1 / 23

ANTH 1013 Week 7 Chapter 6: Anthropological Explanations and Chapter 7: Analysing Sociocultural Systems

ANTH 1013 Week 7 Chapter 6: Anthropological Explanations and Chapter 7: Analysing Sociocultural Systems. Steward in retrospect. Cultural ecologist accused of environmental determinism Civilizations in Americas, Asia, Africa evolve in similar econiches,

Philip
Download Presentation

ANTH 1013 Week 7 Chapter 6: Anthropological Explanations and Chapter 7: Analysing Sociocultural Systems

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. ANTH 1013Week 7 Chapter 6:Anthropological Explanationsand Chapter 7:Analysing Sociocultural Systems

  2. Steward in retrospect • Cultural ecologist accused of environmental determinism • Civilizations in Americas, Asia, Africa evolve in similar econiches, • e.g., dry river valleys modified by irrigation • Environmental determinism vs possibilism • Too idealistic?: some adaptations are mal- • Steward and White’s environmental determinism on culture parallels Mead and Benedict’s cultural determinism on personality (mid 20th century) • Advocate of multilinear evolution

  3. Cultural Materialism: Marvin Harris • Based on neoevolutionism and cultural ecology • Sociocultural systems divided into: • Infrastructure (technology, subsistence strategy) • Structure (sociopolitical system) • Superstructure (intangibles of culture, ideas) • Infrastructure is prime determinant of other two • Ignores social, political, religious beliefs? • Technological determinism or possibilism? • Downplays symbolism and language

  4. Harris’ Cultural Materialism: Ahimsa • Killing cows illegal in India • Ghandi: “central fact of Hinduism is cow protection” • Vedic culture, 1800-800 BC, northern India • Herds of cattle as wealth of chieftans • Communal feasts of beef on special occasions • Population grew, grazing lands plowed, forests shrank • Cattle inefficient consumers of feed - compete w. people • Brahman priests and rulers continued to eat beef • Resentment and unrest by 600 BC • Buddhism appears ca 500 BC - banned killing of animals • Also Jainism: against killing even bugs • Brahmans co-opt Buddhist respect for life doctrine as Hindu practice of Ahimsa

  5. Harris’ Cultural Materialism: Ahimsa (cont.) • Materialist justification for Ahimsa • Zebu cattle feed on scraps, no competition with people • Zebus drought and disease resistant • 12 year life as draft animals for plowing • Cattle cheaper than tractors for small farms • Produce milk • Dung for fertilizer and fuel • Zebus worth more alive than dead • Case for practicality of Ahimsa based on: • cultural ecology (Steward) • energy relationships (White)

  6. Marxist anthropology • Modified Morgan’s unilineal scheme: • Tribal, Asiatic, feudal, capitalism, communism • Materialist: mode of production is prime determinant of social, political, religious life • Believed class struggle unending • Capitalists vs proletariat • Social context: exploitation of workers during Industrial Revolution

  7. Symbolic Anthropology • Humanistic approach • Argues cultural symbols can be independent of material factors, e.g., trucker hats • Collect data on kinship, ritual, myth, values • Interpret these from perspective of people studied • Produce “thick description” to explain the internal logic of a culture for outsiders • May neglect historical, political, materialist factors • Symbolic determinism?

  8. Sociobiology • Developed by E. O. Wilson, 1970’s • Focus on biological basis for social behaviour • Assumes innate predispositions for behaviour a consequence of natural selection • Predicts men are more promiscuous than women • Limited # of eggs vs unlimited # of sperm • 9 months + 3 yrs breastfeeding per child • Women naturally more selective of mates • Inclusive fitness basis for family ties • Protect kin, they protect you • Kin selection causes nepotism • Critics cite lack of biological basis in some kin categories • Offensive to anthropologists who see enculturation as dominant in nature vs nurture debate • Enculturation can override innate tendencies

  9. Feminist Anthropology • Pre-WW II, Mead popularizes anthropology • Redbook column • First to focus on gender roles • Questioned biological determinism re gender differences • Male anthropologists tended to focus on male informants; yielded biased ethnographies • Women’s Liberation movement in early ‘70’s • More female anthropologists • Critiqued sociobiological theories of gender difference • Downplayed biological and behavioural differences

  10. Postmodernism and Anthropology • Question objectivity of ethnographers and validity of old field methods • Demand ethnographers acknowledge their biases • Formerly marginal cultures now in mainstream • Access to education • Internet • Can tell their own stories, ethnographers redundant • Impact on anthropology • Self-reflection now common in ethnographies • Team approach to ethnography predicted

  11. Chapter 7: Analysing Sociocultural Systems • Introduction to ethnographic field methods • Examine cultural universals and variables • Subsistence and physical environment • Demography • Technology • Economy • Social structure • Political organization • Religion

  12. Ethnographic field methods • Devise research design • Identify research objectives • Describe schedule, methods to be used • Background studies • Archival data (images, documents, maps, notes) • Read published work on • Anthropology • Ecology • History • Economics • Political science • Obtain research permit from country of study

  13. Ethnographic research strategies • Participant observation • Learn language • Stay at least a year • Naturalistic observation • Mapping anthropogenic features • Dwellings • Gardens • Trails, roads • Mappping environmental features • Rivers, streams • Topography, soil types • Natural vegetation • Climate • Recording daily activities of people in community

  14. Ethnographic research strategies (cont.) • Time-allocation analysis • How many hours spent on different activities each day • E.g.: eating 2 hrs; attending class 5 hrs; reading 2 hrs; writing; 2 hrs; physical recreation 2 hrs; sleep 8 hrs • Record for different age groups and genders • Develop relationship with key informant • Makes introductions, provides information and advice • Unstructured interviews • Spontaneous, open-ended conversations • Avoid leading questions

  15. Ethnographic research strategies (cont.) • Structured interviews • Ask same questions to many people • Cross-checking makes data more reliable • Craft questions carefully for best results • May submit questionnaire to random sample of pop. • Etic perspective • Gather quantitative data • Outsider’s perspective • Emic perspective • Qualitative data • Insider’s perspective

  16. Ethnographic research strategies (cont.) • Take field notes • Use waterproof paper and pencil • Laptop with database program to help organize notes • Tape recorders • Still photographs • Video cameras • Risk getting “performance” not reality • Useful for re-interpretation later • Surviving culture shock • Loneliness • Anti-malarial medication can cause panic attacks • Adopting diet of subjects can be challenging • Consumption of drugs/alcohol, e.g., in Amazon

  17. Ethnographic research strategies (cont.) • Ethics • Must not let incriminating details get into wrong hands • Can use pseudonyms to protect informants • But this invites falsification of data • Anthropologists have acted as spies (WW II) • Must reveal motives to culture under study • Not supposed to try to change culture under study • Supposed to resist sexual involvement with subjects

  18. Ethnographic research strategies (cont.) • Correlation is interaction of two variables • Causal or spurious relationship? • Independent variable affects dependent variable • E.g., population increase causes increased warfare • Interconnectedness of cultural variables makes assigning “dependent” or “independent” tricky • Multidimensional approach needed • Flows from holistic approach

  19. Cultural Universals and Variables: 1. Subsistence and Physical Environment • Modern cultural ecology • Humans adapt to environmental niches in biomes • E.g., head of tide on river in temperate deciduous forest • Subsistence patterns • Develop as adaptations to biome parameters • Foraging • Horticulture • Pastoralism • Agriculture

  20. Cultural Universals and Variables: 2. Demography • Mainly quantitative data from censuses and surveys indicating population trends in society • Three variables: fertility, mortality, migration • Fertility (number of births) • Crude birth rate = number of live births annually per 1000 people • Mortality • Crude death rate = number of deaths annually per 1000 people

  21. 2. Demography (cont.) • Migration rate • In-migrants - out-migrants = net migration • Natural growth rate = CBR-CDR • Factor in net migration to determine total population change • Other demographic variables • Fecundity (potential # of births based on women stats) • Life expectancy • Infant mortality rate (# of babies /1000 that die before 1) • Child mortality rate (# of children /1000 that die before age 5)

  22. 2. Demography (cont.) • Push factors induce people to leave • Drought, warfare, poverty • Pull factors induce people to in-migrate • Economic opportunity, religious tolerance • Carrying capacity • Maximum population that an environment can support • Influenced by technology, e.g. food production • Cultural values and practices affect demography • Attitudes towards birth control vary

  23. Cultural Universals and Variables: 3. Technology • Broader meaning than in popular usage • Tools and knowledge humans apply to solve practical problems like subsistence and shelter • Material culture: goods (e.g., scissors) • Nonmaterial culture: services (e.g., haircut) • Role of technology in social change still debated • For next week: read Ch 6 & 7: TEST III

More Related