitics are different • e.g. for 'YOU' + 'BE, present': {{you}{'re}}

  21. French pronouns Paul mange la pomme apple P eats the {mange}} {Paul} {mange} {pomme} {Paul} { {la}

  22. Researching syntax and semantics • Each word token inherits a sense • e.g. 'dog', 'eating', 'in' • But this sense is modified by the dependents • e.g. 'big dog', 'eating breakfast', 'in bed' • Exactly how do dependents modify senses?

  23. Simple syntax, complex meaning then < now me eating breakfast then I ate breakfast. me eating breakfast eating breakfast speaker breakfast eating

  24. Researching syntax and sociolinguistics • Syntactic patterns may have social meaning • Professor Hudson ~ Dick ~ Dad ~ Grandpa • he is ~ he's • which I live in ~ in which I live • we were ~ we was • I didn't do anything ~ I didn't do nothing. • How does syntax relate to social context?

  25. Inherent variability speaker local person • we was BE, past educated person speaker • we were

  26. Researching syntax and psycholinguistics • Syntactic structure influences processing • Some structures are harder than others • That Finland has the best schools in the world is generally agreed. • Simpler but harder • It is generally agreed that Finland has the best schools in the world. • More complex but easier

  27. Extraposition 8 words That Finland has the best schools in the world is certain. 1 word It is certain that Finland has the best schools in the world.

  28. Researching syntax and education • Our syntactic knowledge grows all through life: • new constructions • Try as he might, he couldn't open it. • new details of existing constructions • possibility of, opportunity to • Much of this growth happens at school.

  29. Subordinate clauses per 100 words:influence of age and grade

  30. Research questions for education • What causes growth in syntax? • general cognitive growth, e.g. memory • growth in the language network • Can grammatical analysis improve writing? • Yes! • recent research by Debra Myhill • How can teachers help?

  31. Kiitos • This slideshow can be downloaded from www.phon.ucl.ac.uk/home/dick/talks.htm • For more on Word Grammar, see www.phon.ucl.ac.uk/home/dick/wg.htm • My home page, with email address: www.phon.ucl.ac.uk/home/dick/home.htm

More Related