1 / 20

Capturing SME input

The Range of Decision Making Techniques. Considerations when selecting a technique

Olivia
Download Presentation

Capturing SME input

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

    2. Operational Testing Field System Test – Very Expensive and Time ConsumingOperational Testing Field System Test – Very Expensive and Time Consuming

    6. Disadvantage …doesn’t show correlation values…A>B, B>C….C<A ???? Disadvantage …doesn’t show correlation values…A>B, B>C….C<A ????

    7. Capturing SME input Participants will be asked to evaluate criteria through a series of pairwise comparisons, which calculates each factor’s relative importance. To capture these comparisons, each participant uses a remote control to assign a number (1-9) that reflects the relative weight or importance of each decision factor. The discussion is criticalThe discussion is critical

    9. First thing was determining important of missions, then capabilities/tasks and then independently which resources mapped to tasks/missions….so if really important resource mapped to not so important tasks or missions…it will not be given a lot of weight……need to determine importance of mission and importance of resource then together both start to form a picture of what’s really important to accomplish mission. NEED TO CONSIDER SCALE…LEVELS IN CONTEXT OF LEVELS HIGHER IN THE HIERARCHY CAN QUICKLY EXPAND NUMBER OF INPUTS…INDEPENDENCE BETWEEN LEVELS MAKES NORMALIZING TO 100% POSSIBLE Different tools at each level First thing was determining important of missions, then capabilities/tasks and then independently which resources mapped to tasks/missions….so if really important resource mapped to not so important tasks or missions…it will not be given a lot of weight……need to determine importance of mission and importance of resource then together both start to form a picture of what’s really important to accomplish mission. NEED TO CONSIDER SCALE…LEVELS IN CONTEXT OF LEVELS HIGHER IN THE HIERARCHY CAN QUICKLY EXPAND NUMBER OF INPUTS…INDEPENDENCE BETWEEN LEVELS MAKES NORMALIZING TO 100% POSSIBLE Different tools at each level

    10. Relative Scoring Example

    12. Great Idea for coming up with unique scales where linear utility doesn’t capture “knee in the curve” Twinkie Example In practice..rarely usedGreat Idea for coming up with unique scales where linear utility doesn’t capture “knee in the curve” Twinkie Example In practice..rarely used

    14. Functional Analysis

    15. Models offer unique insights with “proof” save time, money ….can be reused….Models offer unique insights with “proof” save time, money ….can be reused….

    16. Results of Analysis 1. System B 2. System A 3. System C

    19. Operational Testing Field System Test – Very Expensive and Time ConsumingOperational Testing Field System Test – Very Expensive and Time Consuming

    20. Questions

More Related