1 / 27

Problem Based Learning: A Case Study

Problem Based Learning: A Case Study. Presented by: Deana Halonen Ph.D. Candidate, M.S.W., H.B.S.W halonen@cc.umanitoba.ca. Agenda. Problem Based Learning (PBL) Characteristics Basic Steps Advantages Limitations The Case Study Major Findings Students Perceptions.

albert
Download Presentation

Problem Based Learning: A Case Study

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Problem Based Learning: A Case Study Presented by: Deana Halonen Ph.D. Candidate, M.S.W., H.B.S.W halonen@cc.umanitoba.ca

  2. Agenda • Problem Based Learning (PBL) • Characteristics • Basic Steps • Advantages • Limitations • The Case Study • Major Findings • Students Perceptions

  3. Problem Based Learning (PBL) • Began in 1950’s as a movement to restructure medical education at McMaster University (Canada) • Unlike traditional instruction that culminates in a problem after basic instruction on facts and skills (sometimes in the form of a test or exam), PBL begins with a problem, teaching facts and skills in a relevant context

  4. Characteristics of Problem Based Learning • Requires students to solve authentic, real-life open-ended problems with many correct answers possible • Authentic problems are those real-life issues faced by doctors, nurses, social workers, police officers, lawyers, engineers, business administrators, pilots, etc., etc., etc.

  5. Characteristics of PBL • Emphasizes students’ pre-existing knowledge; “start with what you know” • Students actively participate by helping plan, organize, and evaluate the problem solving process • Interdisciplinary connections stressed • Students undertake authentic roles

  6. Basic Steps of Problem Based Learning • Students divided into groups • Real problem is presented and discussed • Students identify • What is known in relation to the problem • What information is needed • What strategies or next steps to take in order to “learn” the information/knowledge/skills needed • Individuals research different issues, gather resources

  7. Basic Steps of PBL (con’t) • Resources evaluated in group and new information/knowledge/skills shared/taught to rest of the group • Cycle repeats until students feel that problem has been framed adequately and all issues have been addressed • Possible actions, recommendations, solutions or hypotheses are generated • Tutor groups conduct peer/self assessments

  8. Facilitators and Problem Based Learning • Teachers are seen as the “facilitator” and are key to these learning environments • Model higher-order process skills • Probe for student understanding • Never identify issues or state an opinion while students are framing the problems

  9. Advantages of Problem Based Learning • Greater retention and recall of knowledge • Interdisciplinary: • can require accessing and using information from a variety of subject domains; • Better integration of knowledge • Integration of classroom & field • Development of life-long learning skills • How to research • How to communicate in groups • How to handle problems

  10. Advantages of PBL • Learning environment that is • Active • Cooperative • Self & peer assessed • Student centred • Highly effective • Learning environment that provides • Prompt feedback • Opportunities to account for personal learning preferences & multiple intelligences • Opportunities to allow for a variety of levels of learning

  11. Advantages of PBL • Learning environment that enhances critical thinking and problem solving skills • Greatest strength of PBL is: • Increased motivation • Increased student satisfaction • Increased Student-student interaction • Increased Student-instructor interaction

  12. Limitations of Problem Based Learning • Requires significant pre-planning and development of • Authentic problems, cases, situations • Resources available for students • Literature • Resource people • Professionals in the field • Requires an authentic commitment and willingness to honor the knowledge, experience & skills that students bring to the learning experience

  13. Limitations of PBL • Requires a change of Paradigms • A shift of focus from what faculty teach to what students learn • A view of the Instructor as facilitator of the learning as opposed to “the one expert” whose role is to “bank knowledge” (Friere) through lectures or classroom demonstrations

  14. Resources & References • Problem-based learning, especially in the context of large classes Available online at http://www.chemeng.mcmaster.ca/pbl/pbl.htm • Stepien, Senn & Stepien (2000) The Internet and Problem-Based Learning: Developing Solutions through the web • Rankin (1999) Handbook on Problem-Based Learning Challis Resource Centre • Duch, Groh & Allen (2001) The Power of Problem-based Learning: A practical ‘how to’ for teaching undergraduate courses in any discipline

  15. The Problem • Imagine you are at the end of a phone line with a group of students who are situated throughout a region, province, Canada, possibly beyond. It is a 3 hour class and you know that while students can hear you, they can’t see you or each other. • You have no idea if someone is chatting, has gone to the washroom, is reading the newspaper, making the weekly shopping list, or even left class for the day. • You want to ensure that students are connecting with the material, connecting with you (the Instructor), connecting with each other and connecting with the institution. • You know that students report general dissatisfaction with ‘distance education’ and learning at a distance from their instructors.

  16. The Case Study • How does Problem Based Teaching affect student satisfaction in Social Work courses delivered through virtual audioconferenced Distance Education classrooms?

  17. Methodology • Within a group of students enrolled in a 2 year dual diploma program, Instructor/Researcher taught 4 (3 credit hour) courses: • 2 for 1st year students: 1 using PBL & 1 using Lecture Based Teaching • 2 for 2nd year student: 1 using PBL & 1 using Lecture Based Teaching

  18. Data • Throughout the term, all students were required to maintain a journal and reflect on: • What they were learning • How they were learning it • How they knew they were learning it • How would they demonstrate that they were learning it

  19. Data (2) • Some classes were audio-taped • Some classes were video-taped • In the first ½ of the course • In the second ½ of the course • Instructor/Researcher maintained a journal recording the classroom learning activities that students engaged in • Researcher/Instructor maintained a journal recording students reactions and levels of participation in the classroom learning activities

  20. Data (3) • At the beginning of the term, all students were provided with an explanation about the research and asked to complete a sheet of paper and indicate whether or not they would participate in the research project. The sheet of paper was then placed in a sealed envelope and mailed to an independent third party • Since all students filled in the form, no one was able to tell who chose to participate and who chose not to participate, including the Instructor/Researcher • Once all evaluation was completed and Final Grades were submitted to the Registrar, the Independent third party released the signed sheets of paper to the Researcher/Instructor

  21. Data (4) • One to one or focus group interviews were held with those students who had consented to participate in the research project • Data was gathered on: • The student’s experience and their perception of: • Level of learning in PBL & Lecture courses • Level of satisfaction with PBL & Lecture courses • Level of participation in PBL & Lecture courses • What they were doing differently in PBL & Lecture courses

  22. Findings • The Students • 59 in 4 courses >19 Year 1 & 22 Year 2 > 14 agreed to participate • 12 of the sample were female & 2 were male • Physically located in 8 different communities • 7 in Northwestern Ontario • 1 in Northeastern Ontario • Grade Point Average ranged from 2.96 to 4.0 with average being 3.4

  23. Final Grades (cf)

  24. Major Findings • Retention Rate was 100% • Actively engaged • Satisfaction • Participation • Collaboration • Learning • Construction of Knowledge • Application of knowledge • Retain Knowledge

  25. Students Perceptions • Stimulating • Humane • Challenging • Exchange with others • Resources

  26. Students Perceptions • What were they doing differently?

More Related