1 / 23

Challenging and Supporting First-Year Students

Challenging and Supporting First-Year Students. Betsy Barefoot, EdD STAR Conference University of Ulster June 14, 2007. A Trip Back in Time. Betsy Duke University - 1962 A thoroughly average experience Surviving, not thriving. John

Download Presentation

Challenging and Supporting First-Year Students

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.


Presentation Transcript

  1. Challenging and Supporting First-Year Students Betsy Barefoot, EdD STAR Conference University of Ulster June 14, 2007

  2. A Trip Back in Time Betsy Duke University - 1962 A thoroughly average experience Surviving, not thriving John Marietta College-1961 A thoroughly less-than average experience Barely surviving

  3. “Look to the Right, Look to the Left”

  4. Major Changes in Higher Education • Our views about retention • Our commitment to access • Students “new” to the higher education experience

  5. Our Challenges • Converting access to success • Meeting the needs of different students • Confronting a lack of respect for student support work

  6. Our Challenges • Confronting the remaining sink or swim attitudes • The ultimate sink-or-swim experience: the “mega first-year classroom”

  7. Our Challenges • Dealing with the downward spiral of our negative expectations • Reverting to “chalk and talk” • Giving minimal assignments • Rewarding minimal effort

  8. The Non-Aggression Treaty Don’t ask too much of me, and I won’t expect too much of you.

  9. And yet another challenge – helicopter parents

  10. Finding Solutions • Assuming more responsibility for student success • No more sink or swim – now we use life preservers or preemptive “water wings”

  11. Three Strategies for Rescuing Students • Supplemental Instruction • Learning Communities • First-Year Seminars

  12. Supplemental Instruction • Targets high-risk courses, not high-risk students • Offers a supplemental class facilitated by expert upper-level student • Voluntary or required • Outcomes – improved grade point averages and retention; more in-class time to cover content.

  13. Learning Communities • Two, three, or four courses linked across the curriculum • Single cohort of students participates in each class • Sometimes includes a first-year seminar • Sometimes is linked with residential living • Outcomes include improved retention and better understanding of the connectedness of knowledge

  14. First-Year Seminars • Offered by over 90% of US colleges and universities • Link with improved retention • Characteristics • Small class sections (<25 students) • Providing “basic training” for students

  15. First-Year Seminar Variations • Seminar types • Extended orientation, student success courses • Courses on unique academic themes • Courses linked to academic or professional disciplines • Remedial, “basic study skills” courses

  16. First-Year Seminars • Different modes of administration • Taught by instructors and student support staff • Some required, some “elective” • Use of upper-level students as “peer leaders” or co-teachers for the course • Contact hours: from 1 to 3 per week

  17. Content vs. Process: Process Is Key • Highly interactive classroom environment • Students are encouraged to speak out and to share • Atmosphere of self-disclosure • But – they still include significant challenge • Over 90% carry academic credit

  18. The Comings and Goings of First-Year Seminars • Every year brings the creation of new seminars and the occasional demise of old ones • Seminars are vulnerable to the perception of being “fluff” • Seminars are vulnerable to administrative changes • The importance of assessment • The continual search for the ideal seminar

  19. The Big Idea Behind First-Year Interventions Making the large institutional environment seem small However, as interventions increase in numbers . . . • Problems of quality control • The antidote problem: interventions can’t compensate for dysfunctional environments

  20. The First Year as a Comprehensive System • Philosophy/Purpose • Organization • Learning • Essential role of instructors • Focus on transitions • Service to all students • Exploration of diversity • Introduction of higher education’s roles and purposes • Assessment/Improvement

  21. Concluding Observations • The first year IS important. • ALL students need support. • Upper-level students are a great resource for the first year. • First-year students need a better understanding of the relevance of courses and activities to their present and future lives. • Recognize the first year as a complex system.

  22. Finally . . . • If you could start from scratch and create a system of higher education focused on student learning in the first year • What would it look like? • Who would deliver knowledge? • What structures or techniques would you use? • How would you measure learning? • How can we effectively balance challenge and support? • What can we do to make the system we have more like the system we want?

  23. Contact Information Betsy Barefoot, EdD Co-Director & Senior Scholar Policy Center on the First Year of College Brevard, NC 28712 barefoot@fyfoundations.org www.fyfoundations.org www.firstyear.org

More Related